Scummies 2011 Nominations

[StrangerCoug]

Town won Color Concentration mainly through scum bungling up a lot. Two obvscum going down early, then my other scumbuddy screwing me... I'm trying my best to be sportsmanlike, but I feel town deserves more effort than that to get a nomination.

[GreyICE]

Town won Color Concentration mainly through scum bungling up a lot. Two obvscum going down early, then my other scumbuddy screwing me... I'm trying my best to be sportsmanlike, but I feel town deserves more effort than that to get a nomination.

Oh bollocks. I've seen obvscum live straight until endgame and then the town finds out they were scum all along.

You let the obvtown back you guys into a corner, and instead of the rest of the scumteam pushing out for other lynches and starting other wagons, they bussed mercilessly. Which was miserable, because as soon as there were no other wagons occurring, townies had to ask 'well who was bussing' and you guys always came out as incredibly bad.

The town had strong leadership (Glass, Ghostlin), strong analysts (Rhinocke) and strong attackers (Hot Dogs, once he got rolling).

They played brilliantly, stuck your team on the defensive, and never gave you any holes to capitalize on. With potentially 2 kills a night, and a 9:4 setup, your team got roflstomped.

Played with scum Glass twice now, and really really looking forward to playing with town glass.

2nd, Nth, whatever

[kiwieagle]

Town won Color Concentration mainly through scum bungling up a lot. Two obvscum going down early, then my other scumbuddy screwing me... I'm trying my best to be sportsmanlike, but I feel town deserves more effort than that to get a nomination.

Oh bollocks. I've seen obvscum live straight until endgame and then the town finds out they were scum all along.

You let the obvtown back you guys into a corner, and instead of the rest of the scumteam pushing out for other lynches and starting other wagons, they bussed mercilessly. Which was miserable, because as soon as there were no other wagons occurring, townies had to ask 'well who was bussing' and you guys always came out as incredibly bad.

The town had strong leadership (Glass, Ghostlin), strong analysts (Rhinocke) and strong attackers (Hot Dogs, once he got rolling).

They played brilliantly, stuck your team on the defensive, and never gave you any holes to capitalize on. With potentially 2 kills a night, and a 9:4 setup, your team got roflstomped.

Played with scum Glass twice now, and really really looking forward to playing with town glass.

2nd, Nth, whatever

nth

[inHimshallibe]

Lord Gurgi continuing to own it up in Mafia Discussion.

Nthing Professor Mafia for Lord Gurgi for observations made in "Number of VTs Needed"

[CSL]

@ GreyICE: Even if you get it into the Scummies successfully, it is going to get beat out by more COMPETENT towns...

[GreyICE]

@ GreyICE: Even if you get it into the Scummies successfully, it is going to get beat out by more COMPETENT towns...

@CSL: Maybe if you once in your career played a game where you were competent town I'd have some faith in the idea that you know what a competent town looks like.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

GreyICE, Color Concentration town was pretty good, but not scummy caliber.

It's like Buffy Mafia's town. We caught all 3 scum in 3 days, and only have 1 town death. But I don't think that town deserves a scummy either.

[GreyICE]

Meh, I still don't see where CSL gets off implying they were incompetent.

There's no question they played a very good game, and I was impressed by what I read. Did the mafia play a very bad game? Yeah, maybe. I mean MPM was similar (in that I thought it was a good town, and the mafia played so poorly a lot of that skill wasn't even needed).

I liked it enough to Nth, so I did.

[edmund.angles]

Nth'ing Amrum for Best New Player

. She is both well-considered, eloquent, polite and tough-as-nails.

[ReaperCharlie]

Nth'ing Amrum for Best New Player

. She is both well-considered, eloquent, polite and tough-as-nails.

Ah yes, good choice!

Nth

with enthusiasm!

Amrun is a wonderful new player.

[ReaperCharlie]

@ GreyICE: Even if you get it into the Scummies successfully, it is going to get beat out by more COMPETENT towns...

As much as I usually disagree with CSL, I am going to have to agree with this statement.

