ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[SpyreX]

After MoI flipping town I'm entertaining it but GOD losing because of the great lurker hunt will piss me off more than other games that just ended.

[ooba]

Vote Count

Magua (2)

- Empking, AlmasterGM

Maemuki (2)

- Magua, Hinduragi

Benmage (2)

- Thor665, vezokpiraka

vezokpiraka (1)

- Benmage

SaintKerrigan (3)

- Lost Butterfly, Locke Lamora, SpyreX

Empking (1)

- hasdgfas

hasdgfas (2)

- DrippingGoofball, SaintKerrigan

Not Voting (5)

- Nexus, LynchMePls, Bilbo Baggins, Maemuki, Setael

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch!

[vezokpiraka]

unvote
vote maemuki

I reread her and hinduragi makes great points. I do believe she is the cult recruiter.

[Magua]

*sighs*

[Lost Butterfly]

V/la, Canada time.

SK vote is a good vote.

[Lost Butterfly]

maemuki just strikes me as actively bad as opposed to scummy, not sure how to read her, hascow voting empking (aka number 1 townie) is terrible too.

[ooba]

Espeonage replaces Maemuki. Welcome to the game!

[Thor665]

Nobody else sees Benmage's total wimpification as a glaring and flashing red streetlight of 'you shouldn't be ignoring this'
Because it hurts my eyes.

[Espeonage]

Sup guys. About to start reread. Will post when I'm done.

[SpyreX]

maemuki just strikes me as actively bad as opposed to scummy, not sure how to read her, hascow voting empking (aka number 1 townie) is terrible too.

3 posts is actively bad and when I'm back we'll play a riveting game of "is this just here?"

Empking #1 town??

[Lost Butterfly]

NUMBER 1 townie, he's on another level at this stage.

[Faraday]

hasdgfas' only good post was where he made a pretty poor case on us I am very concerned.

[Lost Butterfly]

hasdgfas' only good post was where he made a pretty poor case on us I am very concerned.


WHDHDHJ HOW DID I MANAGE TO SWITCH ACCOUNTS, WTF.

[Espeonage]

Incoming.

[Espeonage]

Espe's Analysis Page by page

Note: I will not be adding quotes. It is a waste of time on something like this. I will provide post numbers on important posts. Enjoy.

OMFG Espe is reading the tread. lesgo

Page 1:

Not much here, RVS, large wagon. That's actually a good thing. Impossible to garner anything from the votes themselves.

Page 2:

Now we have some action. I'm liking Empking. His over-analysis comes across as town, obviously trying to start some action. Good stuffs.
#36: Not going to go into too much detail seeing as it appears to be purposely weak. However this is a rather scummy post. In contrast to Emp, DGB has tried really hard to start a hard serious counterwagon. Either scum or has never played with MoI before.
LMP gets scum points for #46, that was a bad and lazy vote. Like flopping on a wagon. Top scumpick at this point.

Page 3:

Theory stuff and people missing the point. AGM gets townpoints for his post.
Fuuuu – Vezok is town in this game.
Hascow and magua speak sense, not townpoint gain worthy though.
Replacee makes bad vote, great. But does make a good point at bottom of the page. I'm seeing more of a triangle with SK, Magua and LMP but still.

Page 4:

SK going flippy floppy scumpoints
Hindu may be off but townposting = +townpoints.
Don't see what's wrong with LB. Doesn't come across as scummy. Just as floating around the thread too much. Null tell.
Why are people voting MoI. This is his town meta.

TOWN:
Empking
LB
Hindu
Vezok
MoI (obv)

And LB picks up on what I've been saying.
Can't get a read on Spyrex
Kast vote was bad.

Page 5:

His making actual points overrides. LMP looking for meta lynch when one doesn't exist.
Hascow comes in a ignores big issues. Scumpoints.
Plum makes good post. Raises good points. In light of the MoI flip, it actually makes me more likely to think hydra is town. First well thought out vote on the wagon.
LMP is digging his grave.
Andrius playing town. Hydra definantly town.
Ben gets town points.

