Open 300 - Mafia on Midol (Town Wins!)

[Thor665]

Gut and the way he acted at start of Day. On top of things enough to notice a vote count error about Zorblag, but "lol, obviouslly not scum" enough to not pay any attention to who was NKed? Naaaaah.

I could expanded it to a wall with fancy quotes and PBPA and all that gak - but this is the case.

[Cyberbob]

Apologies to town for my gak reads this game, and fie on AGar for playing me like I did to him when our roles were reversed (jerk!).

consider this a vote post in spirit, were it not for the fact that I don't want you at L-1 so early

[Punkin]

Llama did you crumb? I was wrong on Agar... ;-;

I also agree with a Thor lynch.

Vote: Thor

I agree with Plum, this rubs me all kinds of wrong ways...

FOS Ranmaru

Thor, I also did not catch any proof on PZ...?

[Punkin]

hmmm, you make a really good point bob,
the way folks have been quick hammering, I don't even like him at L-2 this early

unvote

VOTE: Ranmaru

[LlamaFluff]

Vote Ran

NO ONE hammers anyone without me saying so today, also not without them claiming.

[Cyberbob]

right as I decide to go for Thor everyone starts in on Ran

i hate you

[LlamaFluff]

Vote wherever. Like I said, im not going to pull the plug on a cleared player wagon until they hit L-1.

[Punkin]

Llama, out of curiosity, why did you claim? I thought it was pretty obvious by the end of yesterday.

I'd rather lynch Thor than Ran at the moment but, then again, we're not lynching anyone until I give this thread some love, so I guess there's no reason to play vote-tennis with my wife.

[Punkin]

It's very strange to color-code the VCA and then have to wait to do the actual analysis together. Trying that patience thing again...

Is this your subtle way of telling me you'd like me to do another votecount?

[LlamaFluff]

Llama, out of curiosity, why did you claim? I thought it was pretty obvious by the end of yesterday.

Now that I know there is a doc, just have to make sure they are paying attention. This game is essentially tied up with my two clears, a couple prob towns, and another possible claim... I seriously think scum are narrowed down to four people, five max. I was not kidding when I said that yesterday. Not going to lose a huge advantage because someone isnt reading close.

[singersigner]

Tally Hall

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Punkin (0):
Cyberbob (0):
Oman (0):
Papa Zito (0):
Ranmaru (3): Cyberbob, Punkin, LlamaFluff
Thor665 (4): Papa Zito, Ranmaru, Twilight Sparkle, Plum
Plum (0):
chkflip (1): Crazy
Cogito Ergo Sum (0):
Llamafluff (0):
Twilight Sparkle (0):
Crazy (0):

Not voting (4): Oman, Thor665, chkflip, Cogito Ergo Sum

Deadline is May 19th, 2011 at 5pm MST.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Vote: Ranmaru

[Plum]

Gut and the way he acted at start of Day. On top of things enough to notice a vote count error about Zorblag, but "lol, obviouslly not scum" enough to not pay any attention to who was NKed? Naaaaah.

I could expanded it to a wall with fancy quotes and PBPA and all that gak - but this is the case.

Very shiny, I'm sure, but your posts indicate you initially thought PZ's behavior at the beginning of Day 1 was Townish. Second point does nothing for me for reasons I've discussed (and the fact that 'pretending not to be paying attention' is in my experience simply not a scumtell that's usually evaluatable).

But I'm sure this is such a strong case that Zito's sure scum, to the point that you'd vote him over seeing if he's plausibly connected to the two flipped scumbags or not, or see if anyone else has stronger connections to the two of them . . .

Yeah, I don't buy it.

Llama did you crumb? I was wrong on Agar... ;-;

I also agree with a Thor lynch.

Vote: Thor

I agree with Plum, this rubs me all kinds of wrong ways...

FOS Ranmaru

Thor, I also did not catch any proof on PZ...?

I recently ended a game as scum and when the Cop claimed the reaction I chose was similar (and many people caught it as an off reaction to boot. Bah!).

[Thor665]

But I'm sure this is such a strong case that Zito's sure scum, to the point that you'd vote him over seeing if he's plausibly connected to the two flipped scumbags or not, or see if anyone else has stronger connections to the two of them . . .

Yeah, I don't buy it.

Nor should you since I never had a chance to connect him to two flipped scumbags till today and I haven't voted for him today.
I didn't particularly try to connect him to the one flipped scumbag, sure. But I also spent most of that day sheeping (and defending the other soon to be flipped scumbag).
At least keep your accusations straight as you decide to wagon me up for not using good logic .

[chkflip]

VOTE: Ranmaru

[Crazy]

Chk, what were your reasons for voting me? What were your reasons for voting SocioPath?

Why Ranmaru over Thor?

[chkflip]

I'm not answering your questions anymore if you don't bother to remember what I said.

[Thor665]

Mod - V/LA - May 19-22

Noted. : )

[Punkin]

@Mod:

No, I was bitching about needing to wait for Xine.

People voting Ran or Thor should explain why one over the other please.

@Llama:

I've been running through the various scenarios in my head and I actually don't see the harm in outing your innocents. Since you have two, you'll be able to stay one investigation ahead of the scumz even if they decide to start killing them off, plus you'd be tempting them to forgo doc hunting. Also, one of them is already obvious. On the up-side, we know there is no GF and it's pretty clear that your claim is honest: having two more confirmed green will help us quite a bit. With your investigations and my analysis, we might be able to wrap this game up with two lynches.

@PZ:

I know you're opposed to the above. Is your stance based entirely on general strategy or do you have some reason specific to this situation?

[Ranmaru]

third vote on thor wagon with no own justification + still asking empty questions as the entirety of your posts

blammo

I've been good with a thor lynch before.

I asked Llama that because I didn't believe his claim.

[Ranmaru]

I'm vt.

[Ranmaru]

My scum picks:

Thor, Llama, CyberBob, and Zito. (Yeah those two are new ones! : D)

Bob doesn't actually post content and only stabs others for whatever they lack.

Zito, asks for a case on himself even though there isn't that much townieness going for him.

[Ranmaru]

I recently ended a game as scum and when the Cop claimed the reaction I chose was similar (and many people caught it as an off reaction to boot. Bah!).

If you are town you may hurt yourself next DAY.

[Ranmaru]

Zito, why should you? (Meaning what have you done to help the town) Of course, to me you are now null. Didn't your vote on Thor seem a bit, omgusy? (Since he had you as a scumpick)

Why should I what? Ask for his case?

And I thought I provided ample justification for it already. You just skimming boy?

Not at all. Again, I don't believe you have that much townieness going for you to ask someone to disprove your scumminess.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Why do you no longer find me suspicious?