ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[DrippingGoofball]

I don't know. This game. It's running out of steam.

Yes it is.

Here's an amazing ONE TIME OFFER:

Tell me how I'm wrong about SK's slip. Give me a plausible scenario for the events laid out and we'll swing it this way.

Otherwise, jump on the wagon. IF I am wrong (I'm not) the other can happen.

Dealio?

SpyreX is baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaad town.

[Empking]

DGB: You think there are only four scum?

Why, are you five?

Three mafia in a twenty player game is stupidly low.

[Thor665]

DGB is scum for being on the MoI wagon yesterday, and for being the non-town on the Espeonage wagon.

Like her, I'll keep voting someone other than who I just made that case on

[Thor665]

Three mafia in a twenty player game is stupidly low.

Um...cult.

[DrippingGoofball]

DGB: You think there are only four scum?

Why, are you five?

Three mafia in a twenty player game is stupidly low.

There are four in my equation.

[Empking]

Three mafia in a twenty player game is stupidly low.

Um...cult.

So?

DGB: Scum = Mafia?

[DrippingGoofball]

Well I dunno and it doesn't matter. I can't tell them apart. They're scum independently of each other. I'm not going to worry about cult or mafia. Scum is scum.

[Empking]

I'm confused but I don't think I'll be able to be enlightened.

[DrippingGoofball]

I'm reviewing yesterday.

vote: Empking

after re-reading him, it seems that he's putting trying to sound impressive(read:town) without actually saying anything.

^^^ I agree with hasdgscum - Empking is lurking in plain sight a great deal.

TOWN

DGB
SpyreX
AGM
Benmage
Setael - I think I had her as town earlier.

SUPER SKETCH

Magua post #505, but #514 sorta magua-townish. #516 is bad. #523 is baaaaaaad.
Hinduragi #524 - getting SpyreX to do his dirty work
Empking - too much fluff
Locke Lamora - who is he?
Lost Butterfly - playing out of character
Nexus - is in the game? LURKER SCUMZORZ???

DIE SCUM DIE

Espeonage Maemuki - not getting case, his #539 is a heap of nonsense to justify a townie vote.
Thor - Kast died after posting little, and Thor being his only suspect. Biblo Baggins was suspicious of Thor as well. Plus defended MoI for town cred?
LynchMePls - was bus'ed
hasdgfas - too passive
vezokpiraka - a little too subdued, #527 very forced, baseless accusation of CR

More to come, my connection keeps jamming, it's hard to read the game. Note to self, continue from p.26 onward.

[ooba]

Vote Count

Magua (2)

- Empking, AlmasterGM

hasdgfas (3)

- Magua, DrippingGoofball, Lost Butterfly

Benmage (2)

- Thor665, Locke Lamora

Espeonage (3)

- Setael, vezokpiraka, LynchMePls

Setael (1)

- Espeonage

Locke Lamora (1)

- SpyreX

Not Voting (4)

- hasdgfas, Nexus, Hinduragi, Benmage

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch!

[Empking]

SCUM = Thor + 2 of {SpyreX, vezokpiraka, AlmasterGM, LynchMePls} + hascow on gut

TOWN
SpyreX

[Magua]

Nexus - is in the game? LURKER SCUMZORZ???

Nexus was a hardcore lurker/fencesitter in ASoS as well.

Do you have Benmage as town simply because Thor is pushing him, or is there another reason?

[Lost Butterfly]

There are good reasons to believe Vezok could be scum.

Empking is obviously town DGB. Have a job interview tomorrow but will be reading through what I missed and stuff laters.

[Lost Butterfly]

This is *not* the town Setael I know and love. Why?

[SpyreX]

SpyreX is baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaad town

Hey I'm trying here!

Actually your VCA really surprised me with what it shook out (minus me because it ALWAYS says me) sooo:

Is has gut that much stronger and more braver than what you came up with?

[Lost Butterfly]

Bleh LMP's apology looks townish, feel bad for trolling you now.

[Benmage]

Sooo.. I'm reading the thread today/i guess tomorrow aswell.. Gruelish. I started from pg 7.. I'm on 11.. lol. I'm going to dinner now tho.

Anything people have lingering for me to answer... Shoot.

Anything key for me to focus on during the reread... Shoot.

This on pg 9 was funny:

Anyone catching up, this whole page can be skipped.

Anyways...bbl.

[Benmage]

Oh and yes... the dragons about to be awaken.

[DrippingGoofball]

Actually your VCA really surprised me with what it shook out (minus me because it ALWAYS says me) sooo:

Is has gut that much stronger and more braver than what you came up with?

