ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[DrippingGoofball]

Can you summarize the case against Espeonage? I personally don't get it. Maybe you can help.

[ooba]

Vote Count

Magua (3)

- Empking, AlmasterGM, Nexus

hasdgfas (5)

- DrippingGoofball, Espeonage, Hinduragi, Lost Butterfly, vezokpiraka

Benmage (3)

- Thor665, Locke Lamora, Magua

Espeonage (1)

- Setael

Locke Lamora (2)

- SpyreX, Benmage

Nexus (1)

- LynchMePls

Not Voting (1)

- hasdgfas

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch!

---

Deadline is in

(expired on 2011-07-06 23:59:59)

[DrippingGoofball]

VOTE: Magua

I have to, because this action only works on vote leaders.

Magua, you better not be a Miller.

Test by Fire: Magua

[DrippingGoofball]

Also, thanks to whoever trusted me with the gift of the POWURRR.

[Thor665]

...assigned Daycop?

[Thor665]

Also, your "proof" was one game, posted by Espeo in defense of you, where I disagreed that your play was

identical

, and he never brought it up again.

Link one game for me, from anyone where play is IDENTICAL.

PedanticMafia.
Town of Nitpickers Mafia
Team FDH 2 (Flogging Dead Horse)

Seriously?
"Similar" There.

But you fail to tackle the issue that there are others more guilty of what you are accusing me of... You're calling me out for "scummy" things. I don't think I am as guilty of them as you may... I also know that when I commit these sort of tells they are Bentowntells... Which is why you ought to look up some scum games of mine. But to state so strongly for so long that I am the clear scummiest person in this game is ridiculous... You really think you're that much better than the multitude of people who are calling me obvtown? Or do you really think subpar play is some ultimate grand scheme scum strategy....

Your play is clearly not subpar because most of the players are calling you town when you agree that all you're doing is wagoning and not participating.
I am sooooo neutral on the "but other people are doing it as bad/worse than me!" thing. First off - so we're now agreeing this is a scumtell I've got? Because null for you should be null for them, amirite? Second, I actually don't think anyone has been wagoning while doing nothing anywhere near as much as you - name names and prove me wrong. I'll concede a fair point on Benscum games, I don't think I've ever seen them - I'll be back later tonight with some and some thoughts. I do disagree that this game looks like your townplay though, not buying it. Though, it is wonderful to see that your, by far, most active spell coincides with me actually getting more than 1-2 votes on you. Total coincidence I'm sure.

I dispute that you pushed the MoI wagon -

I actually called you out Day 1 for not pushing it

while being on it and called that scummy at the time.

Quote for me please... I forget this.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 5#p3104215

[Magua]

Ow hot hot hot hot hot.



What do I win?

[Thor665]

@Benmage - other than Inglorious - link to scum game(s)?

[Locke Lamora]

I'm going to assume DGB is just being DGB because that really doesn't make any sense.

Benmage: do you have some examples of you reacting to people calling you scum?

To those saying 'Benmage is obvtown' etc., how much actual scumhunting do you think he has done in this game? How similar is it to past Benmage town play you have seen?

CyberSet: are you asking if I think being hypocritical is a scumtell? I think treating two players differently when they're essentially doing the same thing can be a scumtell. I don't think it counts if one of the players is yourself. I think it's certainly indicative that Esp is getting defensive and frustrated with the reasons that he's getting suspected. The part I don't like is that his vote doesn't seem to be based on thinking you're scum. It's basically trying to push you away from what you're doing right now, which is suspecting him, and that, to me, suggests dubious motivation.

[Benmage]

Supernatural and Simpson's are relatively recent.

Then there's Mafia 116 118 and 100.

Blanking on the top of my head.. but that should suffice.

[Benmage]

LL, hell no.. I don't recall things like that... feel free to Meta me.

[AlmasterGM]

VOTE: Magua

I have to, because this action only works on vote leaders.

Magua, you better not be a Miller.

Test by Fire: Magua

If this is real I'm gonna do a little dance.

Magua deaaaath.

There are actually so many people in this game I want to kill I don't even know what to do. I need to prioritize.

Let's start with Magua and then work from there.

[AlmasterGM]

Also Benmage is probably town and the wagon on him is filled with sketchy scum.

[AlmasterGM]

It's like "trololol let's go after Benmage cause he's not doing anything"

WELL WHAT ABOUT LOCKE OR ESPEONAGE THEN, HMMM?

[Benmage]

DGB are we waiting on ooba to do something... or can we keep moving on.. I'd really love to rail into Magua for post 1086.

[DrippingGoofball]

I'm waiting, but we can keep moving you know.

Otherwise day will be too short on information.

[Magua]

If this is real I'm gonna do a little dance.

Magua deaaaath.

Mmmmmm. This'll be fun when DGB declares me innocent. Then I'll get to see you be all "trololololKaleidoscopegambit"

[Benmage]

Because you flat out said that I was scummier than hasdgfas, whereas Hinduragi and DGB have both just said that we're both scum.

And bullshit if "1% difference" is the cause of "in this case.. i guess Cow. (Tho i think at this moment I'd prefer Magua)"

I say I preferred you over Cow. I never say Cows not scummy. And my example is to illustrate that clearly I found the difference between you and cows scumminess negligible. I don’t understand how this concept is hard for you to understand… It is one of the most basic.

It’s like having a scum list… If you can’t lynch you’re top scum suspect… but can easily get your #3 lynched…. You get your #3 lynched. I don’t think I have ever played a game where I have only voted my top suspect… HAS ANYONE EVER?

I WOULD LOVE IT IF EVERYONE WEIGHS IN AND TELLS MAGUA HE IS A FUCKING RETARD.

Everyone in their next post say how you in EVERYGAME do not always vote your top suspect.

I am literally dumbfounded that you are pursuing this.

[Benmage]

AGM, did you get culted last night?

[AlmasterGM]

no

[Hinduragi]

Hinduragi, DGB & LMP have said that either him or Maemuki are probably scum but haven't actually gone anywhere with that position

Read: D2 Start.

Cyber, point out who made which posts.

Yes, Ben is town. I could pick up his wagon being scum driven but I don't see Thor scum. Also, this lack of scrambling makes me think we haven't called out the scumteam yet, like we're missing some and the others we did call out are a little calm or we called out mafia and cult. There is a lot of avoiding the Cow wagon going on though, which does make me feel better about it.

Is Cow stalling or what? That's why this day feels like it's not going anywhere.

Can someone explain how we're supposed to win now? Unless mafia starts killing cult off or we have a good number of unrecruitables, I feel like we're screwed.

[Benmage]

Let's play a game.

Everyone

ought to list the 3 people they, if the CR would seek to recruit.

List 3 please... a bullet as to why would be much appreciated.

[AlmasterGM]

It's D3. If we've lost already this is a dumb game.

And yeah, cow is stalling.

ALL THE SCUM ARE STALLING WAGONS ON THEIR BUDDIES

ALL OF THEM

[Benmage]

Damnit AGM/ HINDU!!

DO YOU TWO ONLY ALWAYS VOTE YOUR TOP SUSPECT... OR DO YOU VOTE YOUR SECOND IF THE LYNCH SEEMS MORE VIABLE?!?!?

[AlmasterGM]

Let's play a game.

Everyone

ought to list the 3 people they, if the CR would seek to recruit.

List 3 please... a bullet as to why would be much appreciated.

I would pick people that i thought were unlikely to be nk'd or lynched. also people that are good at staying under the radar. probably like you, empking, or faraday.