ooba at 2222 wrote:I do not oppose this lynch;
This is in regards to Gandalf
ooba at 2223 wrote:But all this conflicts with my town read on Gandalf - ya, I know I can be wrong but I was sure of it
These back to back posts don’t make sense. If you have a Town read on Gandalf that you are quite sure of you should definitely be opposed to his lynch.
My paranoia about ooba is rising.
ooba wrote:One of the reasons the Chess-AGM-Agar scum team made sense was because if there are two scum teams, most mods prefer to use symmetry i.e trying to balance them out in numbers and power .. Which is why I preferred 3-3 over any other combination
The one downside to your symmetry argument is that AGM as scum would mean very likely Town has NO protective roles (unless they lie languishing in the graveyard with either SnowBunny or Plum). I honestly don’t see a set-up that has two scum protective roles and zero Town protective roles.
--
Shadow wrote:Looking at the claims and what we know Alma could well be scum.
Maybe he's really a scum doc. That he, contrary to AV and Moth, really used his super when said to have done so does not at all imply he's town. If he was scum about to die and if his super was really a protect he had all reason to use it, anyway.
I understand your thoughts be read my response to a similar ooba post above. AGM-scum pretty much requires Town to have no defending roles. I don’t see that as a very strong likelihood.
--
Gandalf wrote:And actually, that would be a horrible Cop philosophy, and you saying it would be a good one contradicts YET AGAIN with you earlier in the game saying that you should cop people who are going to be a powerful force for town.
No, you have no idea what you are talking about. Copping hard to read players is absolutely win. [REDACTED] proves it.
Gandalf wrote:MoI is NOT playing like town MoI, btw. He's getting far too irritated.
Here’s a fun exercise – how do you know how Town MoI plays via direct experience? Please provide links so we can discuss why your meta isn't valid.
Gandalf wrote:Look at how many people died without claiming and tell me again that that proves he's town. Not to mention it could easily be a scum role causing it.......
Cognitive Dissonance Alert – Whoop whoop whooop
Gandalf has spent the better part of this day yelling “there is no reason Town couldn’t have double Powers” in reaction to his Execution ability being called scummy. Yet look at the reaction when someone else makes an argument that LC’s power is Town based.
1. Too many people are dead and didn’t counterclaim.
2. It could easily be a scum role causing it.
He’s picking and choosing his arguments based on what suits him. Not based on a logical assessment.
--
Gemini’s soft call out of me as scum in 2225 and subsequent back-track in 2229 is scummy. Furthermore note 2229 – when directly asked who is scum by Shadow they dodge and weave about giving any reads other than Gandalf, the leading wagon.
Gemini wrote:It just raised my hackles in this post when he suddenly got so worried about our double vote. He seemed to be implying that now that we have a double vote, we need to die so he can live longer. I would sacrifice myself for the town to get a real advantage, but I'm not so pleased to do it just so a hated townie can live one day longer.
[/quote]
Oh, so suggesting you (who I have as possible lurking scum and a good fit for a Gandalf partner) would be a better lynch than myself (who I know is 100% Town) when I’m not a MYLO liability (as said post discussed) is scummy? I want to be clear on your thought process.
"I am a leaf on the wind ... watch how I soar!"
Pretty much Geriatric game restricted at this point ... unless there are players I REALLY want to play with.
