ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[Benmage]

I agree with Magua, nexus is reading town. The vote switchers from MoI to nexus blow.

[ooba]

Vote Count

LynchMePls (2)

- Locke Lamora, MagnaofIllusion

MagnaofIllusion (8)

- DrippingGoofball, LynchMePls, Hinduragi, SpyreX, Kast, Bilbo Baggins, vezokpiraka, Benmage

SaintKerrigan (1)

- Maemuki

Maemuki (1)

- Magua

Magua (2)

- AlmasterGM, Empking

Nexus (5)

- Lost Butterfly, Thor665, Setael, SaintKerrigan, hasdgfas

Not Voting (1)

- Nexus

With 20 alive, it takes 11 to lynch!

[DrippingGoofball]

Yeah, Nexus is town.

CAN'T YOU SEE THAT MoI IS STALLING CLAIM????????????????????????????????????????

[Empking]

Yeah, Nexus is totally town.

[DrippingGoofball]

Nexus, please revote MoI.

He is pulling his hair out creating the perfect fakeclaim.

Players that ignore "

claim or die

" ARE ALWAYS SCUM and I've been playing this game long time.

[DrippingGoofball]

One more vote for MoI and he's back at L-2.

CLAIM OR DIE AND DO IT NOW SCUM

[hasdgfas]

unvote
vote MoI

I still don't like that from Nexus, but after thinking about it, MoI is more of a priority

[Hinduragi]

Yeah, Nexus is town.

CAN'T YOU SEE THAT MoI IS STALLING CLAIM????????????????????????????????????????

Like I said, DGB just has all my reads. Also, this Nexus situation holding up our scum lynch is annoying. If you're town, stop looking at the scum alternative to bussing and get the hell back over here.

[Lost Butterfly]

Cow: What do you think of hypocrisy. Scumtell y/n?

Benmage: thoughts on cow, magua and SaintKerrigan please.

Hey Magua! Is Hinduragi town?

[hasdgfas]

Cow: What do you think of hypocrisy. Scumtell y/n?

It really depends on the situation. Sometimes yes, other times no.

[Thor665]

I agree with Magua, nexus is reading town. The vote switchers from MoI to nexus blow.

You mean...Cow? He was the only one.

Also, why so laid back this game? Did they finally give you the right medication or something? With an MoI run Day 1 I sort of expected you to be diddling his skull and laughing uproariously the entire time as you quaffed beer, instead we get...whatever this is. Whassup?

[SpyreX]

Good lord.

Nexus is town.
MoI is stalling.
Of that myriad of hopping votes SK's needs a bullet.

[Bilbo Baggins]

Good lord.

Nexus is town.
MoI is stalling.
Of that myriad of hopping votes SK's needs a bullet.

QFFT

More later, just wanted to support this.

[DrippingGoofball]

***tapping fingers***

***stretching rope***

[Benmage]

Benmage: thoughts on cow, magua and SaintKerrigan please.

Idno. I'm read to page 5.

From the little phone skimming...Not liking cow..SK meh. Liking Magua.

I agree with Magua, nexus is reading town. The vote switchers from MoI to nexus blow.

You mean...Cow? He was the only one.

Also, why so laid back this game? Did they finally give you the right medication or something? With an MoI run Day 1 I sort of expected you to be diddling his skull and laughing uproariously the entire time as you quaffed beer, instead we get...whatever this is. Whassup?

Your experience with me, must be more limited than I thought.

What are you even asking here??? Why am I not mocking, or gloating over MoI??

When have I ever acted like that?

[Benmage]

Oh and, I guess pretty much not just the vote switcher(Cow)...but all the votes that had recently piled onto nexus....Blew.

[AlmasterGM]

Nexus #365-367 are overly defensive given the situation.

...and then the votes just PILE on like candy. If MoI flips scum, we can definitely find scum in this little mini wagon that started.

I'm still maintaining that Magua is a way better lynch for today. MoI is stalling, though. If you log into MS via phone on vacation and find yourself at L-1, you CLAIM, not offer a random scumread on a lurker. If you can read the thread closely enough to read Kast, you can read closely enough to claim it up.

I still like Magua for today, though.

[Benmage]

I still like Magua for today, though.

Can you bullet why?