Page 6:

Just realised this analysis is pretty fail. Eh I'll keep going. You guys don't have to read it. I'll make a vote at the end.
Thor seems town.
Seteal is scum. Not for the vote. For the complete ignorace of everything that is going on.
Still can't bloody read spyrex.

Page 7:

Mainly solidifies my town reads. I can see a voting bloc forming.
Seteal's post at the bottom of this page is exactly what I am talking about just before. It is plain and simple active lurking. At best vigbait at worst scum or even cult recruiter. Active lurkers usually don't get killed until later.

Page 8:

DGB pops her head back up this page. This provides some interesting stuff. I'm actually reading her as town despite her outlandish posts. Actually probably because of it. The interaction of DGB seems on the surface as a possible scum/town however I'm not buying into that. If either were scum they wouldn't have just dropped it like what happened.

Page 9:

LMP quotes AGM from a few pages back and it just occurred to me. LMP's explosion at the end of the page before is actually screaming of a distressed town. Keeping this in mind. Could also be a scum who has just realised they need to go into damage control.

Scratch the first point. It's the second.

Page 10:

LMP is looking more townie. However that isn't making anyone else look more scum.
And then SK has to go ruin it. If SK flips mafia the LMP is too.

Page 11:

Thor manages to nab scumpoints by appearing and putting the forming wagon on the map. Reason? Because he doesn't like the bigger ones. Why? Who knows, he didn't say.

Thor is getting scummier by the post. Avoiding questions and trying to justify active lurking.

Page 12:

This game is drying up and waiting for the lynch. No noteworthy posts.
Page 13:

@ Setael – omfg that is all you came in to post. LYNCH THIS ONE PLEASE.
Thor is looking for town points post lynch. THIS ONE CAN ALSO BE LYNCHED.
Nexus is town

Page 14 & 15 (lol accidentally forgot to split them.):

Ben gets townpoints for trying to unstagnate the game.
Yeah Nexus seems to have town motivations despite Mina's take.

#369 SETAEL IS SCUM - SEE IT? SEE IT?

Magua gets town points for the Nexus derail attempt. Moreso than others afterwards.

Page 16:

Nothing of importance.

Page 17 & 18 FAIL PAGES:

Blank

Page 19:

SK, noone cares about that RVS debate.
Thor makes bad voteS

Page 20:

Vezok, you're town. Can you try?

Ok now to present.

Will follow the SK lynch for reasons i have listed as I have gone. Namely the wishy washy and then the disappearing act. Willing to also lynch Thor and Set. Set needs to eat vig bullet tonight.

Vote: SK

[vezokpiraka]

hasdgfas' only good post was where he made a pretty poor case on us I am very concerned.


WHDHDHJ HOW DID I MANAGE TO SWITCH ACCOUNTS, WTF.

WOW. That was an incredible feat. Changing accounts like that. LOL

Maemuki is still scum. If this wagon doesn't get enough support I will switch to SK.

[Espeonage]

I am Maemuki

[vezokpiraka]

Oh. Then somehow my suspicion dropped a lot on you.

unvote
vote SK

Like seriously, now I think you are neutral-townish.

[Thor665]

Thor makes bad voteS

Really?
How is voting Benmage a "bad vote"? Do you have a strong town read on him you forgot to mention?

[Thor665]

Who was my other opening vote - Nexus? You can explain how that one was a bad vote too. Or at least clarify which is bad and why.

[hasdgfas]

NUMBER 1 townie, he's on another level at this stage.

I sure don't see it.

[Espeonage]

Because they are both obv town.

Neither of them are remotely scummy. The people you are going after are low posters. You seem to be actively seeking the easiest wagon to get on without looking bad yet also staying out of the limelight. Most of your votes in the second half of day 1 fit the MO of a scum trying to hide in plain sight and not caring what wagon you're on.

[Thor665]

How is Benmage "obvious town"?
I don't see it and it would save time if I could - clear it up please?

[Espeonage]

I can't really see any concievable scum motivation behind the content in his posts. There aren't many but those posts are town posts.

[Lost Butterfly]

espe: can i've a link of a town and scum game you replaced into after day 1, if that's possible.