Return to Gambits (SK Win!)

[Empking]

Vote Count 21

Cobblerfone (2) - earworm, vezokprika
Pine
Nocmen
TheMask
Quilford
Surye
jilynne1991
vezokprika
earworm (5) - Ironhead, Pine, Nocmen, Cobblerfone, TheMask
C-Worl
PeregrineV (1) - Surye
Ironhead
sorasgoof

Not Voting: Quilford, jilynne1991 C-Worl, PeregrineV, sorasgoof

With 13 alive, its 7 to lynch.

Quilford will be replaced

[Empking]

Amrun replaces Quilford

[Pine]

Outstanding. Sup Amrun? Wagon up on earworm.

[Ironhead]

Wagon up on earworm.

Before you do, please read through and offer a fresh perspective on the game; your reads, and (if you agree with the case on earworm) why you think earworm ought (or ought not) be lynched today.

[Pine]

Wagon up on earworm.

Before you do, please read through and offer a fresh perspective on the game; your reads, and (if you agree with the case on earworm) why you think earworm ought (or ought not) be lynched today.

This too. Honestly, I hate it when people do what I just did to replacements. I suppose that makes me a hypocrite.

[The Mask]

I'm on limited access. Not sure if the mod made note of that. Until I'm back to 100% I will only be basing my posts off of current pages.

[Amrun]

I'm on like page 5. I'm going to need a little time.

[sorasgoof]

Still waiting on an answer from C-Worl.

Also, Amrun, I'd like to see reads and thoughts as well. I advise reading through the game, making notes in a separate text file or something, and posting the whole thing when you're done.

[Amrun]

Btw I was going to replace Monk but DK is on my blacklist. So instead I replaced Quilford. Lulz.

P-edit: It's not my first time at the rodeo (though, coincidentally, you were my mod for the first time at the rodeo).

[earworm]

@everyone (and not just the people on my wagon) why or why not do you find me scummy?

[Surye]

Btw I was going to replace Monk but DK is on my blacklist. So instead I replaced Quilford. Lulz.

P-edit: It's not my first time at the rodeo (though, coincidentally, you were my mod for the first time at the rodeo).

Haha, I love it.

I don't like how everyone is sheeping yesterday's case against earworm, with no comment on the lynch or nks. And I keep getting ignored in this game No comment on my idea and vote?

[earworm]

@Surye: It's a decent vote. I'm still getting huge scum vibes from Cobbler so I'm gonna stay put.

[Ironhead]

I don't like how everyone is sheeping yesterday's case against earworm, with no comment on the lynch or nks. And I keep getting ignored in this game No comment on my idea and vote?

I am very suspicious of earworm and so I like the idea of him being wagoned; but the speed with which this wagon was generated, with very little momentum for an alternate suspect, raises a red flag. Maybe he is a scum being bused by his partners; maybe he is innocent and scum have hopped on an easy bandwagon. The doubt is there in my mind, although it isn't strong enough to dissuade me from this wagon. Certainly before he is hammered he ought to be afforded a chance to address the case, claim, etc.

As for your idea and vote; I don't disagree with it, but there is not enough substance from PeregrineV to persuade me to try to wagon him just yet.

[Cobblerfone]

I don't like how everyone is sheeping yesterday's case against earworm, with no comment on the lynch or nks.

What can be said about yesterday's lynch? The NKs would be pretty hard to discuss. Though, since he's dead, I'll just state that I think CMAR/SG was either the hider or traitor.

[PeregrineV]

@Surye- Your vote sucks, to be honest.
As for your logic...it was a forgone conclusion that DK was going to hang. There were few to no cases, it was all "policy lynch, policy lynch". So DK claimed, since that's what you do.
Now, your voting me because I believed him, whereas, you are inferring you thought it was a fake claim?
Do fake claims prevent policy lynches?
If so, please link me two games of comparable size in which a policy lynch candidate claimed and was then not lynched.

