Mini 1176: Dexter Season 2 (Game Over) Who Won?

[Kid Know Nothing]

I'm willing to vote Hindu, Farside, Amrun or KKN today, so if any of those wagons need vote love I will vote - though Farside has seemed more townie lately she has major scum points from before and would be one of the best informational lynches I think.

How does this help the town in any way shape or form?

This is like a big old billboard saying "Hey, see the townies on this list? Go ahead and start the wagon on one. Free mislynch."

[tanstalas]

Not that this is a tell of any sort that is reliable, but LMP is a male as far as I know, not a female.

[Amrun]

Yeah, that is not even close to IIoA. Sorry.

LMP is indeed male.

Sotty and DDD need to get on board with the voting business, here - as well as others.

[Kid Know Nothing]

Not that this is a tell of any sort that is reliable, but LMP is a male as far as I know, not a female.

He never corrected me, I always said she.

Weird. You would think that someone who read my posts would have said something.

How would that be a tell?

[tanstalas]

Because he has his gender listed. You don't even pay that close attention to the people playing.. dunno, like I said, its not a realy great tell, however when I am scum, I make sure I notice gender if it is displayed. When I am scum I kinda coast by

[Kid Know Nothing]

Because he has his gender listed. You don't even pay that close attention to the people playing.. dunno, like I said, its not a realy great tell, however when I am scum, I make sure I notice gender if it is displayed. When I am scum I kinda coast by

Profiles and avatars don't matter. What people say matters. I pay attention to that. If I get someone's gender wrong, they can correct me. He never did.

[Amrun]

Yeah, that isn't a scum tell AT ALL...

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Have we played a game together other than Quiz Show Mafia because that was formatted so differently as to basically be unusable in terms of meta (and of course that even ignores the sample size issues)?

And you were damn good at reading players that game. The format was different but you made points (yes I was scum) but even I could say and most did that it was from a town point of view. This game no. Also as I just said to VBP I don't have time to check mounds of meta and recalling a game from my past is my best with limited time.
Mostly I have to breeze read looking at your recent meta, which I deemed lazy.

I guess I don't understand your point; do you really think I raise good point as town and then completely fail to do the same as scum? As Amrun pointed out like everyone I have my good games and my bad. You claim to have metaed my recent games and found me lazy which I assume is consistent with this game as well. And I'm sure I've been irritating to you when I haven't answered your questions but as I already noted there's a multitude of reasons why I don't always answer questions the first time, or the second, or the third. The point is that you haven't been arguing I'm irritating which I'm sure I am, but that I'm scum but basically as far as I can tell that scum read boils down to the fact that I annoy you.

~~

Sotty and DDD need to get on board with the voting business, here - as well as others.

I think I've made it clear my order of preference is farside, Hindu and KKN in that order. And thus your Blackberry/tans push doesn't really do much of anything for me.

[SocioPath]

Time flows like an arrow.
The arrow that will be the death of the meek.

[Juls]

Official Vote Count

[3]

Blackberry

(Kid Know Nothing, Amrun, VP Baltar)

[2]

Fargrass

(Sotty7, Debonair Danny DiPietro)

[2]

SocioPath

(Kise, Hinduragi)

[2]

VP Baltar

(Fargrass, Blackberry)

[1]

Hinduragi

(SocioPath)

[0]

tanstalas

()

[0]

Kid Know Nothing

()

[0]

Sotty7

()

[0]

Amrun

()

[0]

Kise

()

[0]

Debonair Danny DiPietro

()

Not Voting :

tanstalas

Votes needed for arrest :

6

Deadline for Day 2:

(expired on 2011-07-01 17:25:00)

V/LA:

Until July 4:

Kise

[Amrun]

DDD - If support can be rallied for a Hindu lynch, I've already expressed the acceptability of that compromise. I'm hesitant to leave BB while it is the top wagon, but should people show serious interest in Hindu, I will help move that wagon along.

[Amrun]

Oh, and I thought about it; I wouldn't mind lynching KKN because I feel it will be an informative flip. I don't think KKN vs. LMP/BB is a bus.

