Mini 1157 - Witch-Hunt Nightless - Game Over

[Caboose]

So, do you see how yours and Reck's list differ?

Do you find someone who casts an RVS vote after they clearly recognize that it's not RVS any longer scummy?

No, unless we're in a newbie game.

When did we start using static scumtells?

[Kise]

I'm starting to get the feeling that SH is scum and his partners plan to use him as a scapegoat to "clear" themselves. That's punishment for calling me town though, ain't it?....In fact that'd be a damn good plan in a nightless vt/goon game.... Who am I kidding, I've already been rolecopped. -_-''

[Kise]

Parama is off the scumlist..

[Parama]

I miss the days when Scumhunter posted in this thread


>flake under pressure
QFT

[DemonHybrid]

So, do you see how yours and Reck's list differ?

Not really.

Is lurking a 100% scum tell?

I understand your argument, but Reck's scum list and my scum list are not entirely different. And regardless, it's beside the point.

Why is SH's vote not scummy to you?

[Scumhunter]

Parama, the reason I don't post more is because you guys annoy me. Your "certainty" that I am scum is ridiculous. I don't see mafia tunneling as hard as you are, but I get the feeling that nothing I can say will satisfy your reactionary fos. Go ahead, overreact, lynch me, its all good. But I am telling you I am town and that you are making a mistake. After that, what more can I do? What I will say to everyone is to please think more about lynches in the future. I'd suspect at least 2 mafia are voting me right now. I mean 5 votes. What am I even being suspected for again? Random voting a couple pages into a d1 day start?

[Ythan]

Vote Count

4 Scumhunter (Parama, DemonHybrid, Nachomamma8, xRECKONERx) L-3
2 DemonHybrid (Caboose, Kise)
2 Parama (brundibar, splitfarvle)
2 splitfarvle (Scumhunter, dramonic)
1 Caboose (pycyununn)
1 brundibar (Trouble)
0 Nachomamma8
0 Trouble
0 Kise
0 dramonic
0 pycyununn
0 xRECKONERx

0 Not Voting

7 to lynch

Deadline May 4th

[DemonHybrid]

Parama, the reason I don't post more is because you guys annoy me. Your "certainty" that I am scum is ridiculous. I don't see mafia tunneling as hard as you are, but I get the feeling that nothing I can say will satisfy your reactionary fos. Go ahead, overreact, lynch me, its all good. But I am telling you I am town and that you are making a mistake. After that, what more can I do? What I will say to everyone is to please think more about lynches in the future. I'd suspect at least 2 mafia are voting me right now. I mean 5 votes. What am I even being suspected for again? Random voting a couple pages into a d1 day start?

I'm voting you because you voted Parama for a non-RVS reason, failed to explain in detail what that reason was, and then voted brundibar for absolutely no reason afterwards.

And all you seem to be doing is "I'm totally town, what else can I say?"

Well, a whole hell of a lot. That's what you can say. Especially at this point in the game. You aren't hunting for scum. You aren't defending yourself properly. You're just sitting around complaining while doing fuck-all.

I thought that the reasons for the suspicion on you would be obvious.

[Scumhunter]

My vote on Parama wasn't serious, which I immediately admitted. It was, as I have already pointed out, a way to voice my displeasure with his vote on Kise. If I had known L-6 votes were going to be taken so seriously maybe I would have explained that the only vote to judge me on is the one I make at the end of the day.

[Parama]

wall of AtE

*snore*

[DemonHybrid]

unvote, vote: Kise

better lynch.

This is a scum tell.

Scumhunting 101. Great success!

[Ythan]

Pycyunnun and splitfarvle have been prodded.

[DemonHybrid]

unvote, vote: Kise

better lynch.

This is a scum tell.

Scumhunting 101. Great success!

Anyway, SH, according to your logic, this was completely made up and fabricated and not serious, right?

I want you hung.

[Scumhunter]

WHAT IS SO HARD TO UNDERSTAND. I HAD A SMALL TOWN READ ON KISE SO MY POST WAS A WAY TO SHOW THAT. ITS LIKE IM TALKING TO A BRICK WALL HERE. SAME SIMPLE EXPLANATIONS OVER AND OVER

[DemonHybrid]

WHAT IS SO HARD TO UNDERSTAND. I HAD A SMALL TOWN READ ON KISE SO MY POST WAS A WAY TO SHOW THAT. ITS LIKE IM TALKING TO A BRICK WALL HERE. SAME SIMPLE EXPLANATIONS OVER AND OVER

And did you have "a small scum read" (or more) on Parama?

[Scumhunter]

Its called voting based on a frivolous reason for a reaction. You know the way scumhunting works on day 1. It was what 3 pages into the game at most so no votes actually mean much. Was my vote a "lynch lynch lynch Parama" no. Was it a "HEY, what r u doin? derp derp?" Yes.

[DemonHybrid]

You didn't really scum tell (Although voting Kise is fail at best)

I missed this small little thing. I'm still not sure if I buy it. How could you still be voting randomly by the time you voted brundibar?

[Scumhunter]

Its day 1, its about random votes and forming bandwagons to analyze vote patterns and reactions to look over later in the game. The most towny thing to do is to vote as many people as possible day 1 and gather reactions. Then, use that information to analyze who was on what wagon and combine with who got night killed as a way to piece together the pieces of the mafia puzzle. I have yet to make a vote that is an actual "I suspect you as mafia and am going to push on you vote."

To those of you voting me, I'll ask again: Why are you voting me? Are my answers to the questions not making sense? What can I do to prove my towniness?

[pycyununn]

UNVOTE: Caboose
VOTE: splitfarvle

[pycyununn]

Its day 1, its about random votes and forming bandwagons to analyze vote patterns and reactions to look over later in the game. The most towny thing to do is to vote as many people as possible day 1 and gather reactions. Then, use that information to analyze who was on what wagon and combine with who got night killed as a way to piece together the pieces of the mafia puzzle. I have yet to make a vote that is an actual "I suspect you as mafia and am going to push on you vote."

To those of you voting me, I'll ask again: Why are you voting me? Are my answers to the questions not making sense? What can I do to prove my towniness?

although, scumhunter, many smart mafia scum will know that and not bandwagon, or at least hop on a smaller grop of people to not make themselves too terribly obvious the first day or 2 so you cannot assume that one wold always do that a carefully formulated plan can lead to great succes on both sides, town and mafia, so in which case anyone shouldn't throw out vote willynilly as much as some people usually do because it also judges you.

[Parama]

EPIC
COACHING

lolololololololol

[Caboose]

Is lurking a 100% scum tell?

No

Why is SH's vote not scummy to you?

Because he freely admitted he faked the scumread when there really was no pressure to do so, though, I actually think he's town (I would expect scum would be a lot more weaselly about it).

Also, because scum really have no motive to do it. The fact that the votee was scummy also helps.

I understand your argument, but Reck's scum list and my scum list are not entirely different. And regardless, it's beside the point.

Beside the point? That's one of the tells you used to try to label me as scum!

[DemonHybrid]

If lurking is not a 100% solid scumtell, then wouldn't Recks scumlist be subjective just like mine is? With that logic, they're not different at all.

Also, I find you scummy for pointing something like that out when it doesn't exist. The why, how or what of what you picked is beside the point if the intention of Recks and my scumlists are the same.

[xRECKONERx]

Guys I really don't want to read all this le sigh

[Scumhunter]

Parama, I am not an inexperienced player. I know how to play this game. Are you insinuating, I am not the one who made that post? Don't insult my intelligence please.