@CSL: Maybe if you once in your career played a game where you were competent town I'd have some faith in the idea that you know what a competent town looks like.

As much as I usually agree with GreyICE, this comment was uncalled for.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Nth'ing Amrum for Best New Player

. She is both well-considered, eloquent, polite and tough-as-nails.

Ah yes, good choice!

Nth

with enthusiasm!

Amrun is a wonderful new player.

I can't help but wonder if this endorsement doesn't hurt her chances more than help them~?

[Mr. Flay]

No, it doesn't.

[SleepyKrew]

Quick question. Has a(n) Hydra/Alt ever won a scummy? Can they?

[Faraday]

Yes. See: Gaspar. I'm sure there are a load more too, but that's off the top of my head. Oh roflcopter won a scummy too I think, so yeah there's another.

Hydra's and alts can obviously win things like best town performance, if they're part of the town.

[SleepyKrew]

Poorly worded, my bad.
Does the award go to the main account(s) or the account that was played with?

[Empking]

Poorly worded, my bad.
Does the award go to the main account(s) or the account that was played with?

Bilbo Baggin's scummie was given to Plum and Andrius?

[Faraday]

Poorly worded, my bad.
Does the award go to the main account(s) or the account that was played with?

Played with, in Gaspar's case.

[Amrun]

Thanks for the nomination. I'm honored!

Also, sorry town of Color Concentration, but I won't be Nthing it.

[DemonHybrid]

Nominate the Werewolf Team of Mafia on Werewolf Island! (New York 129) for Best Mafia Performance

-Started with 3 players against 21 others
-Modkilled player on their team on Day 1
-Role outed on Day 1
-Up against another faction, town AND a bulletproof SK.
-Up against a competent playerlist

...and still won without a scratch. Some light suspicion and a slip that no one caught. That was ALL.

They basically bit, clawed and scratched their way through 21 people, 8 game Days, 122 PAGES and THREE MONTHS.

[implosion]

Nth werewolf island werewolves

Nth amrun for best new player

[populartajo]

-Up against a competent playerlist

[/b]

Tour Guide

, [/color]

NPC Tour Guide

,

Torn to Shreds and Shot Night 0/Pre-Game!

8. SnakePlissken

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Put to Death Day 1!

1. Nero Cain

,

Town Seer

,

Shot in the Chest Night 1!

14. Nobody Special

,

Town Voyeur

,

Choked to Death Night 1!

21. Thor665 (who replaced Seraphim)

,

Town Jailkeeper

,

Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 1!

22. RaudhrGarm (who replaced [Moonstruck])

,

Bulletproof Serial Killer

,

Put to Death Day 2!

9. quadz08 (who replaced Lucresia)

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Shot in the Chest Night 2!

6. Eldritch Lord (who replaced MaxKojote)

,

Town Neighbor

,

Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 2!

13. Pine

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Put to Death Day 3!

16. Kise

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Shot in the Chest Night 3!

12. Nachomamma8

,

East Side Mafia Goon

,

Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 3!

11. T-Bone

,

East Side Mafia Tracker

,

Put to Death Day 4!

19. C-Worl

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Throat Bitten Open Night 4!

18. implosion

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Shot in the Face Night 4!

4. Charlie (who replaced kr0b)

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Shot in the Face Night 5!

5. mastin2 (who replaced Lowell)

,

East Side Mafia Doctor

,

Put to Death Day 6!

23. Slaxx (who replaced tclawren)

,

Town Neighbor

,

Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 6!

20. MrZepher

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 7!

2. ConSpiracy

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Put to Death Day 8!

17. singersigner (who replaced Shift)

,

1-shot Friendly Neighbor

,

Endgamed Day 8!

7. dramonic (who replaced Reckamonic, the person who replaced RayFrost)

,

Vengeful Townie

,

Endgamed Day 8!

lolno

[populartajo]

nth amrun

[CSL]

Nthing both Werewolf Island's Werewolf team and Amrun

[Scummies]

first post updated to here, hopefully everything is correct, pm me if you spot a mistake. thank you!