Two days, two wagons, data is scarce for the scumputer. That's why I'm looking at Day 2 behavior especially, I think it was a horrible lynch, SK was bleeding town in the end.

[DrippingGoofball]

I have a theory that the more a player is rabid about the cult recruiter, the more likely he is to be mafia.

How has been rabid about cult recruiters? Certainly vezok. Magua, since you've been accused of being CR a lot, could you tell us who has been the most gung ho?

[DrippingGoofball]

EBWOP

WHO has been rabid... not how.

[DrippingGoofball]

Nexus was a hardcore lurker/fencesitter in ASoS as well.

What was his alignment, pray tell?

Do you have Benmage as town simply because Thor is pushing him, or is there another reason?

He has the odor of town.

SK wagon stall leads me to believe he is probably town. The only other serious wagon aka Thor isn't taking off. Leads me to believe I am right. js.

Yep. Thor. But Espeonage's #686 is fail.

[quote="Magua]I'm not claiming that the hasdgfas wagon is founded on anything concrete. It's built on the same swamp. But it's 10,000 times more useful to see who's willing to join the hasdgfas wagon, who's willing to support the hasdgfas wagon over the SK wagon, and who clings to the SK wagon and for what reasons, than it is to simply lynch SK at this point.[/quote]
I like the above.

I will speculate that there is scum in these parts that are too chicken to hammer a townie I'm defending:

Benmage
>>>> hasdgfas <<<<
Magua
Thor665
Nexus
Setael
Hinduragi

TOWN

DGB
SpyreX
AGM
Benmage
Setael - I think I had her as town earlier. Has grown worrisomely lurky. Lurking in #656, #768 is good, later dropped super sikrit town tell
LynchMePls - was bus'ed - although contribution seems clean. Leaning town though after re-read.
Hinduragi #524 - getting SpyreX to do his dirty work - later seems town

SUPER SKETCH

Magua post #505, but #514 sorta magua-townish. #516 is bad. #523 is baaaaaaad. Does have some decent posts.
Locke Lamora - who is he? Lurking in #655. #701 feels good.
Lost Butterfly - playing out of character
Thor - Kast died after posting little, and Thor being his only suspect. Biblo Baggins was suspicious of Thor as well. Plus defended MoI for town cred? His #718 seems really townie, though.

DIE SCUM DIE

Nexus - is in the game? LURKER SCUMZORZ??? >>> LB has not-town read - Lurking in #695
Empking - too much fluff, #709 is scary scummy #769 urgh
Espeonage Maemuki - not getting case, his #539 is a heap of nonsense to justify a townie vote.
hasdgfas - too passive, #650 is fishing for reasons to vote, day 2 (???) sheeping
vezokpiraka - a little too subdued, #527 very forced, baseless accusations of CR, #696 is horrible.

[Magua]

Nexus was a hardcore lurker/fencesitter in ASoS as well.

What was his alignment, pray tell?

He was town. I think he's town here. I'm questioning why he's in your null category.

Magua, since you've been accused of being CR a lot, could you tell us who has been the most gung ho?

I don't think this tell is as reliable as you may think it is.

Bilbo Baggins, town, started it
Lots of people question him about this, but no one really agrees

AlmasterGM is the first to morph it from "Bilbo Baggins said you're CR" to "everyone says you're CR". Buuuuut, I think that this is more of a towntell, actually, because I don't see scum doing anything so outrageously bold.

D2 then gets:
Empking's "Didn't we say we wanted to lynch Magua before he could recruit" in #488
vezok throws out "Maemuki is the cult recruiter" in #527

I don't have a horrible scumread on Empking, and vezok is...vezok. Vezok could be scum, certainly, but I simply can't get worked up over the possibility.

[DrippingGoofball]

Mmmmmmmmmmm let's see.

Magua being a suspected CR, the mafia should have NK'd him if they have 2 brain cells in the group of them. I know if I were mafia and some people picked up on a player being CR, that CR-candidate would be a bag of bones. Magua might have flipped town, or CR, I wouldn't have cared, I wouldn't want to take a chance.

Given this, it's more likely that Magua is mafia, than CR, if he's scum. That would explain why Magua remains un-NK'd x2. Scum won't kill one of their own.

In fact, I think it's extremely likely that Magua is mafia.

Kast & BBaggins were Nk'd... the mafia was shooting for townies, not CRs. That's a little bit weird.

[Empking]

Why was Kast non-CR? (Obviously BB was obv town but I for one don't remember having a town read on Kast.)