I still prefer one of BB or Hindu.

I'm feeling inexplicably a little more townie about tans atm.

[Sotty7]

Sotty: When you state that someone is pushing a case on someone that hammered is a player trying to make "town brownie points" how do you not consider damning a player?

This makes no sense.

I mean either I'm town trying to question a player I find scummy (which is what I'm doing and you've ignored) or I'm scum trying to ask questions trying to look good. Why latch onto one theory and not read my reasoning for questioning Kise?

I have explained this plenty of times.

You are scum questioning Kise for his bad hammer under the belief the town would back you. Only it backfired in your face. How hard is this to understand?

Are you going to continue to ignore my questions?

Getting to the point to where I wish I could ignore you. I'm done trying to convince you that you're scum though.

I'd like to lynch Farside, KKN and Socio in that order. I would compromise on Hind lynch over a Berry lynch at this point.

KKN's LMP case is okay really, but the fact that he has sat back nearly all game not pushing his supposed top scum suspect just really claws in my gut.

I have to apologize for my weekend activity. It's really hit or miss if I get computer access sometimes.

[Kid Know Nothing]

I have pushed it Sotty. Any time I've brought it up, it is promptly put onto the backburner. If I make a point against LMP, it is largely ignored. I have not sat back all game. Every time LMP was screwy, I've commented on it. I've been trying to bring it up, it's been lost in the other discussions. I have discussed other people.

What other thoughts do you have on the case besides "okay"?

Tans, you're really starting to lose town points for me.

@Amrun; So you are willing to lynch me for information because it's me versus LMP, who you've already said is scummy?
BB, do you have any response to the case I layed out against LMP?

[SocioPath]

LMP was not a concern of mine all game, until his replacement shot off all kinds of alarms.
I'd although I'll reserve judgement and opinions for now.

[Juls]

Prodding Hinduragi again.

[Amrun]

BB shot off alarms for you? Hmm. Lynch LMP then.

KKN: I still don't WANT to lynch you, but if it comes down to you or NL, I'm lynching you.

P-edit: NOOOOOOO!!!!

[VP Baltar]

ok everyone vote for either farside or blackberry now. we need a claim. people on wagons going nowhere are being useless if they are town.

[tanstalas]

ok everyone vote for either farside or blackberry now. we need a claim. people on wagons going nowhere are being useless if they are town.

Just wondering why you include farside but not yourself or Socio who have wagons just as big?

Anyhow..

Vote:Farside

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

ok everyone vote for either farside or blackberry now. we need a claim. people on wagons going nowhere are being useless if they are town.

Just wondering why you include farside but not yourself or Socio who have wagons just as big?

Anyhow..

Vote:Farside

Because no one besides the people on the VPB/Socio wagons have expressed any interest in lynching VPB/Socio which is why they're completely unproductive.

[tanstalas]

I could have sworn I saw some people say they would lynch Socio, but just taking a quick look it looks like that was Sotty, and she prefers farside and KKN first.

I agree with VPB though, people on the 2 man and 1 man wagons need to get onto one of the farside/Blackberry wagon

[Fargrass]

In conclusion?
1. She was overdefensive for one vote at the beginning of the day.
2. She contributed almost exactly nothing day one, she made about two posts with any real content.
3. She sheeped her way onto a mislynch.
4. The misrepresentations. I will go through and find examples of this.

Info again. Why does any of this make her scum?

[Amrun]

^ Um. They are mostly self-explanatory.

[Kid Know Nothing]

In conclusion?
1. She was overdefensive for one vote at the beginning of the day.
2. She contributed almost exactly nothing day one, she made about two posts with any real content.
3. She sheeped her way onto a mislynch.
4. The misrepresentations. I will go through and find examples of this.

Info again. Why does any of this make her scum?

Please sign your posts.

And again. I cannot be more clear with this. If you cannot see why those are scummy, then I don't know what.

[Juls]

Fargrass, I have already asked you guys outside of thread to sign your post. Please do so. This is an official warning.