That was the extent of the case that chk was presenting against Sateal. It was a terribly weak vote, and it reads of chk trying to attack the attacker of a scumbud (chainsaw defense).chkflip wrote:UNVOTE: P.T.
VOTE: Satael
Way too interested in rushing the current wagon, amongst other scummy things they've done.
I agree, except I would at Satael to the list of town. He basically orchestrated the Pine lynch. That leaves:Nachomamma8 wrote:Vote: Cecily
She waffled on the Pine wagon yesterday A LOT, which suggests that she was unsure of which position to take on her scumbuddy's wagon. We go from Pine is an inevitable lynch and will die anyways here, to attacking havingfitz for rushing the wagon here. I find this a bit more damning that chkflip's play because he at least was consistent.
PT Barnum, havingfitz, and mike are pretty much confirmed town at this point.
Doesn't seem a great scum tactic to me ... Pine was looking very likely to be lynched, not sure that scum would want to put their head on the line by trying to slow down the wagon. Yeah agreed 100% on the weak vote though.Bub Bidderskins wrote:Vote: Chkflip
Now with the knowledge that Pine is scum, this post looks really bad:
That was the extent of the case that chk was presenting against Sateal. It was a terribly weak vote, and it reads of chk trying to attack the attacker of a scumbud (chainsaw defense).chkflip wrote:UNVOTE: P.T.
VOTE: Satael
Way too interested in rushing the current wagon, amongst other scummy things they've done.
@Chk: What made Satael's pushing of the pine wagon scummy at that time?
WIFOMmikemike778 wrote:Doesn't seem a great scum tactic to me ... Pine was looking very likely to be lynched, not sure that scum would want to put their head on the line by trying to slow down the wagon. Yeah agreed 100% on the weak vote though.Bub Bidderskins wrote:Vote: Chkflip
Now with the knowledge that Pine is scum, this post looks really bad:
That was the extent of the case that chk was presenting against Sateal. It was a terribly weak vote, and it reads of chk trying to attack the attacker of a scumbud (chainsaw defense).chkflip wrote:UNVOTE: P.T.
VOTE: Satael
Way too interested in rushing the current wagon, amongst other scummy things they've done.
@Chk: What made Satael's pushing of the pine wagon scummy at that time?
Who do you think is most likely chk's scum-bud?Cecily wrote:@Nacho if you'll read through the first post that you pulled of mine in the last sentence I state that while I know that Pine will be lynched and am totally for that I don't see the point in rushing a day that could prove helpful. And in this case it did prove helpful because everyone except for chk commented on Pine and then chk came in and accused the person who started the wagon. Setael's read was spot on and going against it was stupid on his part and indicates that he really didn't want to have to make up something about Pine.
Another point of evidence is the very last thing TO said about her FoS being chk. While her claiming her role was stupid no one would have believed her had the scum not lynched yesterday and the town would have jumped on her anyways, she straight called out chk and given how naive his play style has been otherwise I'd call it a very rookie NK and say that that is evidence enough for me.
vote: chkflip
Hang on a minute ... up to recently we were discussing how big the scum team was - now you seem to have decided that its a three man team to the extent you are doing your maths on workin out whether we are in Mylo. Do you know something we don't?Bub Bidderskins wrote:I agree, except I would at Satael to the list of town. He basically orchestrated the Pine lynch. That leaves:Nachomamma8 wrote:Vote: Cecily
She waffled on the Pine wagon yesterday A LOT, which suggests that she was unsure of which position to take on her scumbuddy's wagon. We go from Pine is an inevitable lynch and will die anyways here, to attacking havingfitz for rushing the wagon here. I find this a bit more damning that chkflip's play because he at least was consistent.
PT Barnum, havingfitz, and mike are pretty much confirmed town at this point.
Nacho
Chk
Cecily
Myself
I know I'm town, and I've got a town read on Nacho (pine's constant attacks on Pappums vouch for him). So that leaves Chk and Cecily as the remaining scum simply by the process of elimination, without even getting into the cases on those two.
I am assuming we have three mafia and that there were at least two on Void's lynch. Based on this assumption...that means FMPOV, at least one of these individuals -Nachomamma8, P.T. Barnum, chkflip, Bub Bidderskins- is scum.Rhinox wrote:Final Votecount of Day 1
Voidedmafia (7) - Nachomamma8, P.T. Barnum, chkflip, Bub Bidderskins,tarsonisocelot, Jahudo,Pine
Cecily (1) -havingfitz
havingfitz (2) - mikemike778, Idiotking
Nachomamma8 (3) -, CecilyVoidedmafia, neil1113
not voting (0):
Since Pine was so obviously the lynch target for the day...I would be extremely surprised if there was not at least one scumbuddy bussing him. Possibly two but I doubt it. I would guess there is at least one on his wagon and more than likely, one off it.Rhinox wrote:Final Votecount of Day 2
Pine (6) - P.T. Barnum, mikemike778,, Nachomamma8,tarsonisocelothavingfitz,Pine
neil1113 (1) - Bub Bidderskins
Setael (1) - chkflip
not voting (3): Cecily,, Setaelneil1113
Who do you think is scum, then?mikemike778 wrote:Hang on a minute ... up to recently we were discussing how big the scum team was - now you seem to have decided that its a three man team to the extent you are doing your maths on workin out whether we are in Mylo. Do you know something we don't?Bub Bidderskins wrote:I agree, except I would at Satael to the list of town. He basically orchestrated the Pine lynch. That leaves:Nachomamma8 wrote:Vote: Cecily
She waffled on the Pine wagon yesterday A LOT, which suggests that she was unsure of which position to take on her scumbuddy's wagon. We go from Pine is an inevitable lynch and will die anyways here, to attacking havingfitz for rushing the wagon here. I find this a bit more damning that chkflip's play because he at least was consistent.
PT Barnum, havingfitz, and mike are pretty much confirmed town at this point.
Nacho
Chk
Cecily
Myself
I know I'm town, and I've got a town read on Nacho (pine's constant attacks on Pappums vouch for him). So that leaves Chk and Cecily as the remaining scum simply by the process of elimination, without even getting into the cases on those two.
Anything Pine said on the scum team size is irrelevent.
Way too blinkered to be considering anyone as 'confirmed town' as well (applies to Nacho as well) . I actually have suspicions on PT still and am not prepared to 100% discount my Day 1 thoughts on Fitz when I was 100% sure he was scum.
I still find it incredibly scummy that you resorted to ad hom. It was a poor reason to call me out, and I definitely think it's more likely for scum to post what you did.PT Barnum wrote:How else should I have responded? Of course I was defensive, I was defending myself (I don't know what you mean by "uncharacteristically"). At my sounding "peeved" and calling setael an ass, well, I still think it was incredibly unfair for her to post a point that I thought I had already answered thoroughly without also mentioning my response to it.