Battle for Olympus - Game Over!

[Shadow Dancer]

Do not use the tree stump power for the sake of mod confirming yourself. If you're town, we'd effectively use a townie either way.

Wrong. If it safes us a misslynch he needs to use it.

[Shadow Dancer]

So you basically claim useless random role that confirmably caused a town death...

When did this happen? Flavor indicates that no one died by a Hellfire.

Yeah, you're right. Persefone was only a speculation...

[Shadow Dancer]

@Katymine: Good thought. Spring and Summer have a more positive notion. Definitely worth trying out for confirmation purposes.

[Shadow Dancer]

@Quad: I am pretty sure that treestumps neither can be killed nor count towards the lynch theshold.

[Shadow Dancer]

He seasons, but I, Demeter, am Evergolden.[/b]

Premature much?

[Shadow Dancer]

that was retarded calling it now ooba is scum and wins easily

Could you maybe finally care and back that up?

[Shadow Dancer]

@Charon: Don't youconsider this whole "Here you've got four green buttons and one big fat red one and not the glimpse of an idea what any of them might do"-business a bit bastardy?

[chesskid3]

that was retarded calling it now ooba is scum and wins easily

Could you maybe finally care and back that up?

Making cases is dumb it's just who can argue better

he's scum that's all there is too it

[chesskid3]

@Charon: Don't youconsider this whole "Here you've got four green buttons and one big fat red one and not the glimpse of an idea what any of them might do"-business a bit bastardy?

it's an inventor who doesn't know waht his inventions do

it's not that bastardly shut up

[Axelrod]

Ok, so, moving right along then....

This is about the time I like to start compiling claim lists to see where we're at.

This is what I remember off the top of my head:

2. Chronopie - Normal Power "Grace" gives an extra vote to someone. Used N1 on Agar.
3. AurorousVox - Athena, Doc
4. AGar - Knows Poseidon is in the game.
5. Shadow Dancer - Poseidon, Jailkeeper. Targeted Dekes on N1 (Failed?)
7. Iecerint - Dionysus. (Name?)Cop. Regular power redirected on N1 to AGM, Jesus Christ. Superpower on AV (this is supposedly 100%). AV is not Greek pantheon.
8. ooba CryMeARiver -
9. Dekes - Not Jailed on N1 (right?)
11. Gemini (mockingjaye + Katy hydra) -
12. AlmasterGM RangeroftheNorth - Asclepius, Regulat power, Doc. Super, prevent next 3 kills.
13. MagnaofIllusion - Hated Townie can be lynched at L-1
14. Axelrod -
15. gandalf5166 - Regular power, redirect. Redirected Ice to AGM on N1. Super, immediately lynch the vote leader. Lost his vote D2. "Knows" SD is not a SK.
16. quadz08 - Demeter, Mod Confirmed
17. mothrax -
18. LordChronos -
20. chesskid3 - also claimed a Jailkeep power, I believe

I am sure I have missed some things.

One thing that juped out doing this was what Gandalf said about an ability being used on him last Night which explains how he knows SD is not SK and how he knows Dekes was not jailkeepd, because what that strongly suggests is Gandalf knows that SD got redirected onto Gandalf last Night (SD not SK because Gandalf is still alive. Dekes not jailed because SD re-directed). Except if SD got redirected onto Gandalf, then Gandalf would have been jailed and shouldn't have been able to redirect Ice. Plus that this would mean two redirectors.

[chesskid3]

Similar to a jailkeep

[AGar]

Lynch1 - AV
Lynch2 - mothrax

Quadz treestumping himself is a double-edged sword. We lost a townie, but at the same time we now have his voice throughout the game, as long as I understand a treestump correctly.

Mothrax has done nothing but come in here and poke shots at different people and then exit the same, lurking hardcore throughout. Good money says that in a large game with as much going on here as there is, this is tactical scum lurking. Lynch2 should move here, folks.

[gandalf5166]

@Axel: Why would you assume that I had had him redirected to me?

[Shadow Dancer]

@Chess: An inventor would be some one who hands out items to specific players.

Shockingly I agree with you on this. SD's insistence on pulling out targets is bad.

OKOK, I concede that you have a point.
Let's try another explanation: I've played with both Chess and Moth before and while Chess' performance here more or less matches up with what I've seen of him in rusty guillotine I remember town moth as being much more talkative about her reads.

I feel like Quad preemtively treestumping himself is a clear symptom of there beng already one clai too much. It's time to become serious. Moth is a great lynch. AV already has one vote. Time to become serious.

vote Moth

[gandalf5166]

@SD: Yes. But he's just pointing out the parallel. Having abilities that you don't understand is fairly normal in theme games.

[Shadow Dancer]

It is not normal that you have no idea what your own ability does. Some randomness might happen (like a random inventor) but in a non-bastard game I would expect the mod to at least reveal which potential effects are there and not just soome random/flavour based names.

[gandalf5166]

Why?

[ooba]

Lynch 2 VC

Mothrax (3) – ooba, AGar, ShadowDancer
Iecerint (1) - AV
Not voting (2) – Iecerint, Axelrod, , Dekes, Gemini, MoI, LC, AGM, Gandalf, Chronopie, Chesskid, Mothrax, AGM,

---

Calling it now - chess is scum and will probably get crosskilled

[chesskid3]

---

Calling it now - chess is scum and will probably get crosskilled

aka you're killing me tonight?

[gandalf5166]

I actually find myself agreeing with chess on ooba-scum. I need to go dunk my head in a barrel of water real quick.

[ooba]

---

Calling it now - chess is scum and will probably get crosskilled

aka you're killing me tonight?

Yup. How will I have an easy win if I allow you to continue calling me scum?

[Shadow Dancer]

Making cases is dumb it's just who can argue better
he's scum that's all there is too it

Ah... Understood. You prefer being ignored for making no case at all to being ignored for making a bad case. That definitely brings you into a position where you can call out "I told you so", but it's not at all helpful.

Yup. How will I have an easy win if I allow you to continue calling me scum?

O_o WIFOM levels rising...

[MagnaofIllusion]

Axelrod’s 1384 strikes me as more “Look how helpful I am” posting. He’s not pressing scum reads and just more or less actively lurking.

I’m getting the feeling this Day is stretching out longer than it should.

Lynch2 - Axelrod

--

I feel like Quad preemtively treestumping himself is a clear symptom of there beng already one clai too much. It's time to become serious. Moth is a great lynch. AV already has one vote. Time to become serious.
vote Moth

You know that you just place a real vote not a Lynch2 vote, right?

[gandalf5166]

Lynch2: Axel

I brought this up earlier, and now that it's got MoI behind it it might actually go through >.>

[Shadow Dancer]

I’m getting the feeling this Day is stretching out longer than it should.
[...]
You know that you just place a real vote not a Lynch2 vote, right?

Yes. (But please stay coordinated in following me)
Is there any specific reason why you think Moth is not scum or not a good lynch?