Mini 1137: Long Overdue Mafia [Game Over!]

[havingfitz]

So one statement out of all the posts made by the Bub and mikemike player slots is going to determine your read on a player? That seems a bit....weak. It's still not a slam dunk for me either way with regard to Bub and mikemike (I'm going to be really pissed if neither of them is scum) but ATM I'm leaning Bub for all the reason I've brought up recently. The

dodgey

bits.

[Bub Bidderskins]

I suspected Satael before Faraday claimed and before the MYLO mass claim and before I found your scumslips.

Can you point out where you stated suspicion of me? All I remember is you saying I was on your town list for my Pine post.

I think I only theorized about it in the quick-topic, so you wouldn't have seen it.

Before anybody hammers, I want to hear what Cecily has to say when she comes back.

[Setael]

I suspected Satael before Faraday claimed and before the MYLO mass claim and before I found your scumslips.

Can you point out where you stated suspicion of me? All I remember is you saying I was on your town list for my Pine post.

I think I only theorized about it in the quick-topic, so you wouldn't have seen it.

Before anybody hammers, I want to hear what Cecily has to say when she comes back.

OK well would you like to share your reasoning regardless? I find it odd that you'd theorize about that in the qt and yet only state i'm definitely town in thread.

[Bub Bidderskins]

Like I said before, my reads have been drastically changed today by the combination of the claims given and me discovering MikeMike's slip.

[havingfitz]

Like I said before, my reads have been drastically changed today by the combination of the claims given and me discovering MikeMike's slip.

And by mikemike's "slip" you mean the fact he didn't counter-claim Void...right?

I find the delayed discovery of your "instant" scum-tell of him more suspicious than his lack of a counter-claim.

[Faraday]

So one statement out of all the posts made by the Bub and mikemike player slots is going to determine your read on a player? That seems a bit....weak. It's still not a slam dunk for me either way with regard to Bub and mikemike (I'm going to be really pissed if neither of them is scum) but ATM I'm leaning Bub for all the reason I've brought up recently. The

dodgey

bits.

aye for the most part i think towntells are more accurate

[Setael]

Where are you Cecily? I'm awake and ready for this day to end.

[Faraday]

unless you expect her to self hammer, uh you'll be waiting a bit longer.

[Setael]

I just want her to start talking.

Anyone want to play cards while we wait?

[mikemike778]

we could play I-spy instead. Cards isnt practical

I spy with my little eye something beginning with C

[Setael]

I hope it's a chocolate croissant.

[Faraday]

we could play I-spy instead. Cards isnt practical

I spy with my little eye something beginning with C

or you could FUCKING HAMMER HER.

[Faraday]

and probably end the game since she's not a traitor or would have been hammered. DO YOU NEED IT SPELLED OUT FOR YOU? SHE'S CAUGHT.

[havingfitz]

I don't understand why neither Bub OR mikemike are willing to hammer Cecily. If Cecily was scum, whomever of Bub and mikemike are town (because if both of them are town they would have voted her for the instant win) should have voted her by now. Fock! Hammer the contentless slacker.

So out of sheer boredom here are some musings...

We know Bub AND mikemike are not scum because they would have been able to vote Cecily for the win already.

We know Cecily is not town because 1) we know from above that Bub AND mikemike aren't scum and 2) if either Bub or mikemike were scum...they would have been able to vote Cecily for the win already.

Cecily is confirmed scum.

Bub or mikemike could conceivable both be town but we know they aren't both scum. So just focking hammer Cecilyscum.

Or are we waiting patiently for her v/LA to end and her either say something worthless or for her to self vote like Pine did?

I feel so good about being right re: Cecily for the majority of the game.

mikemike...if you have addressed the fact that you did not attack Pine when he claimed you had not visited anyone (the night you visited Bub) could you please post a link to where.

Bub...could you please explain your reaction to Pine's fakeclaim? Since you were visited by mikemike...you both would have known Pine was lying when he claimed to have gotten no result on mikemike. Yet for some reason you do not feel the need to put a vote down on him.....who you knew was lying.

Another also....has anyone mentioned that Pine addresses his "scum partners" in his closing post? It doesn't do scum any good to indicate there are still multiple scum left. If anything scum would want us to think there were fewer scum to keep town offguard. And from my understanding of how a traitor works (thats to Setael) Pine would not have know there was a traitor and therefore would not have indicated "scum partners" if the game set up was 2 scum + a traitor. So I def think we have 3 scum (2 left).

Did I mention Cecily was CONFIRMED SCUM and someone needs to vote her?

[havingfitz]

EBWOP...the only way Cecily is not scum is if, FMPOV, Setael AND Faraday are scum. From the non-voters POV...they would include me in that equation.

So bub and mikemike...do you honestly think there are two scum amongst Setael, Farada and me? If not...vote Cecily. If you do think two of us are scum, please elaborate.

If Setael and Faraday are both scum I'm going to be really pissed.

[havingfitz]

Buuuuuuut...since the two of you are voting each other....that means you do not think there are 2 scum on the current Cecily wagon. And if you truly believe that and think the person you are currently voting is scum...then FYPOV...Cecily is confirmed scum.

Vote her please.

[havingfitz]

I'm not patient enough for this shyte. Someone please get in here and hammer our more than likely confirmed scum FFS!

[havingfitz]

mikemike ---- Last visited: Mon May 16, 2011 1:52 EST pm

Hey mikemike...wtf is the delay? Do you disagree that Cecily is confirmed scum and if not....why no vote. FMPOV if Cecily is not scum then Faraday and Setael BOTH are. Is that what you think?

[Faraday]

BUMPAN for mikemike.

[mikemike778]

mikemike ---- Last visited: Mon May 16, 2011 1:52 EST pm

Hey mikemike...wtf is the delay? Do you disagree that Cecily is confirmed scum and if not....why no vote. FMPOV if Cecily is not scum then Faraday and Setael BOTH are. Is that what you think?

I don't know ... you have been a top suspect for me all game. I'm not ruling you out as some sort of traitor role.

Bub's lack of a hammer indicates to me he doesn't know who his partner is and suspects it could well be Cesily but he could well be wrong. I'd rather not take the chance and lynch Bub and then figure it out tomorrow.

POE is fine but I haven't seen that much scummy about Ces other than her lurkiness which isn't a strong tell in my eyes. It only takes one incorrect town read for it all to fall apart. Bub is scum and should be the pick for today - scum read > POE.

[mikemike778]

I hope it's a chocolate croissant.

No it was Cat

[havingfitz]

mikemike...if you have addressed the fact that you did not attack Pine when he claimed you had not visited anyone (the night you visited Bub) could you please post a link to where.

mikemike...feel free to respond to the question above.

Also, you aren't going to get a Bub lynch. Cecily is focking confirmed scum. There isn't a focking traitor and if there was...scum wouldn't know who it was. The only chance you would have of getting a Bub lynch is to have the player formerly participating known as Cecily vote for him...and then flip Setael AND Faraday to him. I don't think that is going to happen. Whereas if Bub comes online and sees the light...and votes Cecily...then you just look all that more suspicious tomorrow. And I say tomorrow because I think there are three scum (based on Pine's farewell post).

[Bub Bidderskins]

Screw it.

Unvote; vote: Cecily

I wanted to see what Cecily had to say first, but she's obviously trying to lurk her way out of a lynch.

[havingfitz]

I hope for my sanity's sake she is in fact scum. And if there was (by some miracle chance a possibility of Faraday's set up speculation being right) a traitor in the game...game over would be nice.

[Faraday]

Mike/Cecily right? None of you are scum?