OPEN 310 - Medical Mafia - TOWN WIN

[IceGuy]

What I also see is that, roleclaiming nurse doesn't hurt you. Scum has no more reason to kill you than anyone else. What do you guys think of this?

Bad idea. If the nurse claims, scum knows for sure which player is unprotected.

[HellloooNewman]

FYI, gonna be V/LA till Wednesday

[Moratorium]

So I asked the three wagoneers a question each.

DK pleaded ignorance to what hypoclaiming was, despite the discussion. Not an acceptable answer.
tim_hill said he doesn't like being told what to do. I can accept that answer, a few people were reluctant to hoppster's initial RVS-killer post, for example.

jillynne has yet to answer my question. Top 3 scum reads please, and why.

And as for Amrun's case on tim, I'll at least accept the case that it is thought through, and can see why you think it is valid. I still can't shake the feeling that the two of you aren't operating on the same plane. tim is more new player than scum, for me.

[Hoppster]

You know...alot of things feel genuine. Isn't that what scum are best at?

...Poor nurse. This sucks, because scum can easily say their the nurse, but the real nurse will have a hard time. I highly suggest the genuine nurse to just hang back. (Like, not lurking, but don't say anything that makes it obvious you're the nurse.)

This post is scum trying to seem like they're helping.

Everybody needs to join the cool-jilynne-wagon.

DK, shut up, because you're distracting the town from lynching scum.

If you all ignore DK for a moment I'm sure you'll all realise how obvscum jilynne is.

I'm *always* hesitant to throw down votes.

Something I've noticed though, is that when people challenge me to vote them, their usually town, since scum doesn't want people to vote them.

Give me a few minutes and I'll try to write a case on you.

^ Fence-sitting scum

Ok, why not, let's lynch DK. He's not making sense, he's pointing random fingers at random people, and he's detrimental to the town.

That's reason enough to vote him:

Vote: DeityKabuto

^ Scum jumping on an easy bandwagon, contradicting their reason for fence-sitting earlier in the process.

With vote-hesitant town, I'm verrrry sceptical that they would be persuaded to vote for somebody simply on the basis of "OH THIS GUY IS ANNOYING".

With 'vote-hesitant' scum, of course, they can easily forget about their previous hesitation to vote.

Town who are "hesitant to throw down votes" do NOT vote with the attiute of "herpa derpa let's vote DK, I mean, why not?"

[Amrun]

Jilynne has come off as genuine(ish) to me. :/ Jily, can you link your completed scum game for me, please?

Nurse doesn't claim today. Nurse claims in his or her FIRST POST tomorrow. Thoughts?

[IceGuy]

@Mod: If we lynch scum today, and more than one doctor dies N1, what role will the nurse get?

[DeityKabuto]

Vote jilynne1991

jilynne1991, why are you so quicky to end this day and lynch DeityKabuto, EH? o.O

[tim_hill1990]

Yes, it was me. What was your problem with

Amrun asked before you I think, or maybe just after, in not such a polite manner. That I think was why I didn't rather than you asking.

Also, what do you currently think of DK and Hoppster?

Hoppster> Town, seems very active and genuinely wants only scum lynched, has been scumhunting.
DK> There is just no reading this guy, you could read him town and he'd be scum and vice versa.
I actually think he's smarter than he lets on, him playing erratic like he does I think is his way of providing a smokescreen in order to hide his true alignment.
Problem being that this only really helps a scum alignment, it serves only to hinder town.
That being said I think he'd be a worthy lynchee, if he's scum, well we lynch scum, if he's town, well we get rid of an anti-town player.
Him being difficult to read means we would probably never be able to work out his true alignment.
Also DK still hasn't truely answered the question> Why did he try to quickhammer? (unless I missed it somewhere)

What I also see is that, roleclaiming nurse doesn't hurt you. Scum has no more reason to kill you than anyone else. What do you guys think of this?

Rolefishing anyone?

If you have to be asked for reads, then my quota of patience with you has already dried up.

I suppose that's aimed at me? I will try and give my reads more often from now.

Bad idea. If the nurse claims, scum knows for sure which player is unprotected.

Agreed, I also think it'd better for the nurse to lay low, if scum does try to fakeclaim nurse, when that happens the nurse will know almost for sure who one of the scum is.

[DeityKabuto]

Roles aren't revealed through death, so we should all just claim now.

I say, now is the time to claim, starting with the first on the list to the last, counter-claims are welcomed and we lynch who we think is lying.

[DeityKabuto]

Roles aren't revealed through death, so we should all just claim now.

I say, now is the time to claim, starting with the first on the list to the last, counter-claims are welcomed and we lynch who we think is lying.

Also we will keep repeating this, we will keep lynching who we think is lying until it is down to no scum.

[Quilford]

Roles aren't revealed through death, so we should all just claim now.

I say, now is the time to claim, starting with the first on the list to the last, counter-claims are welcomed and we lynch who we think is lying.

You are such an idiot it's

unbelievable

.

[Quilford]

Roles aren't revealed through death, so we should all just claim now.

I say, now is the time to claim, starting with the first on the list to the last, counter-claims are welcomed and we lynch who we think is lying.

You are such an idiot it's

unbelievable

.

[Quilford]

whoops double post

DK GO READ THE SETUP INFORMATION RIGHT NOW

[DeityKabuto]

whoops double post

DK GO READ THE SETUP INFORMATION RIGHT NOW

Lol? Explain.

You know ordering me around, I will mess up.

[Moratorium]

whoops double post

DK GO READ THE SETUP INFORMATION RIGHT NOW

Lol? Explain.

You know ordering me around, I will mess up.

Do you understand that a mass claim will result in 9 Doctor claims? Answer please, this is important.

[DeityKabuto]

whoops double post

DK GO READ THE SETUP INFORMATION RIGHT NOW

Lol? Explain.

You know ordering me around, I will mess up.

Do you understand that a mass claim will result in 9 Doctor claims? Answer please, this is important.

I understand, which is why my system will also allow counter-claims which means people can counter-claim, and the lynch will be the town who are the ones to decide who is lying or not.

Also, I don't get why you guys disagree with this, there is nothing wrong with it. It will spice up the game, and only scum would have a problem with it, because it would cause turmoil to the scumteam if they dont play it safe.

[Moratorium]

retriplesupervote DeityKabuto

[IceGuy]

I hope tim_hill1990 is a quack doctor. I can't stop facepalming right now.

[DeityKabuto]

retriplesupervote DeityKabuto

The boring people in this world.

[Moratorium]

You're trolling, yes?

[Moratorium]

...rainy day at the hospital. All staff members sit at large conference room...

DK: "Well, I've called this staff meeting because there's word of some mafia-type people who appear to have infiltrated us. I want everyone to declare their true nature. I'll start. I'm a doctor!"

Everyone else: "I'm a doctor, too!", "me too!", "same here", "yup, doctor", "I'm a doctor man!", "Doctor!", "Doctor here", "yep, same with me! It's an amazing coincidence!"...

...everyone stares across the table at each other...

[Quilford]

DK, nobody knows what type of doctor they are.

[Moratorium]

I'm assuming he got his scum role PM, didn't read the game, assumed everyone got their PM with specific doctor details, and, not realizing this, now thinks a mass claim will actually reveal useful information.

[IceGuy]

I'm assuming he got his scum role PM, didn't read the game, assumed everyone got their PM with specific doctor details, and, not realizing this, now thinks a mass claim will actually reveal useful information.

I know what I'm going to post in the "Funniest Scumslips" thread when this game is finished.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: DeityKabuto

[Amrun]

I am okay with this.