As for the NKs & lynch, DK claimed bodyguard and flipped bodyguard.
I had a town read on Sathoris because I liked his logic here even though I disagreed: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 0#p3129860

I agree with Cobbler on this statement

...I think CMAR/SG was either the hider or traitor.

although I think CMAR was the traitor. Almost every post contained the mantra "______ is town." Seemed more like a signal than a read.

[earworm]

@Surye- Your vote sucks, to be honest.
As for your logic...it was a forgone conclusion that DK was going to hang. There were few to no cases, it was all "policy lynch, policy lynch". So DK claimed, since that's what you do.
Now, your voting me because I believed him, whereas, you are inferring you thought it was a fake claim?
Do fake claims prevent policy lynches?
If so, please link me two games of comparable size in which a policy lynch candidate claimed and was then not lynched.

As for the NKs & lynch, DK claimed bodyguard and flipped bodyguard.
I had a town read on Sathoris because I liked his logic here even though I disagreed: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 0#p3129860

I agree with Cobbler on this statement

...I think CMAR/SG was either the hider or traitor.

no vote? who do you suspect?
although I think CMAR was the traitor. Almost every post contained the mantra "______ is town." Seemed more like a signal than a read.

[Nocmen]

My case on earworm is that I see him most likely as sheeping hte case on DK yesterday, as well as the fact that he was unwilling to post reads for a bit. And of the most important reads he has, his votes, I don't like any of them. All seem fishy.

[Surye]

@Surye- Your vote sucks, to be honest.
As for your logic...it was a forgone conclusion that DK was going to hang. There were few to no cases, it was all "policy lynch, policy lynch". So DK claimed, since that's what you do.
Now, your voting me because I believed him, whereas, you are inferring you thought it was a fake claim?
Do fake claims prevent policy lynches?
If so, please link me two games of comparable size in which a policy lynch candidate claimed and was then not lynched.

As for the NKs & lynch, DK claimed bodyguard and flipped bodyguard.
I had a town read on Sathoris because I liked his logic here even though I disagreed: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 0#p3129860

This is some serious misinformation. He was at L-4 when he claimed. Since when was L-4 considered "claim time" and "forgone conclusion"? Are you kidding me? And then you go off on some unrelated tangent about fake claims and policy lynches. Also, want to take a position on who's scum? You answered my question posed to people voting earworm. Which would be fine if you had an action position.

I love my vote even more. earworm's sheeping isn't as scummy as Peregrine's behavior imo. Sheeping against DK is pretty cool.

[earworm]

oops. didn't even realize that post #515 failed.

It was supposed to say "vote?"

Seriously. People need to vote.

Everyone here-->Quilford, jilynne1991 C-Worl, PeregrineV, sorasgoof.

Vote.

[Amrun]

I'm sorry... I'll buckle down now.

[Empking]

C-worl and vezok have been prodded.

[Amrun]

Guys, do you know how much reading a day 1 with dk in it hurts my brain? You ought to be grateful!

I'm still struggling through.

[Pine]

I got home safely from vacation, pretty jet lagged. I'm trying to use this afternoon to catch up, but I'm afraid this game is one of my lowest priorities, given its relative lack of activity and my confidence in the progression of its major wagon.

[sorasgoof]

I'm finding it hard to participate in this game when there is so little activity. Can we pick it up a little?

inb4 someone says I haven't been posting either. Read the above statement.

@Earworm. I'm not so eager to throw around my vote. How long do we have left until the deadline? There's no reason everyone needs to have a vote on someone right now.

[earworm]

I'm finding it hard to participate in this game when there is so little activity. Can we pick it up a little?

inb4 someone says I haven't been posting either. Read the above statement.

@Earworm. I'm not so eager to throw around my vote. How long do we have left until the deadline? There's no reason everyone needs to have a vote on someone right now.

it helps me determine your alignment. Right now I can't even tell where your suspicions lie.