[AlmasterGM]

For why he's scummy - read the thread. He's obviously just as, if not more scummy than MoI, and pretty much nobody disputes this (most of the arguments are things like, "he's CR and less of a threat"). As for why he should be lynched OVER MoI - 1) MoI is a strong town player, whereas Magua is relatively useless. If we mislynch MoI it's a pretty big shot in the foot, whereas lynching Magua doesn't hurt us that much. 2) There are lots more interactions surrounding Magua in the early game (specifically with Maemuki and SaintKerrigan), whereas MoI is being called out on this one isolated post. 3) MoI is loud and will always be on the table as an option. He can be dealt with later or through night actions. Magua will fall off the radar and always be the guy everyone wants dead, but never wants to waste time on. He should be lynched now before he can hide.

[Benmage]

For why he's scummy - read the thread. He's obviously just as, if not more scummy than MoI, and pretty much nobody disputes this (most of the arguments are things like, "he's CR and less of a threat").

Wow whose saying CR is less of a threat?? CR is the number 1 threat…. Whose saying otherwise? 'Nobody disputes hes just as scummy as MoI'…yet has 2 votes…
-Also I wouldn’t call Magua terrible at all.

Magua will fall off the radar and always be the guy everyone wants dead, but never wants to waste time on. He should be lynched now before he can hide.

This is malarkey.

I really dislike the shitty answers like “read the thread” .. That has to my one of my biggest peeves in this game. Because 99% of the people who call other people scummy. Have no fucking clue what they are talking about. And when asked about it they only say irate things or crap like “read the thread”….Logic and Analysis eludes these people.

Can’t you bullet for me why he is scummy?

[Magua]

Hey Magua! Is Hinduragi town?

He's null-to-scum. Fine, rational, hasn't really taken a stance that puts him outside of the mainstream yet. Gutread says "playing it safe" which results in mild scumminess.

For why he's scummy - read the thread. He's obviously just as, if not more scummy than MoI, and pretty much nobody disputes this (most of the arguments are things like, "he's CR and less of a threat").

Bilbo Baggins is the only saying that I'm the cult recruiter and should be ignored until D2. I like your use of "arguments", plural, though.

As for why he should be lynched OVER MoI - 1) MoI is a strong town player, whereas Magua is relatively useless. If we mislynch MoI it's a pretty big shot in the foot, whereas lynching Magua doesn't hurt us that much.

2) There are lots more interactions surrounding Magua in the early game (specifically with Maemuki and SaintKerrigan), whereas MoI is being called out on this one isolated post.

So my interactions with two people (one of whom I think is scum) is "lots more" than the interactions people have had with MoI?

That seems...incorrect.

Now, I think the MoI is not the best lynch, or I would've hammered him. But your point here bears little actual resemblance to the truth, and seems smushed to fit into a hole rather than being a natural fit. If you think MoI is town, and don't want to see him lynched because of that, that's fine; I can dig that. But trying to upplay my lynch by saying I have "lots more interactions" than MoI does is just patently false.

[Locke Lamora]

Reading some of this thread is like pulling teeth. Only more painful. Scummy things that jump out at me:

-SK's vote hop reads as very forced and over-justified.
-Cow's hop on and off the Nexus wagon screams of riding the prevailing mood.
-Almaster's pushing for Magua over MoI based on connections shortly after lining up lynches based on MoI's flip and the Nexus mini-wagon is ridiculous, and overall his reasons for Magua over MoI are incredibly weak.
-Hinduragi's repeated DGB-sheeping is beginning to look very much like he doesn't have any ideas of his own.
-Magua seems like he's spending a whole lot more time explaining why lynches aren't a good idea than he does actually pushing lynches of his own.

MoI does seem genuinely annoyed to me. I guess he could be annoyed because he's been caught by a case that he thinks is nonsense, but I'm not really buying the 'stalling for a claim' argument. Knowing MoI and having played with him recently as scum, he's pretty quick off the mark, doesn't take that long to come up with fakeclaims, and if he was going to bother to post from his holiday, I would have thought that as scum, he'd come up with one beforehand, not draw the inevitable heat from posting and not claiming. And on that note...

Unvote; Vote: Magua

My bad vibe from LMP's earlier statement hasn't gone away, but I'm having a hard time articulating that into something concrete that people aren't just going to summarily dismiss with 'hey Locke your case sucks', so I'll put that on the back-burner for now.

[Empking]

Magua will fall off the radar and always be the guy everyone wants dead, but never wants to waste time on. He should be lynched now before he can hide.

This. Just this.

[DrippingGoofball]

Magua will be vig'ed.

I Magua is not vig'ed, I will have kittens.

[DrippingGoofball]

EBWOP SPAM

"

IF

Magua is not vig'ed"