Received my prod. Sorry about the two day absence. Am helping someone move today, so don't know when I will be able to post, but I will try as hard as I can to get a chance today. I will respond to a few posts now, but am already running late.
silverbullet999 wrote:For the longest time, the only evidence that you supplied was that he had a serious vote. That is not a scumtell at all. When asked what about it made it scummy, your response was essentially "because it is."
I explained that I found it suspicious and thought it was best to look more into. I never said AHA HE'S SCUM BECAUSE HE'S CLARTIFYING THAT HIS VOTE IS IMPORTANT.
Yes, but
why
is that suspicious? Nevermind, we are just talking around in circles here, and this is producing nothing productive.
silverbullet999 wrote:I further explained this down the road, his posts in between at that time didn't mean anything to me.
And later still you said you had found more things to be suspicious of. I never understood it much.
silverbullet999 wrote:I want to seriously hit you with a fucking rock repeatedly. THERE'S NOT FUCKING MISUNDERSTANDING
SubzeroSith wrote:silver wrote:
If my questions are dumb and you answering them shows me to be even MORE scummy. Why the fuck would they NOT be worth responding to?
They were minute and pointless. It isn't as if I don't have enough reason to think you're scum.
He is Admitting he was lazy to get more reasons to think i'm scum right there.
Again, you seem to be misreading it. And again, talking in circles - unproductive.
silverbullet999 wrote:HOW... HOW would I possible know.. OK These guys are scum and These guys are town. Did you NOT Completely Ignore how I hated There Will Be Bloodshed because I'm hesitant to call anyone town because i don't want the same thing happening again? Jesus
But you should be trying to find out. You should be saying that this person looks scummy for such and such and this person look more townie for such and such. No absolutes, but more than just, they voted for me so are scum.
silverbullet999 wrote:I already looked at all of your posts. That's why I was accusing you of exactly what you are admitting to.
I meant on the whole forum... -_-
Ah! Well... that doesn't mean much. Or maybe... how many games were you in at this time?
mastin2 wrote:Nhammen wrote:There were a few pieces of silver's actions that didn't add up with him being scum
Explain. I sure as heck can find some, but I don't see any evidence in your posts showing you not seeing pure scum. If that makes sense.
In other words. List everything which you saw that didn't add up with him being scum.
Three things:
The OMGUS, while it can come from scum, tends to come from townies more often.
The hanging on to his initial posts after they had been identified as scummy.
The self-vote.
I had presented one reasoning for the OMGUS (as fluff), but that seemed kinda off to me.
On closer examination, I determined the second is a personality tell (I have seen it before in previous games from MonkeyMan, and that player did it equally as both town and scum).
Both the OMGUS and the self-vote can be explained as WIFOM. ALthough, now that I think about it, I'm not sure if silver is the type of player to do WIFOM like this. Hmmm...
mastin2 wrote:Your read on nhammen is pretty much what I see as well. For not just against Silver, but also the whole game, essentially.
I... really? I didn't think I had been doing that with anyone other than silver. I noticed myself doing it with silver, but when I presented my cases he responded with "no I wasn't," so my only response was to say "yeah you were."
) As is Toon. And Jmurph, obviously. (And naturally me.)
