Jil disagreeing with someone, like in post 52, is town points for her, even though in post 57, I dislike her concern for hpw townie she appears to others.
Cobbler's 59 is an excessively townie post.
Jackalope's 70 is bad - reads like scum nervous at other players being declared town, trying to sow the seeds of paranoia and dissension. Do not like.
Agree with earworm's 72, but correct theory can come from either alignment. Similar with Surye's 79.
Cworl's 82 is a lot of complaining without any actual effort towards moving the game forward. In other words, it gives the appearance of being pro-town without actually being so. Unsure whether or not this is an intentional smokescreen, though.
I like Surye's 86.
Mask's 91 makes me really uncomfortable - sk or traitor suspicion out of nowhere? Why not scum? Very strange and makes Mask far more likely scum in my eyes.
Cobbler's 95 is bad. Too concerned with how others think.
Surye's 97: Why answer for jil?
Surye's 98 indirectly defends Cobbler.
Nocmen's 107: Why is discussion of theory revolving around RVs WIFOM in any way, shape, or form? Why did you feel the need to point it out? What conclusion are you attempting to draw, and why didn't you state that conclusion instead of leaving it vague?
Nocmen's 110 expands on the WIFOM point, but it isn't WIFOM. At all. This is a reach. Most of what I don't like about it is the sideways manner in which he attacks earworm. It's too indirect. (Edit: Answered in 228, but I still don't like the answer.)
vezok's 116 is hilarious. "Douche asshole shit."
Don't necessarily agree with Ironhead's 121, but this post and the rest of his posting give me a townread on him. (Similar with CMAR, but I haven't bothered commenting on that since CMAR is now dead.)
Sathoris' 124 is bad. The theory part where he disagrees with Cobbler's massclaim idea is fine, but neutral, but the way he "notes" the fact that Cobbler proposed a potentially bad idea rubs me the wrong way. Sathoris' vote is on CMAR for a very weak reason; why not back this up with a vote on Cobbler?
Vezok's 125-126 give me a fairly strong townread on vezok. Both him and Cobblerfone are attempting to break the game and feeling it out in a way that seems genuine.
Surye's 131 is :goodposting:, particularly about Sorasgoof and Jackalope. I don't necessarily agree with everying Surye says in this post, but it is a townie post.
Mask 134 gives me more a sense of "trying to look pro-town" than actually being pro-town. "Well I thought of this idea but I just realized it sucks, but I'll post about it anyway!" Also dislike the use of smilies and the attack on Surye - and he waits until post 135 to lay down a vote. Why?
C-Worl 138 shows a little bit of effort, at least. Feels genuine. His defense of himself in 140 is sufficient.
earworm 144 is a good post.
DeityKabuto 151 - THAT IS THE FIRST THING YOU SAY ABOUT THE GAME?! a;lkfa;sdlfj This is why I could not replace in when he was alive.
Ironhead 153 is :goodposting:
Cobbler 154: CMAR isn't a goon or serial killer? What the fuck? How could you EVER come to that conclusion? (Edit: Answered in 159. I don't like the answer, but it exists.)
Nocmen's 156 makes no sense.
Cobbler's vote on Surye in 166 is bad.
Nocmen's 174 is blatantly incorrect. Ironically, he is accusing Surye of not reading carefully, when Surye is doing so and Nocmen is not. (Edit: Addressed in 184.)
Cobbler's 189 is bad because I've played with Cobblertown and he had plenty of suspicions of his own. Everyone has SOME suspicions... Even as scum, he expressed suspicions, as well as when he was town.
Cobbler 192: People did suspect you in Cthulhu, though.
I like Nocmen's 194.
Sora 196 is valid, though a little late.
Sathoris 199 is terrible. How is not caring what people think a scumtell? This is a towntell, especially in jilynne. Also, she votes jily for having few scumreads, and then fencesits on Cobbler HARDCORE without mentioning that Cobbler did the exact same thing Sathoris is voting jily for, and further into the game with a lot more thought put into it.
Nocmen 200 is a good post.
Sathoris 209 resolves some outstanding issues from 199.
Mask 222 annoys me. I'M NOT LURKING LOLOLOL *proceeds to lurk*
Sora 224 is :goodposting:
Ironhead 227: I don't understand the supposed case on earworm at all, at this point.
Nocmen's 228: Wait, if you could vote for both earworm and Cobblerfone, you would? You see no confliction here? At all?
earworm 223: Though I generally agree with most of earworm's theory discussions, his posts are notably sparse of any sort of scumhunting thus far.
wredfar 225: Notes one of the things I previously noted in C-Worl, which gives me good vibes.
Sathoris 239: WHY DO YOU STILL NOT NOTE THAT COBBLER DID THE SAME THING? After you supposedly agreed with Nocmen about something he was saying about this, you should be referencing both jil and Cobbler when you talk of scumless lists, and yet you are not. This indicates that you are not genuinely scumhunting and just sheeped Nocmen's posts about Cobbler that were happening last time you were on to bolster your case - which basically says that your case is entirely fabricated.
Pine 243: VT claim. Ew.
Pine 245 is poor reasoning.
Pine 247 is WIFOM but I find it oddly convincing.
Pine 249: Your sample size is too small. He actually completed SpyreX's Dynasty Warriors first, and even though he won, he wasn't a townread by far. Speed Mafia is another completed scumgame in which he was far from a universal townread.
Sathoris 251 shows he is following anything shiny. Shows no conviction in his reads. Pine vote isn't terrible, though.
Pine 274 is valid.
Nocmen 277 is a stretch.
CMAR 282: Aw, CMAR is a youngin'.
Ironhead 286: Why aren't you advancing the game?
Sathoris 287 is okay.
Nocmen 291: The repeating of not wanting to vote Pine "right now" is a little weird.
Sora 304 is bad. Willfully not advancing the gamestate or scumhunting.
CWorl 319 is weak.
320 is Mask's underwhelming catchup post in which he manages to completely misread Surye, full of old news and distractions about 13 year olds and alts.
Mask 333 is hypocritical and a bad case. LOL SETUP SPEC IS BAD RIGHT GAIZ? Reads like he ISOed Surye, picked a couple of things that looked vaguely scummy to talk about, and winged it.
DK 337 makes me laugh.
Cworl 346 is more complaining about the gamestate without doing anything to advance it. He's still doing reaction-testy, RVS-type votes and then complaining that no one is close to a lynch.
Ironhead 352 is guilty of exactly the same thing.
Mask 365 makes me conflicted. It seems like he is defending DK, which upon first read, allotted him townpoints, but on second read, he seems TOO SURE - and is giving DK townpoints for the same thing he is giving Surye scumpoints for. BUT he's open about that. I just wish he'd explain it because I am confused.
Mask 366: Aaaand 3 minutes later he shamelessly bandwagons DK.
Mask 373: No, that is not what distancing means.
Mask 374: He makes a good point - why isn't jily voting? This is a scumtell I've observed in her, but I feel otherwise townie about her ... though I can't recall her scumreads and that is a bad sign.
jil 387: Openly calling DK a policy lynch, has no suspects. Ugh.
Sora 385: The active lurking is getting really old.
Pine 399: Has no one even commented on Pine's stupid claim?
DK 403-404: Actual scumhunting. Color me surprised.
DK 412: Aaaand this is the DK I know and blacklist.
PeregrineV 449: How do you know DK is claiming his real role and is not scum? (Edit: Answered in 454, but badly.)
Surye 450-451 is :goodposting:
Sathoris 470 is good.
But until I have a better target for my vote and case, I will continue to be vocal about it.
