Mini 1170: Nowhereville Mafia '11- Over!

[PJ.]

Okay guys, we're getting off track. Everyone give your read on earworm, if you think he is scummy, throw your vote on him. If you don't explain why.

[SleepyKrew]

Panzer, "throwing your vote" would hammer.

[PJ.]

Yeah, I want reasons as to why he isn't hammered. NS can catch up during night so that reason is invalid.

[charter]

Yeah, I think an Earworm hammer would be swell right now.

[earworm]

@charter
Missed 479. I'm not making a big deal out of it. 517 provides no substantive empirics to show correlation so I'm going to ignore that.

@elfen
When have I made a big deal out of nothing?

unvote

Why the unvote?

@ear
Wouldn't it be scummier if I said "Oh yesh, he's hella scum, def lynch him." after the town has already made the decision?

Yeah, but that's not what I said. You have a read on me when you really, really shouldn't. Gut town reads should not exist.

[SleepyKrew]

And why not ear? A gut read lead us to where Kalofer is now (why isn't he the main wagon, btw?).
Panzer and charter, no.

[PJ.]

Why not?

[SleepyKrew]

We wait for NS.

[PJ.]

Why? He'll have three days to catch up. There is no reason other than stalling to wait for NS.

[SleepyKrew]

His opinions may sway today's vote. Stop being so daft o.o

[PJ.]

I seriously doubt that. at this point, i think the scumteam could be you, ear, and NS. It seems like your stalling so you and NS can make a play at saving your buddy. Quinn's actions do suggest that he could be your scumbuddy.

[SleepyKrew]

I've already said I'm waiting on NS so I can hammer... Honestly...

[PJ.]

There is no reason to wait. Hammer.

[Midnight's Sorrow]

Vote Count D-1 #12

(2) Kalofer- hiplop, LordChronos

(1) The Kool- earworm

(6) earworm- Espeonage, Panzerjager, CooLskins, charter, The Kool, Kalofer

(1) charter- SleepyKrew

(3) Not voting- Nobody Special, Elfen, cloudocean

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline is June 3rd, Midnight Central.

[SleepyKrew]

No.

[Nobody Special]

Panzer, chill. I'm pretty sure I'll be finished before bed tonight.

hiplop, half an hour to read 21 pages? You didn't do much scumhunting, did you?

FoS: hiplop

[PJ.]

Where you at, NS?

[Espeonage]

Unvote, vote: Panzer

Reread what you have read in the last page and make a nice little case on why you aren't scum and if I like I won't try and derail Ear's wagon.

[Nobody Special]

I also want to say that now that I've thought it over, I can see how townhunting CAN be useful, but not at this point. The ratio of town to mafia makes it an impossibly large process of elimination. I think it's much better to start with scumhunting.

I know I can't ask Quinn about this directly, but it just seems as though he

knows

precisely how many mafia there are. How does he know this? As a townie, I don't. He must be scum.

I've explained plenty.

NeEvil is also scum. Yay metas

Can you elaborate?

I just want to say that I'm at page 10, but with the thing I found Quinn saying, added together with a quick iso of earworm, I'm ready for the day to end if you guys are.

Hammer when ready; I'll keep reading.

[Nobody Special]

Oh, Espe unvoted. Well then.

Vote: earworm

L-1. I won't hammer because I'm still reading, but I won't be sad if the hammer is dropped.

[The Kool]

That's WIFOM, and while I don't have much against WIFOM (depending on the type of WIFOM) you're being a hypocrite here because I've been acting blatantly scummy yet you think I'm scum.

The difference lies between 'one scummy moment' and 'consistently scummy'. Panzer is shifting to the latter the more he talks, IMO.

I like simple WIFOM, but if you start taking it too far or ridiculously in any other manner, it is a hindrance to the town, by obfuscating their reads. On the other hand, my sadistic side thoroughly enjoys a good WIFOM, especially when I'm scum.

[PJ.]

Unvote, vote: Panzer

Reread what you have read in the last page and make a nice little case on why you aren't scum and if I like I won't try and derail Ear's wagon.

Oh, Espe unvoted. Well then.

Vote: earworm

L-1. I won't hammer because I'm still reading, but I won't be sad if the hammer is dropped.

Clearly I was correct, and we were just wasting our time. The hammer could have been dropped and NS would have had no opinion on it. The correct play is earworm. It's been earworm. And he should have been hammered a while ago. Also, the burden of evidence is on the accuser espeonage.

[Kalofer]

I'd also like to wait for NS and hiplop to finish reading and say what they have to say before hammering earworm. The lynch is there, where's the rush? So my view is that since sleepy suddenly started acting so defensively around the earworm wagon and stopped being so aggressive because of it then if earworm flips scum, sleepy is probably one of his partners.

I think Quin is a townie that made a mistake, and that there are bigger fish to fry. Ear isn't clear, of course. Nobody is.

No gut here in this post, so the first part is a lie and the second part is completely irrelevant but even more, it's entirely inconsistent with a player of your aggressive nature.

I understand the argument on Quin. Mostly. Though I disagree, he did indeed act scummy.

Understanding the argument on quin is not a hard thing to do but why do you disagree? For that matter why do you disagree that kool is scum? In fact besides me who the hell else do you even find scummy?

[charter]

Well, Espeonage just jumped ahead of Cloud as the most likely buddy for Earworm and Sleepy.

[Elfen]

Well, shall I cast my vote and hammer away?