Open 297 - Twofold Mafia (Game Over)

[don_johnson]

i'm confused. i have been accused in post 270. is post 272 the "anti-town behavior" to which you are referring? if so, please explain what is "anti-town" about responding to an iso that seems to be skewing some facts? also, please post your meta case, or at least some semblance of what you were thinking there. i would hate for you to just slide by without being held accountable for what you are saying...

[Chevre]

Vote Count

(6) IceGuy (

ThAdmiral

, Nikanor, andrew94, Mist7676, don_johnson,

Amrun

,

ThAdmiral

)
(2) Mist7676 (neko2086, Scott Brosius)
(2) Amrun (RICO ACT,

IceGuy

)
(1) andrew94 (

IceGuy

, ConSpiracy)
(1) don_johnson (

TheJakalope

,

TheJakalope

)
(0) TheJakalope (

Amrun

)
(0) Scott Brosius (

Amrun

)

(0) Not Voting ()

With

twelve

living players, it takes

seven

votes to lynch.

Deadline:

April 24th, 2011 9:11pm U.S. CST

Prodded:

RICO ACT

Replacing:

no one

[neko2086]

So Jackalope, is iceguy scum or not? Also, you were already voting don. Who did you think you were voting?

I'm inclined to agree with Scott. The problem is not so much that Mist is just arguing with herself, she's trying to ride both sides of the iceguy fence, and in the meantime taking potshots at don (ie 'there goes don again with his votes with no reason').

Amrun, if you're gunna say you think don is scum due to meta, you need to qualify that somehow.

Mod, I don't think Amrun is voting herself.

-Fixed. Thank you.

[andrew94]

@jackalope, looking at anyones iso ususally paints someone as scummy, especially if you looked at his iso with the thought of him being scum
nty, get on the iceguy wagon

[Amrun]

Don, I explained what was anti-town about your previous posts already. In essence, you're active lurking, not putting forth much effort, and not being totally transparent with your reads etc.

And if anyone would care to actually read what I wrote, I said that I had only skimmed his meta and would be doing a more in-depth investigation later.

[Mist7676]

Y was everyone saying hooray?

Don has been scummy as IceGuy had posted earlier. IceGuy has been scum hunting a bit which makes me want to unvote and vote don but not that much. My read on him is 60/40 with scum:town ratio.

[don_johnson]

amrun: which games of mine did you "skim"?

how many games of mine do you feel you would have to read in order to develop a "reliable" meta?

what, in particular, did you notice while skimming?

considering i am part of a voting bloc, i don't see the accusation of "active lurking". my votes are carrying a certain amount of pressure. i am questioning other players and answering questions directed at me. you have laid out an accusation against me, but you have failed to follow it up with any relevant questioning. in other words, you are mudslinging. you claimed to have reason to believe i am scum. please produce that reasoning. and do it quickly. the longer you take, the less i will be able to believe that you have done any "skimming" at all.

[don_johnson]

mist: to what does this-

Don has been scummy as IceGuy had posted earlier

refer? the only mention i can find is something about Ice questioning the motvies of a voting bloc. voting blocs are inherently pro-town by nature as they tend to help organize town votes. organization and cooperation is how town wins games, so even a voting bloc started by scum will generally tend to have a majority of town players in it and therefore serve as a valuable town resource. but this may be a theory discussion. in any case, please qualify your post.

[Mist7676]

Mistake I meant TheJakalope.

[ThAdmiral]

A wagon stall like this is more likely to happen on scum than town.

Just sayin'.

[TheJakalope]

Ok, a flip is what we need to get this game moving, and I have been having thoughts about iceguy looking scummy. Not my top candidate for being scum, but definitely up there, and with 4(?) scum in this game, that's good enough.

unvote

VOTE: Iceguy

[neko2086]

Oh ffs.

Jackalope--so you're OK doing that with one player completely absent. That's cool or whatever. You've still yet to say WHY you think ice is scummy, and what the hell do you mean by "4(?) scum"? Are you trying to play dumb now?

[Chevre]

Vote Count

(7) IceGuy (Nikanor, andrew94, Mist7676, don_johnson, Amrun, ThAdmiral,

TheJakalope

)
(2) Mist7676 (neko2086, Scott Brosius)
(2) Amrun (RICO ACT, IceGuy)
(1) andrew94 (ConSpiracy)
(0) don_johnson (

TheJakalope

)

(0) Not Voting ()

With

twelve

living players, it takes

seven

votes to lynch.

Deadline:

April 24th, 2011 9:11pm U.S. CST

Prodded:

RICO ACT

Replacing:

no one

IceGuy, a

Townie

, was lynched on Day 1.

It is now

Night 1

. The deadline is

April 20th, 2011 at 9:40pm U.S. CST

.

[Chevre]

Night One Results

Amrun, a

Townie

, was shot during Night One.
neko2086, a

Doctor

, was mauled to death during Night One.

It is now

Day 2

. The deadline is

May 8th, 2011 at 9:55pm U.S. CST

.

Vote Count

(9) Not Voting (andrew94, ConSpiracy, don_johnson, Mist7676, Nikanor, RICO ACT, Scott Brosius, ThAdmiral, TheJakalope)

With

nine

living players, it takes

five

votes to lynch.

Deadline:

May 8th, 2011 9:55pm U.S. CST

Prodded:

RICO ACT

Replacing:

RICO ACT

[Mist7676]

FIRST POST!

(anti-meme)

[Scott Brosius]

I sincerely doubt all 4 scum were on the wagon. Therefore knowing neko flipped town, that leaves RICO ACT and Conspiracy. Those two and Jackalope are my top scum reads at the moment.

[andrew94]

can you explain your rico act and conspiracy?

[ThAdmiral]

@ scott: makes sense. Out of those I would choose conspiracy. Jackalope seems to me noob-town, and rico act has hardly posted.

Of course there's also you. In fact you would probably be my second read.

vote: conspiracy

[Scott Brosius]

can you explain your rico act and conspiracy?

I did. It would be rare to see all 4 scum were on the wagon. I know I am town, we know neko, IceGuy are town. That leaves only 2 people off the wagon. RICO ACT and Conspiracy.

I am also more willing to lynch Conspiracy given that we have gotten absolutely nothing from the RICO slot.

[Nikanor]

So Scott, you've got two top reads. You've even said that your ConSpiracy read is stronger than your RICO read. That's great and all, but why aren't you voting for ConSpiracy?

[Mist7676]

It is possible for all scum to be on the wagon. Maybe about 20% chance. Scott is right about ConSpiracy and RICO. VOTE: Conspiracy if a replacement comes in lets see how they do before we finish this lynch.

[don_johnson]

vote RICO

No need to be hasty. Why anyone would be protecting a vacant slot is beyond me.

[Mist7676]

Because If a replacment comes in and does better than him we would regret it.

If ConSpiracy is mafia don is my day-3 vote.

[TheJakalope]

vote RICO

No need to be hasty. Why anyone would be protecting a vacant slot is beyond me.

We definitely need to wait for someone to replace before we start voting RICO, we have nothing Town or Scum to go off of.

[Scott Brosius]

Because If a replacment comes in and does better than him we would regret it.

If ConSpiracy is mafia don is my day-3 vote.

Wolf slip?

At this point I'm not putting Conspiracy at L-2 when half the game isn't here. Didn't initially vote as I wanted to reread Jack.