New York 131: Tricycle Mafia (Day 5)

[Pine]

WTF? Neither of them are claimed power roles. Jmurph is essentially just a VT now, and NS is unknown and not actually confirmed.

You're right, Mastin. You're really obvious as scum.

[Toon Fighter]

I am no longer confirmed town?

[Pine]

You never were. Mastin is full of shit

[mastin2]

Toon, you're confirmed town to ME.
But Jmurph and NS are confirmed town to OTHERS.

And Pine, my reasoning's pretty simple. A potential PR who may or may not be real. If the scum kill you, that means they're legitimately afraid of you. If they don't, it either means you're scum, or that they're hoping to mislynch you as scum.

Think about that for a second. I can't explain why this is important without ruining the effectiveness of this move. But I have a good reason to believe that--if the doctor is NOT on you--whether you live or die will further our ability to nail the remaining scum. The key is in my wording above. See if you can figure it out for yourself. It's something I believe that town'd know instinctively, but that scum can't figure out. ('Least, I'm HOPING it is something only town can figure out. )

Call it another gambit if you'd like. But a protective role--if existing--should NOT be on you, Pine. Let the scum have the option of killing you if they really want to. I, personally, don't think they will, but I am curious as to what they'll do.

[Pine]

Your idea is asinine, Mastin. If I get killed, it proves WHAT? That I WAS a threat after all? Oh well, now we know we can trust Pine, but he's dead, so THE THREAT IS ENDED. It's like you said "Don't protect the Cop that doesn't have any results yet. If he dies, we'll know we can trust his future results."

What shitty logic.

[mastin2]

...Apparently not. Pine, you're not getting it. Look closer. You're reading too much into one part while forgetting the other(s).

[Pine]

I know exactly what you're getting at, Mastin. I just think it's stupid to play those games and disagree with you.

Bah. We'll discuss it in post-game. Suffice to say I think your logic I flawed and perhaps born of scummy intent.

[mastin2]

Well, then, I'll again say I'm not positive you're seeing what I am, based on your original reaction.

What I see is a lack of protection on you being a gamebreaker in our favor.

[Maxous]

But--just for the sake of argument--let's say you DO flip town. Well, then, we know there's likely one scum on you. (I wouldn't think both would risk it on a town lynch at this stage in the game. Too risky, since after the mislynch, we WOULD be analyzing the wagon.) And one of those names is Zepher. See where this is going?

Before I adress the rest - this is important.
Why is Zepher scum from our interaction when I flip town?

[MrZepher]

Because he's Mastin scum and probably wants to lynch as many town as possible
previously stated.

The only thing on you is that you have a little bit more suspicion on you than just what Mastin has brought up about our "interaction"

[mastin2]

Uh, Zepher? I didn't understand any of that.

And for Maxous. Like I said, interactions are hard to explain.

(Sorry, incoherent right now.)

[jmurph3]

@Mod: Can we get an updated votecount?

[Pine]

I was under the impression that was a lynch.

[Toon Fighter]

What was a lynch? to my accounts, Max is still at L-1

[mastin2]

Yeah, so was I. L-1.

[Pine]

Good god, people. Way to fail.

I expect better out of you, especially Mastin.

Fake hammer /fail

[Maxous]

Do you think I don't know how many votes are on me Pine?

I could explain what is wrong about Mastin's #960 but I should'nt have to.

[quadz08]

Votronic

With 10 players alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

jmurph3 (0) –
silverbullet999 (1) – nhammen,
mastin2 (1) – Maxous
nhammen (1) – silverbullet999
Pine (1) – Nobody Special
MrZepher (1) –
Nobody Special (0) -
Uite (0) -
Toon Fighter (1) – Uite

L-1 -->

Maxous (5)–Toon Fighter, jmurph3, mastin2, Pine, MrZepher

Not Voting (0) –

Deadline is in (expired on 2011-06-09 23:00:00)

[silverbullet999]

VOTE: mastin

I don't see the maxous case, also it sort of occured to me that mastin came in today saying we must lynch either me or pine and we'll win... now that's changed in the same day.... disturbs me.

[Pine]

I'd accept Mastin today, Maxous tomorrow (or vig), but aren't we approaching deadline?

[silverbullet999]

Deadline is in (expired on 2011-06-09 23:00:00)

[Pine]

For this slow-ass, indecisive Town, that's pretty close to deadline.

[silverbullet999]

OH THE BLOODY THING IS LITERALLY A COUNTDOWN!! THAT'S AWESOME!

*ahem*

Touche

[jmurph3]

Alright friends, here;s how this is going. I'm drunk. Awesome, I nknow. Additionally, I am literally the only one guarantteed to flip town. Which means I;m probs gone tomorrow. Basically, here's how this plays out: either I, as confirmed town, or pine, as claimed RB is lynched tonight. And if I am lynched tonight, here;s what I am thinking. Mastin should be vig-ed to basically confirm that he is town (and/or SK depending on how that shit goes down). I strongly suspect he is town. I think someone else is SK. I also think that we have an SK instead of a vig because of how often the "vig" shot has been made. Here is what I would do (if I were you, and/or if I were around, which I suspect I will not be). I would get rid of mastin if he;s not already gone to clear any suspicion. I would get rid of one of nhammen and/or silver (the other is definitely scum if one flips town). From there, I don't know where to go, because it would depend on how everthing else plays out, but I think that we as town have a good chance of winning, Make me proud, friends. [/drunk] Sorry for any and all incoherence.

[Pine]

You're a funny drunk, jmurph.

I agree somewhat about nhamman, but Silver is Town. Not sure where you see the Silver/nham dichotomy.

Dichotomy is a fun word. You should try to say it three times fast if you're reading this and still drunk.