Mini 1137: Long Overdue Mafia [Game Over!]

[Setael]

I haven't posted because I've wanted to reread first. I won't have time to until Monday.

[havingfitz]

v/LA till Tuesday night.

noted.

[Rhinox]

VOTECOUNT 3.2

chkflip (1) - Cecily,
P.T. Barnum (2) - Setael, Bub Bidderskins,
Bub Bidderskins (1) - mikemike778,
mikemike778 (1) - P.T. Barnum,
Setael (0) -
Cecily (2) - Nachomamma8, havingfitz,
havingfitz (0) -
Nachomamma8 (0) -

not voting (1): chkflip

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Deadline for Day 3 is

Wednesday, May 4th at Noon EST

.

Bub and fitz are V/LA.
Sending out a mass prod. Hope you all had a happy easter!

[Cecily]

I checked in, had nothing to add to the cases I've made because no one else had really posted anything worth noting. I've got a lot of work today, I'll try and get something in tomorrow.

[mikemike778]

I checked in, had nothing to add to the cases I've made because no one else had really posted anything worth noting. I've got a lot of work today, I'll try and get something in tomorrow.

You've not posted anything since the 19th - are you saying no-one has posted anything notable since then ?

[chkflip]

Yeah, sorry guys. Trying to get my life back on schedule. Will do a nice wall post when I'm finished looking over everything.

[chkflip]

VOTE: Cecily

Case forthcoming.

[Nachomamma8]

Okay, so I've done a little bit of recalibrating, and mike really isn't confirmed town. The safest person to claim a tracking result on would be a scumbuddy, so I can't yet rule that out.

Honestly, I'm about 90% sure that our scumteam lies in one of chk and Cecily, then another one out of P.T. and mike. Right now, I'd be inclined to say Cecily and P.T., but I'm sure that will change during ISOs.

[Nachomamma8]

Note: I would much rather lynch from those off the wagon instead of from those on it; Cecily is more obvscum to me than anyone right now. The P.T. votes and mike vote are really things we can take care of tomorrow, and will probably be a good idea to take care of tomorrow.

[Bub Bidderskins]

Okay, I'm back from V/LA. I'm getting caught up right now; expect some content this afternoon.

[Bub Bidderskins]

Bub ... I'm getting more and more wary of you. Been reading through the last few days and you seem to be posting just fluff, nothing questions, questionable votes and agreeing with people.

You voted PT ... seemingly purely because he attacked someone who attacked him (ie me). That's about as woolly a reason (see previous description of what woolly means people) as I've seen for voting for anyone. Which combined with 731 looks bad indeed.

Post 731 - you are more than happy to agree with Nacho's assessment that me, PT (who you later vote for little reason) and Fitz (why does everyone think he is town anyway ?) are confirmed town. And then happily add another couple to the confirmed list ... no one is confirmed at this point don't make out they are.

Post 727 - Little thing but you seem very sure how big the scum team is and its only the scum team who know that (and Rhino natch).

Post 725 you voted Chkflip for aggain what seems like a very simplistic reason (one post on Satael). You seem to be knee-jerk reacting to anyone that could be seen as even slightly scummy. Scum don't try and scum hunt they try and use what others post to their advantage.

Post 606 - you vote Voided because 'I agree with the case on him'. This is kind of like the demo of all of your scumsigns here - voting town (you vote Neil day 2), agreeing with people blindly, voting for no satisfactory reason (I mean come on - I agree with the case on him).

You have floated out a range of very basic questions of the nature of -who do you think is scum' (you have asked variants of this question a lot). This to me points at someone who is trying hard to look pro-town. Doesn't look like natural scum hunting at all to me.

And yes as PT kindly pointed out, Jerbs wasn't exactly un town like either. And with that ...

Vote Bub

Before you ask ... I've not forgotton about you Fitz so I guess its a bit more tap dancing on that front. But we should lynch Bub today.

The reason I'm voting for PT is that he has consistently only posted content targetted at people who have attacked him. Consistently. The first time he ever voiced any suspision of you was directly after you attacked him. For me, that capped of a trend and it reached a voting point.

