00s Band Mafia (Game Over!)

[evilpacman18]

Sheeping and acknowledging that it's sheeping is anti-town town VI play. We're not lynching C-Worl. Tarson picking an easy target noted. I don't understand why Scumhunter didn't claim his song. I want explanation for DH's "Aw hell, I'll do it now." I'm seeing him as town though. Regfan, what's your opinion on the wagon threat on gorilla? And finally. Chesskid. Your kill analysis is bizarre.

[evilpacman18]

Lol @ Cage the Elephant being obscure.

[DemonHybrid]

Cage isn't obscure, but Free Love sure as hell is.

I realized that a mass-name claim was probably a good idea like a few seconds after I posted before my claim. It was more like: Shock (why the hell are people claiming?) and then realization (oh, well I guess it could benefit, so why not).

[DemonHybrid]

Pine: TO said she was female a few times now.

[tarsonisocelot]

Also, TO is male.

No. It says female under my avatar so you don't have to make this mistake.

[gorilla]

So....Pine, C-Worl or gorilla....

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.

Vote: gorilla

. Your votes so far have been midwagon and opportunistic.

Really? Was vote number 2 on Talapus, hardly midwagon especially since I was one of the ones who pushed it the strongest. My other serious votes have been nintendo and tarsonis, both of whom have been legitimately scummy. tarsonis's C-Worl vote, that's actual opportunism right there because she's voting a player who's drawn fire for stupid/VI play and not for actual scumminess from what I see. defense agains Hiraki kill is just WIFOM (much as I hate that term that is what it is). Your vote was better off where it was.

[Scumhunter]

I have 2 songs. Outing either one could out my ability.

[gorilla]

You just outed the fact that you're a power role. Good going.

[Scumhunter]

Thank you.

[DemonHybrid]

Scumhunter, you are so very very dumb. -_-

[chesskid3]

if you hadn
t fucking said that
nnoone would have fucking known

you fucking sack of shit

[tarsonisocelot]

First four, more later/tomorrow. Don't have time to do them all at once due to coursework + sickness. If you have suggestions for formatting or want me to read a particular player next say so. Hope this is helpful.

Scumhunter: Major troll, "quickhammered"(actually put at L-1 while pretending it was a quickhammer) claiming a troll reason, called Regfan on rolefishing then softclaimed a PR while under no pressure.
If you think my stated reason for voting wasn't good consider:

You give a racist troll the hammer on a claim of a black person. And you expect quick hammers NOT to happen. Shame on all of you.

vote Talapus

posted in response to Talapus claiming Rihanna (this was L-1).
Probable scum

Chesskid: Claimed miller, votes nintendo calling him 100% scum without providing reasons. Votes evilpacman for being overreactive, based off reaction to set-up guessing. Calls Gaoth for claiming that having a band formed in the 90's was a scumtell then turning around and nameclaiming Muse.
Quickhammered Talapus with this comment:

Vote: Talapus

very successful day 1 guys this wagon will be great for analysis post flip (tbh i don't even care what the flip is)

Calls the Hiraki kill evidence of either multiple scum, and SK or a vig. Seems a leap of reasoning. Chess seems to be using the 90's game as a frame of reference perhaps more than is useful. Criticizes scumhunter for claiming with no reason. Overall, leaning town.

Gaoth: Begins with Parabollock-alt questions then starts speculating on setup. As mentioned above, calls nintendo scum for claiming a band formed pre-2000 when later claiming Muse. This was bad.
Calls Regfan for suggesting nameclaiming but not doing so - valid point.
No posts yet today. Leaning scum

Regfan: Asks for name-claims - bad, posts an analysis of tells - good. Criticizes those assuming that a Blink-182 claim makes nintendo town for assuming there are no fakeclaims. Another set of tells. Posts an analysis of Talapus' ISO and votes for them. Claims Radiohead, fishing for song/bandclaims. Null

[Parabollocks]

I'm Avenged Sevenfold, my encore performance is "Blinded in chains." >_>

[C-Worl]

Audioslave - "Doesn't Remind Me"

Can we get a list of who's claimed so far so I know who to pass the popcorn to?

[Scumhunter]

I don't think I will be able to post again today. I just wanted to leave an inspirational quote from one of my personal heroes. Kenyan-native and Professional Troll Barack Hussein Obama "My Brethren, troll not merely for the lolz you may receive, but also for the hope of transcending trolling for the win." -Barack Obama, 2001 while planning the 9/11 attacks.

[Regfan]

Spoiler: Day One, Page 9-13

Post #225 by Evilpacman18 - I'm curious as to why you didn't check if this was to my scum/town meta? It's neither actually, trying a new playstyle so I can follow when and why my FoS's change.
Post #227 by Nicodemus - Link to the game where you believed Pine played similarly to this please? He's not playing to the scum meta that I know of him.
Post #233 by Gaoth - As much as I hate to admit it, Gaoth is probably town. I don't see him claiming a band that's not orginally from the 00's as scum, especially when attention was towards him.
Post #236 by Gaoth - Uh. Yeah Gaoth is town, he wouldn't have stated that he didn't instant look up his band as scum.
Post #250 by Gorilla - Ugh. Again questioning my day one reads, not the sort of comment I've ever seen from Town-gorilla.
Post #305 by Gorilla - Need to read this when I'm not so tired, but this seems opportunistic.

