Scummies 2011 Nominations

[ReaperCharlie]

RC, if we start doing that shit, we'll have to give out an award for every god damned role.

This.

Quiet, you! Even Ythan agrees!

Being talked about.

nth

, obv! <3

[Ythan]

Charlie and I only agree on this most blatantly obvious good ideas.

YRC hydra for Title Fairy.

[ReaperCharlie]

We would be an excellent team at pretty much everything if we put our heads together and stop bickering.

We should mate.

[ReaperCharlie]

DATE! I meant... DATE.

[Ythan]

We should mate.

Whoa now.

[tanstalas]

We would be an excellent team at pretty much everything if we put our heads together and stop bickering.

We should mate.

Freudian slip much?

[DemonHybrid]

Nominate the following award:

Best Use of a Power Role

Just to make it official.

This is a fantastic idea.

[gandalf5166]

Or, put differently, do we give one award for town PR play and one for scum PR play, or just one regardless of alignment?

Edit: The reason I ask is because I think that town PR play is considerably more difficult than scum PR play given that you generally don't have buddies to bounce ideas for targets off of and are generally at a significant knowledge disadvantage anyways.

I think that in general, town power roles would be more deserving of it, but if somebody did a great job, I don't see why scum shouldn't be eligible for it.

[Quilford]

Nominate the following award:

Best Use of a Power Role

Just to make it official.

This is a fantastic idea.

Totally gonna nom that C9++ open you held when it gets accepted

[Twistedspoon]

Nominate

zMuffinMan for funniest player

[Twistedspoon]

oh, and

Nth

Feysal for most outstandind newcomer

[AGar]

Nominate DemonHybrid for Smooth Operator for NY 129: Mafia on Werewolf Island

I was his backup, so maybe I'm a bit biased, but I didn't have to step in once for this game for so much as a votecount. He kept on top of things (I don't believe more than 24 hours elapsed between any two votecounts, prods were swiftly distributed and noted), and when things went wrong (two separate modkills arose), he handled them exceptionally well. Kept me up to date on every happening, and was ridiculously OCD about pretty much everything. One of the best modding efforts I've seen overall.

[Mr. Flay]

Nominate

zMuffinMan for funniest player

It's customary to provide examples.

[Powerrox93]

Nominate DemonHybrid for Smooth Operator for NY 129: Mafia on Werewolf Island

I was his backup, so maybe I'm a bit biased, but I didn't have to step in once for this game for so much as a votecount. He kept on top of things (I don't believe more than 24 hours elapsed between any two votecounts, prods were swiftly distributed and noted), and when things went wrong (two separate modkills arose), he handled them exceptionally well. Kept me up to date on every happening, and was ridiculously OCD about pretty much everything. One of the best modding efforts I've seen overall.

Seconed

[Swift Justice]

Nominate

zMuffinMan for funniest player

It's customary to provide examples.

+ makes it a hell of a lot easier if the judges have some actual examples of funny posts from the player.

[SleepyKrew]

I don't recall muffin ever making me laugh.
He strikes me as the kind of person who takes Mafia seriously, actually.

[xRECKONERx]

nth DemonHybrid for Werewolf Island

[Twistedspoon]

I don't recall muffin ever making me laugh.
He strikes me as the kind of person who takes Mafia seriously, actually.

Maybe I just make him funny then ^_^

[ReaperCharlie]

Nominate TGGC for Professor Mafia

2nd.

This tool, while unpolished, could be very useful.

---

Also, I am gonna

Nominate SleepyKrew

for not only

Best Newbie

*, but also for

Most Cunning Manipulation

**, for his surprising upset win in the game Newbie 1098: Trouble in Trieste, which was widely considered to be a locked-in win for town by anyone privy to players' alignments.

Replaced in D1, dealt with his predecessors' stigma expertly, without ever garnering more than one vote on him.
His only partner was lynched on Day 1, leaving him completely alone for the entirety of the game.
He was able to outsmart the likes of players that have been around for years (Faraday, Kublai Khan, xRECKx, dramonic).
Perhaps most importantly, his join date is AFTER the game's start date. i.e. He was a raw, raw newbie.

*The above nomination of Best Newbie is dependent on whether April 27 2011 was actually his join date.
**The above nomination of Most Cunning Manipulation stands on its on, whenever he actually joined the site.

[AGar]

Actually, he's an alt. And he's admitted to such in scumchat.

[gandalf5166]

Why did he join a newbie as a newbie then?

[AGar]

He replaced. Anyone can take the newbie slot.

[gandalf5166]

Oh right.

[ReaperCharlie]

Oh, nvm then. Darn you, SleepyKrew. I thought you were all ballin' an' shiznit.

Still, good game though.

[mastin2]

Nominate DemonHybrid for Smooth Operator for NY 129: Mafia on Werewolf Island

Oh, right. I was going to nom Demon for that, but forgot.

N'th.