Juls wrote:[1: This reads as if you are going to piggyback someone elses argument.]
[2:If you have evidence, present it. I can think of no reason to keep this information to yourself.]
1:
Setting up to piggyback an argument that hadn't been made yet? How could I know that someone would attack Kalofer or Oopidstay after I did? This point doesn't make any sense and for that reason I don't know how to defend against it.
2:
I can think of several reasons:
A. Not giving my reasons means that I get to see who will actually agree with my suspicion without piggybacking my reasoning.
B. I believe that not giving any reasons increases the amount of pressure: the person that has been voted doesn't know how strongly I suspect them or why. All they do know is that I suspect them.
I'm curious about this comment. According to your join date, you have been playing mafia longer than I have. I find it hard to believe that you haven't encountered reasonless suspicions from town before.
Juls wrote:Wait, I thought Kaloofer and Oopid were scum? Surely you don't think its 3 scum in a 9 player game?
unvote, vote wicked
Somethings not jiving here....
I don't think there are three scum in this game (my guess would be that there are two), but I also never said Twistedspoon was scum. In addition, there's no way I could know for certain that Kalofer and Oopidstay are scum at this stage, so of course I could be wrong. Just because I say I believe two players are scum doesn't mean I can't find another player's actions strange.
I think this is a really weak point.
Juls wrote:Also, good posting by plague.
This seems like a strange comment to make coming from you. I'm not saying I disagree with the comment, but considering you had
just
been voting implosion for buddying, this seems a bit hypocritical. Especially since you seem to disagree with him on a few reads.
Now that Juls has answered my question directed at her, I think that her previous vote for Oopidstay seems a bit suspicious. Voting somebody because they self voted isn't suspicious alone, but considering that she kept her vote on him even after
she acknowledged that he hadn't encountered any self votes in his previous games, I find it a bit strange.
FoS: Juls
for
&
.
More later.
"You miss 100% of the shots you don't take. -Wayne Gretzky"
-Wickedestjr