Mini 1161 - Neruzian Era Mafia (Over!)

[charter]

Unvote

thought I did that already. Reading now.

[charter]

I'm leaning towards DarthYoshi being scum. Empking is suspect, but last game I remember being in with him, I had him nailed to the cross as a scumread, and I'm not getting that here.

[charter]

And Scott is pretty scummy too.

[Neruz]

Dammit, did i really put that vote count at the bottom of the page. Aagh.

Vote Count

Empking

( 3 )

- pappums rat, Vi, Faraday

Quilford

( 3 )

- Scott Brosius, Empking, hiplop

Scott Brosius

( 1 )

- Twistedspoon

hiplop

( 3 )

- Neuky, DarthYoshi, Quilford

Charter

( 2 )

- Sloth, Zdenek

Not Voting -

charter

With 13 alive, it is 7 votes to lynch.

Day 1 will end on May 10 at 0400 UTC/GMT

[Scott Brosius]

Alright I realize I need to catch up.

[Neuky]

@TS and Faraday - I was reading Newbie 1085 which you were both in along with Hiplop (who was scum). And it looks pretty similar to me. He DID put quilford at L-1 "to add pressure" too. I'm still thinking he's scum, but want to hear Twisted and Faraday's impressions about the meta from that game - he was scum, AND they lynched him day one. What makes his meta so different now?

@Neuky: you seem to have quite a mixed opinion on quilford, or so I gather from your last post. What is your opinion on Charter and who might your top scumread be?

It's still Hiplop at the mo' pending the above of course. Quilford - I ISO'd him again just because of your question to me, and I'm not seeing anything shouting scum - read the whole thing and you'll see what I mean. Regards to Charter, I'm not sure - again, I'm leaning town as he's hardly a blushing violet is he? He seems unafraid - and I like that.

Ok, lets just massclaim then.

You weren't serious here were you?
If not that's a very dangerous thing to say; some poor newbie skimming the topic could easily read this and claim in their next post without detecting that you weren't serious :/

I don't like this much TS - it was pretty obv a joke, and no newbies were going to buy into that were they? I'm not omgusing you just because you were asking me questions, but this did jump out at me a bit tonight when re-reading the last few pages.

[Neuky]

Oh, and I eagerly await Scott's comments, as I do happen to agree with you about him.

[Twistedspoon]

I don't like this much TS - it was pretty obv a joke,

well let me just say that I didn't see it a joke when I first read it, and a more sheepish player than myself might have followed it seriously

[Twistedspoon]

I'm still thinking he's scum, but want to hear Twisted and Faraday's impressions about the meta from that game - he was scum, AND they lynched him day one. What makes his meta so different now?

Firstly you can't say

they

lynched him D1. I take all the credit for the hiplop lynch in that game. D1 was mine and D2 faraday's

secondly, reading both games in ISO again, I actually agree with you. In both of the games he post a lot of fluff and only reads when provoked (after 14 ISO posts in 1085, and only after I continually asked him)

so yeah, I guess his meta is similar, however since I have no hiplop town meta, I can't make a conclusion as to if it is solely scum hiplop who posts fluff

@Hiplop: do you have any past town games on mafiascum?

[hiplop]

this is my second game on mafiascum, though faraday has seen me as town

[Twistedspoon]

this is my second game on mafiascum, though faraday has seen me as town

and that makes you town automatically?

we both know faraday can be wrong, hiplop :/

[Sloth]

scum

Quilford
Empking

also can you guys explain the suspicions on Empking?

Why put empking in your scumlist when you don't even know why people suspect him?

VOTE: Hiplop

[hiplop]

and that makes you town automatically?

we both know faraday can be wrong, hiplop :/

where did i say this? i said faraday has seen me as town


and sloth, i meant explain them further

[Twistedspoon]

scum

Quilford
Empking

also can you guys explain the suspicions on Empking?

Why put empking in your scumlist when you don't even know why people suspect him?

VOTE: Hiplop

hey, nice find

I'll gladly join this wagon once our pal Scotty has made his catchup post

[Twistedspoon]

and that makes you town automatically?

we both know faraday can be wrong, hiplop :/

where did i say this? i said faraday has seen me as town

this is my second game on mafiascum, though faraday has seen me as town

the though part made it seem as though you thought that justified yourself as town because farady has a town read on you

[hiplop]

i use the word though in pretty much every single post TS

[Twistedspoon]

but you used it as though it made you town since faraday said he had a town read on you

nevermind. If other players think it's a tell they can judge. I'm hardly going to convince you yourself that you're scum :/

[Neuky]

Firstly you can't say

they

lynched him D1. I take all the credit for the hiplop lynch in that game.

D1 was mine

and D2 faraday's

I had to laugh at that -that was the most amazing D1 I've seen - 34 pages. But you were a "bit" wrong about faraday lol.. anyway, I do agree - This:

Alright I realize I need to catch up.

seems to be the worst ever case of active lurking....

[Neuky]

@Hiplop:

hiplop where'd your neuky town read come from?

Neuky has seemed towny the entire time, hes the one im least confident in though, to be honest.

- I don't understand this. Please clarify. my thoughts are how can I appear towny "the entire time", while I'm also the one you are least confident in. Remember that Faraday declared me town, and waited to see if you sheeped his thoughts? This is what I think you did here, but decided to qualify it at the end of your statement.

[hiplop]

@Hiplop:

hiplop where'd your neuky town read come from?

Neuky has seemed towny the entire time, hes the one im least confident in though, to be honest.

- I don't understand this. Please clarify. my thoughts are how can I appear towny "the entire time", while I'm also the one you are least confident in. Remember that Faraday declared me town, and waited to see if you sheeped his thoughts? This is what I think you did here, but decided to qualify it at the end of your statement.

The others have seemed more pro-town..its really not that difficult to uunderstand..is it?

[Twistedspoon]

Firstly you can't say

they

lynched him D1. I take all the credit for the hiplop lynch in that game.

D1 was mine

and D2 faraday's

I had to laugh at that -that was the most amazing D1 I've seen - 34 pages. But you were a "bit" wrong about faraday lol.. anyway, I do agree

lol, yeah

it was frustrating at times but I can't complain since I ended up being so wrong D2 XP

[Faraday]

don't discuss that game. ever.

Anyway, I think Hiplop's town here though. Seems a little different, I guess if a fairly similar playstyle.

[Sloth]

Faraday, you calling all my scumreads town is starting to get a little annoying

[Faraday]

Well, can you at least see my point about charter?

[Sloth]

Is it a purely meta thing?