Nachomamma8 wrote:Setael wrote:chkflip, can you explain why you won't post your mythical cecily case until I've posted why I read her as town?
In a nutshell, I had a town read on her from the beginning. She is not at all careful with what she writes in her posts and
has often said things that I think scum would be careful to not say
. I've never gotten a scum read from her posts.
Examples?
OK so I was looking back for examples. These are a couple of the ones I had noticed:
Cecily wrote:If it makes you feel any better about the question I was thinking of accompanying it with "what three things would you bring if you were stranded on a desert island?" just to keep the feel of ice breakers, but I didn't think that went along with the game very well and someone would probably have given me crap for asking it.
This one because I don't see scum admitting that they thought of posting something and didn't in order to avoid negative attention.
Cecily wrote:Honestly, no one has jumped out as scummy yet. Everyone in this game seems for the most part level headed and no one has just been throwing claims around (other than pappums, but thats another story).
Also this. I think townies are way more likely to admit to not having scum reads on anyone. Scum is careful to have
some
suspects.
But actually, while ISOing her again I started doubting my read. She repeatedly says "I'm going to be honest..." which made me raise an eyebrow since scum would more likely be of the mindset that they have to convince us they're being honest. Also I don't like a few of the things she said re: the Pine wagon.
Cecily wrote:Alright, I'm not thoroughly convinced. I admit, Pine I do like your claim and there really is no way for someone to argue a tracker claim, but the truth of the situation is that somebody is lying. I'd be more inclined to believe such a claim if it were a more influential PR (such as doctor, cop, etc) and no one called you out for having the same role.
Cecily wrote:Someone is lying because someone (or a few people) are always lying in this game. It seems very unlikely that both people who were attacked by seteal's post come out to be town oriented PRs and since I'm more willing to believe TO's claim because it can be proven via night actions I'm going to assume that Pine is lying about his role.
Cecily wrote:I understand that we all want Pine lynched. I will be very happy if I get to hammer, but we do still have at least a week left in this day and I don't see what the whole mentality of voting asap just to make sure you were a part of the unanimous decision is all about.
Cecily wrote:The only reason I wasn't on the Pine wagon was because I didn't log on in time to get my vote in before Pine lynched himself and I thought we were waiting at L-2 in order to keep the day going, but then fitz put us at L-1 and in came Pine before I could get my vote in. Otherwise I would have been all over it.
She was way too eager to get town cred for Pine's lynch, and the whole someone is lying thing is weird. It's a stupid reason to be certain one of them is lying, and then the "someone is always lying" is just backtracking. I think she knew Pine was lying because she's his buddy.
Also, the fact that she keeps asking people to give reasons for suspecting her, which is something I've realized I do as scum.
Woo! 360!
unvote, vote: Cecily
