DaSpotthatkillsu wrote:scum going for a perfect game.
definately.
BUT WHO THE FUX SCUM?
Lemme make this as simple and easy for you as possible, as I can tell you're frustrated.
You have confirmed YFC as, at minimum, a blocking role. We (balam) have confirmed fate as scum or ourselves as scum. One of us must be scum while YFC is not guaranteed to be anything whatsoever. With YFC, you are taking a less certain and secure route. If you truly believe YFC to be scum, then at minimum we are still going to be scum if fate is town.
The key thing for you to consider is whether fate is scum or balam is scum. Analyze the play of the two slots and decide for yourself which benefits scum more.
I can give my biased summary of fate's play with the following:
> Actively backs off on people when they no longer suspect him - scum motivation here, no town motivation
> Screams a lot but provides minimal content when attacking people (balam, current) - see above
> In his "drunk" attack on us he claims complete certain, then says "well, it wasn't really certain" when we say we think he's town (well, I say it...) and then goes "it was not certain at all, it was just a trick!" when pressured about his actions - Why would town remove themselves from their initial action in this manner? Fate-town in the game I linked drunk pressured me to avoid a NK, but there is no such motivation here because he has someone he thinks is scum. Why would he side-track with a random drunken reaction fish on someone he claimed afterward to have a town read on? It's pointless save to try and force the person to back down. The consistency in which fate's tried to argue everyone down from attacking him is indicative of scum.
> Fate's trying to skew our "role fishing" as somehow setting up for a role cop fakeclaim. Our actions here are consistent: we pushed YFC for a claim, we pushed FD for a claim. Unless he wants to claim that YFC is also town, there is no indication of role fishing to help us with our "fakeclaim."
I'd also like to comment re: the stuff about YFC's claim. YFC targeted you, you were a strong scumread, this is perfectly natural play. You should think before you go "ZOMFG NO PRO-TOWN PERSON WOULD TARGET ME" - we can't read the mod's mind to know whether you're town or scum, so yeah. Re "why didn't you protect teh ethar": hindsight is 20/20. We know
now
that ether wasn't a PR and was going to be killed by the maf, but that was information left unknown at the time yos was making the decision. You're acting like yos should've been able to see the future.
Yos' claim checks out with logic, aside from the fact it's confirmed from the role cop'ing.
P-edit: we are confirmed as rolecop to yos, but not to anybody else, to clear things up. You obviously dunno if we're scum with yos and we set this up or not, but... yeah.
