Bunnylover wrote:
Can't I just already tell you I'm town therefore we don't spend 5 pages determining if I am town or scum?
Okay.
Implosion's early play has been bad. He showed up to make a pointless non-scumhunting vote and justified it by saying he's hoping to figure out who is the other head of the Soben hydra. To me this reads like a completely pointless exercise and is obvious coasting through RVS.
Crymeariver's dismissal of the early game is bad, and seems like an excuse to avoid commenting on things, but I also think that his scum-slip could have come from town or scum. Chesskid, what made you think that he is town?
On that note, I think that WrathChild is scummy for not commenting on the scumslip. He posted soon after it was pointed out, and it seems to me like it would have been a natural thing to comment on.
inHim, why the town read on Beefster?
IceyC wrote:
CAN WE PLEASE DO THIS DRAM-MINI STYLE??
What does this mean?
I don't object to people posting town-reads in general, but I don't understand why Soben is bothering to post town reads that are so weak that even though they have a town read on IceyC, they aren't willing to back it up by voting him as he's asked.
Pine reads as scum to me. His early posts are a mess. He calls for the vigging of IceyC, and says that he is the only suspicious person in the game, but he doesn't follow it though with a vote. Then asks for Gandalf to be vigged, and as soon as Gandalf takes issue with it, Pine takes the trouble to retract the vig request. He also didn't vote Gandalf. These sorts of interactions makes me think that he was pretending that the vig request was serious, but was never actually suspicious of these people.
Pine wrote:
Toying with jumping on the CMAR wagon, but my gut says something's just off about the whole thing.
Do you think CMAR scumslipped?
Pine wrote:
Only if Icey is something other than Town, which you already stated you think they are. So, which is it? Compliance commensurate with your earlier confidence, or fabricated reads?
PE: Ninja'd slightly, though InHim made an observation instead of an analysis.
Here he is making sure that he get's credit for his posting.
Pine wrote:
the "No one on my wagon is solidly Town" bit was a red flag.
I feel that this attack on SCR is bad because I don't think that not having strong town reads at this point in the game is a red flag.
LMP is playing aggressively early, which is something that I remember him doing as town.