Cecily wrote:1) I happy to see the chk wagon growing. 3) So far based solely off of who's being pushed chk/fitz seems like a good pairing.
While I don't like judging completely off of who's sticking up for whom I do not see chk as being anything other than aligned with Pine because setael's case was honestly that strong and not going with it was a rookie scum mistake.
3) And now fitz is pushing me, and I'm still not completely certain what his case is against me
and I'm sad he won't be back until deadline to fill me in. It just seems like a perfect grouping of three and since that's the number of anti-town people we've agreed on for this game I'm fairly certain those are the remaining two. And at the very least it's chk and someone who's playing the last role very [and I mean very] cleverly.
Bold is mine.
1) Cecily...you keep pointing to newb or rookie mistakes by chkflp in your suspicions towards him. He has been on the site longer than you (albeit only by 2 weeks), has made 5x as many posts as you, and he has been involved in 51 topics/games while you have been in 8. Throwing out newb/rookie tells under these circumstances seems a bit weak...and I haven't noticed but has anyone else agreed with you on your newb/rookie accusations towards chkflp?
2) Could you explain this? What do you mean when you say chk and I make a good pairing "based solely off of who's being pushed?" Can you elaborate?
3) I've been pushing you for a few days. What do you mean "
And now
" I'm pushing you? And I have provided numerous suspicions towards you. My
ISO 34,
ISO 37,
ISO 45,
ISO 46,
ISO 56 and
ISO 57 to name several. What do you want to try and tap dance around?
Nacho...you are all over the place. Your reason for suspecting me is stupid. It was meant to be humorous. I realize past roles has nothing to do with respect to this game...but interjecting it as humor gave me another chance to bitch about the disparity. I have
never
been scum in almost two years on this site, in 30+ games, except! for one game that I replaced in which was modded by Faraday...hence my comment to him.
Faraday...you don't know what you are doing. Are you trying to relive our game where you were Riddick (ie suspecting me without any basis)? You haven't provided any reasoning for suspecting me. Saying you "aren't big on explaining [your] reasoning" is a cop out. Everyone still alive in the game has provided ample material to at least be able to source/explain whatever suspicions you do happen to have. What is your case on chkflp and on me?
Looking at the Day one lynch....four (Nachomamma8, P.T. Barnum aka Faraday, chkflip, Bub Bidderskins) of the seven players remain from the Void mislynch. One of the dead has been ID's as scum...I find it hard to believe on a 7 player mislynch that there is not at least one other scum member (and I am assuming there are three scum). As I do not think chkflp is scum...that leaves me with Nacho, Faraday and Bub. I'm not confident enough to put a vote on any of them ATT though.
Of the four remaing players alive off the Void mislynch I think there could be one scum (havingfitz, mikemike778, Idiotking aka Setael, Cecily). Discounting myself of course...that leaves me with three. I do not think Setael is scum based on his case on Pine (though it would have been a perfect time to bus a partner given Pine's poor play and scummy hammer) and between mikemike and Cecily...I suspect Cecily significantly more than I do mikemike (see earlier ISO sampling in this post). I would also note that I had Pine
2nd on my suspect list D1 before he hammered Void and voted him in my first post on D2. I also voiced D1 suspicions on Pine in my
ISO 56 and
ISO 57.
As for the D2 Pine wagon....I could see there being at least one partner bussing him which (not counting myself) leaves Faraday, mikemike, and Nacho. As I am leaning against mikemike being scum ATM that gives me, once again, the toss up between Nacho and Faraday. They are too close for me to choose between but if I had to I'd probably lean towards Faraday. I definitely think there is at least one scum not bussing their partner Pine...which leaves us with Bub, Setael and, once again, Cecily. I leaning town on Setael and between Bub and Cecily it's once again significant suspicions towards Cecily guiding my vote her way.
tl:dr;
I'm not convinced chkflp is scum so I will not change my vote from Cecily.