Spoiler: Reasoning behind Pine being town

Diddin, sorry I thought I had explained the Pine town-read.
1. He's playing the opposite to how I've seen him play scum in the past.
2. Although I can admit he has done some questionable plays, his overall demeanor is of geninue scumhunting.
3. His defence of C-Worl reads as legitimate, I don't think Pinescum would defend C-Worltown and I don't see them as scum together leaving Pine to be town.
4. The fact he openely stated he wanted to discuss or was waiting for something from the mod reads as a town-tell, mafia very rarely admit to having side-discussions with the mod because they later become forced to out what it was about.
5. The fact he believed that your main performance song led towards if you were a town-power role or not, mafia would have had to have one power-role between them thus knowing that power roles are an encore song, not the main performance.

Spoiler: Day Two, Page 14-16

Post #334 by Pine - No it doesn't, you're saying there was no scum kill which I highly doubt.
Post #342 by Chesskid - Liking the defence of Tarson to be honest. People are jumping on him without considering other options.
Post #344 by Nintendo - How do you not realize the irony here? You're sheeping a lynch on someone because they sheeped the previous lynch.
Post #345 by Diddin - I can agree with this.
Post #350 by Gorilla [/B] - As much as I can understand this vote coming from you, surely you realize the harm that such a quick wagon puts on the town this early into a day.
Post #353 by Chesskid - Link to the game please?
Post #359 by Pine - As stated earlier, this reads as a town-slip.
Post #365 by DemonHybrid - Confusion over what's going on reads as a slight town-tell, scum are likely have discussed this scenario at some point last night.
Post #370 by Tarsonicelt - DemonHybrid has already gone into this. The biggest town-tell in this post is the fact that Tarsonisoclet is claiming a fairly unknown song. Sure he may have claimed 'An unknowish band so he couldn't be counter claimed' by what reasoning would their be for not picking their main song "Ain't no rest for the wicked" if he was faking?
Post #372 by DemonHybrid - Townpoints for him for pointing out the above logic.
Post #386 by Tarsoncielt - Oddly enough I agree with a lot of this.

Tarsoncielt, explain what part of name claiming is "bad".
C-Worl, you said that you attained results by watching what occured early on in day one, I want those results now.
Scumhunter, expecting some legitimate reads and reasons from you very soon.

Spoiler: Claims so far

Gaoth: Muse - Knights of Cydonia
Regfan: Radiohead - Knives Out
Pine: Three Doors Down - Be Like That
DemonHybrid: Green Day - 21 Guns
Scumhunter: Queens of the Stone Age - ?
Tarsoniocelt: Cage the Elephant - Free Love
Parabollocks: Avenged Sevenfold - "Blinded in chains
C-Worl: Audioslave - Doesn't Remind Me
Nintendo: Blink 182 - Roller Coaster
Chesskid: Eninem - ?

Players still to claim: Nicodemus, Diddin, evilpacman18, Chesskids Song, Scumhunters Song.

Town (From strongest to weakest):

Chesskid, Pine, Diddin, Tarsonisocelot, Goath, C-Worl, Evilpacman18, DemonHybrid.

Null:

Parabollocks, Scumhunter.

Scum (From strongest to weakest):

Nicodemus, Nintendo, Gorilla.

Vote: Nicodemus

[C-Worl]

Thank you.

EPM go.

Also Chess and Scumhunter need to finish the claims they started on.

And it's spelled Eminem not Eninem.

[evilpacman18]

Kings of Leon - Birthday

[C-Worl]

Kings of Leon - Birthday

Pass the popcorn

[evilpacman18]

diddin next

[evilpacman18]

Regfan your list misses gorilla's claim or that he needs to claim if he hasn't.

[Parabollocks]

Hiraki was not a town shot

i agree with this 100%, Hiraki was more of a threat to scum then town, the main piece to the puzzle is figuring out why Hiraki was the scum shot, or who would've shot him.

also after re-reading i'm gonna go to the grave with these reads.

100% Town, no doubt about it in my mind: Regfan, Diddin, Chesskid3, Pine, taron

i'm unsure about my other reads, i need to go through it again, but the above reads will never change.

[DemonHybrid]

Why diddin and Pine? I agree with the other 3 (and Scumhunter, no matter how dense he is)

[Parabollocks]

Diddin because what talapus did was pretty damn scummy and he just looks pretty town to me, i guess.

Pine because at first i was weary about C-worl and him but most of his posts have been coming off town to me, i can go more in-depth if you like.

[Scumhunter]

I refuse to claim my main song or my encore song.