Vi wrote:
I'm not sure I agree, but regardless there's someone missing in this analysis.
I still feel that Faraday is town.
Anyway, after doing the write up on Sloth, I've decided that I should probably do the same for DY, Vi and Faraday, the first two because I currently think that they are likely scum, and Faraday because if he's scum, then just about everything I am thinking is doomed to be wrong. On that note, I'll start with Faraday.
Faraday:
His early play, in retrospect, wasn't particularly townie: he voted for Quilford without providing a reason. He drew attention to Jules without explicitly calling her scum, commenting:
Faraday wrote:Pre-apology: Some of this is out of order because I saw a couple things, noted them and then re-read the first 3 pages in more detail.
Is a little weird too.
However, he definitely was scum-hunting. He tried to determine if Hiplop was town or not, by trying to see if Hiplop would sheep his town read of Neuky.
Just because it might be useful, I'm going to keep track of his town reads. He decided that TS, Sloth, Charter and Hiplop were town (or at least townish) fairly early.
Faraday wrote:
I'd have probably voted quilford for his first 2 posts, they appear like he's trying too hard to settle in the game, this is the same reason I later asked him the 'are you nervous' question, as that's pretty much how it came across to me, that he was uncomfortale and trying to settle in to the game. Vi's right, in that it seems like the response scum would be more likely to make, I'd have thought he'd have well just told me to fuck off, more-so.
I haven't really liked anything he's done since then either tbh, so yeah, wagonwagon on the wall who's the fairest of them all.
He finally gave a reason for voting for Quilford, and I don't particularly care for it because he was trying to push a lynch on RVS reasons which is never too good. He also said that there were other things, but never clarified wbat they were.
Faraday wrote:
hey empy, what do you think of twistedspoon?
This post makes little sense coming from scum. It would be addressing a townie to put suspicion on to a scum buddy.
Fake investigation test of Hiplop. Unless they are scum together, this essentially clears Hiplop.
The things that bother me about his play are his push on Quilford without giving his reasons, and the fact that his reads have been fairly fixed since early in the game; the only one that seems to have fluctuated is his read of Hiplop. Also his read of Quilford changed after Quilford's claim. On the other hand, he is definitely scum hunting, and I agree with his choices of town reads (which makes me feel better about the fact that his reads have remained stable). I don't think that the question to Empking that I just mentioned makes sense coming from scum. I may as well that additionally add that his opinions seem genuine to me, which gives me a gut town read of him.
The bottom line is that I think he's town.
Anyway, I'll do DY and Vi this weekend.
) post explained, hes the odd one out. But the whole charter thing makes me kind of believe him.. AHH :\