So my current omfgobvtown reads are: Vi, Gamma, Juls, Mykonian, and... wait for it... Amrun. I bet only one of these is a surprise. Vi is a dayvig. Vi hit scum. Vi is town. Gamma's town for :goodposting: like in [redacted]. Juls is someone my instinct says not to trust. Might just be the fact my last game with her I didn't have any good interactions with her on a not-quite-game-related level, so bad memories etc. More trusting everybody else here on this one because I think I've got bias. Myko's calling of RC scum earlier in cmbnation with the lack of a fake feeling surrounding his push on EK = solid town read. Amrun's probably the explanation you guys want, and here it is: amrun has been one of the incarnations of actively posting reads an providing content this game. She's replied rather well to the amounts of pressure place on her, and I can't really understand what the case on her even is to begin with.
Slight town reads: AGM, GreyICE. I've experience with both of them. They both give me the squishy good feeling that means I want to punch GreyICE and tell him to shut up even though I know he's town and means well while I just roll my eyes at AGM and don't even feel like I should bother.
Needless to say, I don't have the best of experiences with them but yeah... still think they're town.
For my null reads: Magister Ludi, Maxous, Inhim, Elvis, Kats, DK and Iece. ML's initial stuff bugged me but I fee that his posting's improved over time. Maxous' posting is too far an few between for me to really get a firm grasp on how I feel about him. Inhim's presence this game has been really low but lack of experience with him means I dunno the alignment tell on that (trusting Vi n this would put Inhim as leaning scum by the by). On EK, gut says town, myko (town read) says otherwise. I don't consider myself the strongest scumhunter, so they nullify each other. Kats has been... kats. Initially, DK was on my scum list, but I feel less like he's scum after reading his iso. The fact his presence hs been low is fine when contrasted with his posts actually having smething to them rather than being words. I feel like Iece has really tunneled
hard
on ML in the past but his read-over posting was nice, and I want to see his play now that he isn't going "omfg omfg ml must die omfg" all the time.
Leaning scum: C-worl (only
leaning
here because I'm trying to trust Vi's word on this a bit more than my own) and BBros. C-worl's lacked content in 90% of his posts. His strongest "content" posts are... trying to convince toasty to not nominate gamma to win. I'm having a hard time seeing how he has any town logic here, but I guess he
is
a bit dim. I want to see some actual reads out of him, though. BB has a strange contrast when I read through his iso. His main large posts read rather competent but then when I read his smaller ones I get the feeling of someone who's at least seeming ignorant when it comes to how to play. The contrast really sets me on edge, which is why he's here. Feels like the newbie feeling Im getting is deliberate and faked.
Scum: DUM.
DUM's posting across the board is just unutterably bad except for
this post. They've come in mostly taking either light pot shots or doing absolutely nothing. They even go
"You didn't state reasoning, omg!" and then fail to state reasoning for their own list. The double standard just really sticks. Also feel the exception to their bad posting is fine but the follow up on the reads given is... non-existent really. They just make
posts like these and seem to adjust their "reads" on people based upon whether they suspect toasty. The super strong push there reads like fake tunneling in an attempt to not have to back up anything else about what they say (not that they've said much anyway...).
