Mini 1161 - Neruzian Era Mafia (Over!)

[Faraday]

Sorta..but not? I think his actions make as much sense coming from town as scum, and the early thing makes me think town. I guess it's meta to some degree alright.

[DarthYoshi]

@Hiplop: Why would being on your phone keep you from saying whether or not you still suspecting Quil? It isn’t the brevity that I’m wary of you for—it’s your clinging to the Quil wagon.

@Faraday: How is Charter’s stance on Quil not scummy? If it is a meta game, are there particular games to take a look at?

@Charter: Why are you leaning to me = scum? Also, why unvote without revoting?

Sloth’s #336 is a good catch.

@TS: Why are you waiting to join the Lynch Hiplop party until Scott shows up?

Hiplop and Charter are still my top two suspects. Feel like Pappums and especially Scott are active lurking. Me no likey.

[Faraday]

Pappums is active lurking?

[Faraday]

And it's just not scummy I don't think.

[hiplop]

@Hiplop: Why would being on your phone keep you from saying whether or not you still suspecting Quil? It isn’t the brevity that I’m wary of you for—it’s your clinging to the Quil wagon.

.

i didnt want to check back on the thread on my phone.. thats what i meant. I think quil is scum, the only other wagon is on me.. hence me staying on quil. I suppose i could switch to empking, but i think quils more likely scum

[Scott Brosius]

Faraday

241 You were the biggest proponent of this wagon, and you jump off because you expected Quil to be a PR? This seems forced.

DarthYoshi

180 Accusing me of active lurking is wrong. I just haven't participated, I'm more than willing to admit that. But active lurking is posting somewhat often without really saying anything. I just haven't been posting. I have more time now though.

Quilford

126 is stupid. Stop throwing the word "sheep" around anytime someone agrees with someone. Vi didn't sheep your vote, misrep alert.

166 The scummy empty threats of "when i flip town"

charter

222 You unvote Quil when he was at L-1 Yet in 249 you claim that it is good town strategy to lynch all vanilla claims. Why the inconsistency? The VC in 265 is incorrect, you had unvoted.

hiplop

108 is terrible.

I still like my vote. Anyone else notice how remarkably quiet Quilford has gotten since being strung up to L-1. I find this to be indicative of scum trying to be careful not to draw anymore attention to himself. Hiplop reads as noob more than scum.

[Faraday]

'forced'. also not what I said, either I'm fairly fucking sure.

[Scott Brosius]

I'm just wondering what is a scummy VT claim if not that. (with the daring people to hammer, enjoying flipping town, etc.)

[Faraday]

i'll point it out if i see one.

[charter]

@Charter: Why are you leaning to me = scum? Also, why unvote without revoting?

Was waiting until I had time to explain why I think you're suspect, which I have now.

I thought Juls's one real post was pretty suspect. Lots of questions worded so as to draw out a suspicious response. They looked like they were asked so she could later say "aha!" rather than discern anyone's alignment. I thought this was scummy of her, but was waiting until I saw if that's what she did or what.
Don't like your comment on Looker's post, not anything close to what I was thinking about it.
Don't like how you said you think Neuky's flip would help us figure out Quil's alignment, especially since you didn't say 'if Neuky flips xxxx, I think that says xxxx about Quil'. Nothing to back that up. Not much of anything to back up your Neuky read.
Don't like your stance on me, though that doesn't mean much.
Don't think you're scumhunting.

charter

222 You unvote Quil when he was at L-1 Yet in 249 you claim that it is good town strategy to lynch all vanilla claims. Why the inconsistency? The VC in 265 is incorrect, you had unvoted.

The next six words right after I unvote explain why I unvoted.

Scott, who else do you think is scum?

[Sloth]

Sorta..but not? I think his actions make as much sense coming from town as scum, and the early thing makes me think town. I guess it's meta to some degree alright.

Well with me being not familiar with people's meta I'm purely judging charter on this game's actions, and I disagree with you on the first statement you made.

[charter]

His statement really has nothing to do with meta.

[Quilford]

vote me, bitchezzz

I'm not quite sure what to say; my reads remain the same

[Quilford]

holy shit

mod: V/LA for a day

[Neuky]

don't discuss that game. ever.

Anyway, I think Hiplop's town here though. Seems a little different, I guess if a fairly similar playstyle.