As for me asking the "who do you think is scum?" question, that is the standard question that I ask of people who I think are not contributing to the game. Yes, I guess it is extremely generic, but that's sorta the point.

As far as me confirming scum, I agree, I did it too quickly.

In response to me knowing the size of the scumteam: I generally operate under the assumption of a three-scum team in mini games of 12-13 players.

Okay, so I've done a little bit of recalibrating, and mike really isn't confirmed town. The safest person to claim a tracking result on would be a scumbuddy, so I can't yet rule that out.

Honestly, I'm about 90% sure that our scumteam lies in one of chk and Cecily, then another one out of P.T. and mike. Right now, I'd be inclined to say Cecily and P.T., but I'm sure that will change during ISOs.

Specifically, why Cecily over Chk?

[havingfitz]

v/LA till Tuesday night.

noted.

Back. I'll try to get something posted today. Can anyone not voting Cecily (aside from Cecily and her scum buddy) please look over her ISO and ask yourself why you aren't voting her?

[Setael]

I'll ISO Cecily as soon as I get a chance - hopefully by tonight.

[mikemike778]

got home later than expected: promised post tomorrow

This is the eagerly awaited post 2 of 2 then is it ... just like Pine's post 2 and 3 of the three part series.

[havingfitz]

got home later than expected: promised post tomorrow

Five days and counting since last post.

Was the post Easter mass prod an official one or does PT still need a real one?

I'll prod him again.

I checked in, had nothing to add to the cases I've made because no one else had really posted anything worth noting. I've got a lot of work today, I'll try and get something in tomorrow.

I see you had time to log in this morning but still nothing to add to our game?

[Bub Bidderskins]

Okay chums, the Easter hangover is officially over. You can't have eaten

that

much candy. Now get in here and post some content!

[Cecily]

Time to log on =/= time to post. I hate falling 18 pages behind. But I'm busy again today, hopefully tomorrow will give me more time to get a solid read on everybody. But this is my birthday weekend so I can't promise much after tomorrow until at least tuesday.

And to everyone voting me/ thinking of voting me... what reasons, other than lurking, do you have on me?

[chkflip]

Cool...Pine has a little breathing room. I have not enjoyed exercising restraint and now that it is not the hammer....

VOTE: Pine

exhaaaaaaaaaaaaaale......that's better.

You definitely just went back to what made me think you were scummy in the first place... I understand that we all want Pine lynched. I will be very happy if I get to hammer, but we do still have at least a week left in this day and I don't see what the whole mentality of voting asap just to make sure you were a part of the unanimous decision is all about. Since you've done it with everybody now I'm not going to go back and call you scum again, I'm just saying that it's instances like this that make me question just exactly what your intentions are.

Amongst several other posts, it's not-town-motivated posts like this one that have my vote on Cecily. I'm sorry my content D2 has super lacked, I don't know if I mentioned it but uni is t-3wks until it's over and I've got projects ect. If there's anything specific you want me to cover, call me out. Otherwise I'll be deepening this case as time allows.

[Setael]

ISO'd Cecily. She's town.

PT or chk should be lynched today.

[mikemike778]

The reason I'm voting for PT is that he has consistently only posted content targetted at people who have attacked him. Consistently. The first time he ever voiced any suspision of you was directly after you attacked him. For me, that capped of a trend and it reached a voting point.

Why did you consider PT confirmed town (other than because Nacho said so) before he attacked me ?

When did you notice this trend of PT attacking people who targetted him ?

Why did you vote Voided Day 1 (other than because others voted him) ?

[Nachomamma8]

ISO'd Cecily. She's town.

PT or chk should be lynched today.

That's an absolutely terrible way to gauge alignment, considering we have flipped scum.

[Rhinox]

P.T. Barnum has not picked up his prod.

Will have a replacement by the end of today unless PT comes back.

Faraday is replacing P.T. Barnum effective right now. Thanks and Welcomes!

[Faraday]

Hi.

[Faraday]

P.T. Barnum (2) - Setael, Bub Bidderskins,

omg setael wat? </3

[Faraday]

Anyone wanna summarise the game for me in a nice manner so I can sheep them?