Well, this is not a happy development. For the unfamiliar, which is most of you, I typically don't have strong opinions on anyone in the early part of a game, and I also typically like to do more indepth re-reading before casting votes, which is just not happening now (I'm incredibly busy). Compiling the claim list was both an attempt to get a discussion started, and also an attempt to see if anything could be determined just laying all the claims out next to each other.
gandalf5166 wrote:@Axel: Why would you assume that I had had him redirected to me?
I'm not assuming it so much as noting that it would explain your otherwise cryptic remarks that you both know (1) that SD is not a SK and (2) you know that Dekes was not jailkept last night despite SD claiming that he targeted him. If you knew that SD had targeted YOU, then you would reasonably presume he was not a SK - because you didn't die, and you would also know that SD did not target Dekes, so that's why Dekes would not have been jailkept. The issue there, of course, is that you were apparently not jailed last Night, as your targeting of Ice has been confirmed by Ice. So if everyone is telling the truth, that's not what happened, but it was the only immediate thing that jumped out at me from doing that list.
Dekes wrote:This post is missing some sort of reaction to quadz's claim and subsequent use of his super and worse, anything resembling a scum read. Axel, anything you wanna tell us?
I think the link you posted is wrong there, but assuming you are talking about the post where I started the claim list, the part at the top where I say "moving right along then..." was my way of reacting to Quadz's claim and subsequent mod-firming. Really not a lot more to say there. And no, there aren't any "reads" in that post, that wasn't what it was for. I'll do up something more substantial tonight when I can put aside some time for it. Quick hit would be that MoI feels a lot like the last game I played here, which was A Clash of Kings, where there was just this constant niggling sense of worry about him, but nothing you could really pin down or build a case around, and there always seemed to be other people it was always more pressing to address, until it was the end and he was scum and won. Ooba feels a bit the same way. I was going to attempt to look closer at both Mothrax and Lord Chronos. I'm a little worried they are kind of soft targets though. A bit too easy to switch to if you know what I mean.
I'm also inclined to get suspicious of anyone who jumps on me. Character flaw.
I'll do more tonight. I find when i make some kind of promise to post something later, I usually make myself do it however busy I am.