Me confused here Faraday - I know you have a unique posting style - but please - some more info on this?

especially as you said "Vi/Hiplop intereactions are so fucking awkward." - so you must be saying there's a possible link there?

Re Quil: I'll second that I didn't like him vanishing as soon as he appeared to be off the hook. I was the one saying he was showing newbie tells ... however ... Having had a look at his meta, one thing that does worry me is that he seems more newbie in this game than others. He's definitely posting differently imo.

[Sloth]

His statement really has nothing to do with meta.

Never said it did.

[Quilford]

I'm posting differently because I'm around different people.

[Vi]

Sure, the L-1 reason for Quilford was horrendous by Hiplop, but I know his scum meta and this doesn't seem to follow suit :/

so yeah, I guess his meta is similar, however since I have no hiplop town meta, I can't make a conclusion as to if it is solely scum hiplop who posts fluff

So what you're saying is that this meta reason doesn't exist.

I'm not saying it's the strongest town tell ever, but I think it's pretty lgit.

and charter looks v town. his early play is strongly town

Oh really.

Looking back I think I can see why people are calling DarthYoshi scummy. So many semi-useless questions and clutter, relatively few meaningful statements. That and pap-rat isn't active lurking. (fake edit: typed before I saw charter's post)

Faraday, you calling all my scumreads town is starting to get a little annoying

That's an odd choice of smiley. I'm assuming you have a Town read on Faraday?

While Scott B.'s post physically hurt to read, I can't disagree with the accusation on Quilford. Three days gone (but not from the site) and comes back to show us what active lurking

really

looks like.

I thought about switching my vote but Empking is avoiding this thread as much as Quilford.

[Empking]

Empking isn't avoiding this thread its just that nothing has caught my eye in the last day.

Why am I the one who's avoiding the thread? (compared to someone like Paprum)?

[Vi]

That was quick.

*I have a Town read on pap-rat
*He isn't trying to ask why he's getting picked on (let alone only saying that)
*He would read my post enough to know he's not the only one getting called out

Although whatever you have cake for, happy

that

.

[Empking]

That was quick.

*I have a Town read on pap-rat

So you're voting me because I'm avoiding the thread. And the reason you are of the opinion that I'm avoiding the thread is because you find me scummy. I'm pretty sure there's a flaw in your logic somewhere.

*He isn't trying to ask why he's getting picked on (let alone only saying that)

So the reason you said I'm avoiding the thread is because after saying that I asked why I was getting picked on?

*He would read my post enough to know he's not the only one getting called out

Yes but you most definitely weren't calling out PR for some reason.

Yeah after seeing your response I'm pretty sure that whole comment "While Scott B.'s post physically hurt to read, I can't disagree with the accusation on Quilford. Three days gone (but not from the site) and comes back to show us what active lurking really looks like.

I thought about switching my vote but Empking is avoiding this thread as much as Quilford." was just distancing from your budddy.

Although whatever you have cake for, happy

that

.

Its my scumday!

[Vi]

That was quick.

*I have a Town read on pap-rat

So you're voting me because I'm avoiding the thread.

And the reason you are of the opinion that I'm avoiding the thread is because you find me scummy.

I'm pretty sure there's a flaw in your logic somewhere.

It would be really sweet if you thought that much of me. ♥

*He isn't trying to ask why he's getting picked on (let alone only saying that)

So the reason you said I'm avoiding the thread is because after saying that I asked why I was getting picked on?

It verifies the accusation, yes.

*He would read my post enough to know he's not the only one getting called out

Yes but you most definitely weren't calling out PR for some reason.

I called pap-rat Town a long time ago and he hasn't done anything to shake that read.

Yeah after seeing your response I'm pretty sure that whole comment "While Scott B.'s post physically hurt to read, I can't disagree with the accusation on Quilford. Three days gone (but not from the site) and comes back to show us what active lurking really looks like.

I thought about switching my vote but Empking is avoiding this thread as much as Quilford." was just distancing from your budddy.

Explain.

[Empking]

It says "I find X scummy but will not contribute to X's lynch". That's textbook distancing.

[Vi]

ITT I'm not allowed to have more than one suspect?

I also wasn't referring to changing my vote to Quilford.

And, I just got out of a game where two of the three scum were lurkers, not badposters. What say we do things right this time?~

[Empking]

Who were you planning on changing your vote to?