New York 134: Planet of Hats (Scum Win!)

[Palisade]

Or, I just have a strong town-read (reads change. Mine did on day two) and am frustrated (screaming at him--I know what I'm doing!) that my partner is holding onto a dead read. (That's

my

territory, Redhead! >.<) And am determined to make sure that lynch doesn't go through. That's just what I do.

[sanchocolates]

I don't see it, and you aren't communicating in our QT. Stop posting reads without explaining them or at least discussing them with me, asshat.

Um, 3rd party?

[bvoigt]

Or, I just have a strong town-read (reads change. Mine did on day two) and am frustrated (screaming at him--I know what I'm doing!) that my partner is holding onto a dead read. (That's

my

territory, Redhead! >.<) And am determined to make sure that lynch doesn't go through. That's just what I do.

And what gave you this strong town read?

I don't see it, and you aren't communicating in our QT. Stop posting reads without explaining them or at least discussing them with me, asshat.

Um, 3rd party?

Could you elaborate?

[Wraith]

Votecount 2.1

Palisade

(5)

:

xRECKONERx, SleepKrew, Celebloki, sanchocolates, Taro

Knight of Cydonia

(3)

:

Thor665, PBuG, Palisade

chkballin

(1)

:

Palisade

, bvoigt

JDGA

(1)

:

chkballin

PBuG

(1)

:

SleepyKrew

, Knight of Cydonia,

Palisade

,

Celebloki

,

Taro

jilynne1991

(1)

:

Parabollocks

Parabollocks

(1)

:

65536

SleepyKrew

(0)

:

xRECKONERx

Noting Voting

(6)

:

Mist7676, JDGA, jilynne1991, Zihark, PeregrineV, BeaverWeasel

With 19 alive it takes

10

to lynch.

Deadline is

July 13, 2011

My bad, just started a morning summer class so I'm a little short on time M-Th. BeaverWeasel and chkballin will be prodded if they do not post by the time I get home from work tonight.

[Taro]

Pretty sure I'm not voting jilynne1991 mod...

Too many scummy players @_@

PBuG, Palisade, sancho, celebloki...
But they don't make sense together.

unvote: PBuG

(preeeetty sure this is where my vote actually was)

Vote: Palisade

Please don't hydra again if you can't do it properly. Also your moonlogic and bad reasonings are showing a lot.
Oh, and stop trying to white knight and bus your buddy at the same time, it's confusing.

[Wraith]

I specifically told myself not to confuse the IGMEOY with the Vote...

And I confuse the IGMEOY with the vote.

Fixed and updated

[chkballin]

Alright, been out for a few days. Sorry about that; we all know how life can get a hold of us sometimes. Content within the next 24.

~

CHK

BALLIN

[Thor665]

Noting Voting

(6)

:

Mist7676, JDGA, jilynne1991, Zihark, PeregrineV, BeaverWeasel

Hi - we're a list of at least 1-2 lurking scum as well as of town players who are allowing scum to get away with it.

[Palisade]

Mod: We're voting for KoC

.

And what gave you this strong town read?

Semi-explained in-thread, semi-explained in-QT. Reasoning is not my strongsuit. I'd rather not waste my time explaining the read when I am NOT very good at elaborating on my reads. They're there. They just are.

My partner might do a better job of explaining my town-read than I do, ironically enough. I'm about to do something else, so I can't spend my time trying.

That something being (now with my partner's permission) a Wall explaining why KoC, Celebloki, Sancho, and chkBallin are our scumteam. It probably won't take me more than 48 hours of work, though it depends on how much I slack off.

[Wraith]

Fixed.

@Thor: As a reminder Mist and Zihark have replaced out and I still cannot find a replacement for them.

If any players know anyone who they could possibly convince to replace in, please do so.

[Celebloki]

Mod: We're voting for KoC

.

And what gave you this strong town read?

Semi-explained in-thread, semi-explained in-QT. Reasoning is not my strongsuit. I'd rather not waste my time explaining the read when I am NOT very good at elaborating on my reads. They're there. They just are.

My partner might do a better job of explaining my town-read than I do, ironically enough. I'm about to do something else, so I can't spend my time trying.

That something being (now with my partner's permission) a Wall explaining why KoC, Celebloki, Sancho, and chkBallin are our scumteam. It probably won't take me more than 48 hours of work, though it depends on how much I slack off.

You chumps really need to sign your posts. At this point one of you can't make cases or show reasoning for his reads and is essentially telling us to "deal with it". My understanding of this hydra is someone that wants to make posts on a fun forum while his partner plays the game but never seems to come around. If this isn't the most anti-town thing I've ever read I don't know what is. Is this some hydra made up of multiple personalities of DK or something. So you go ahead and tell us you can't make cases and aren't good at reasoning, but then you want us to take you seriously when you post a wall about who you think the scumteam is. This is ludicrous. Can't we just lynch this guy already?

[Palisade]

Spoiler: This Is A Distraction

It's not that I can't make cases. I can. And am in the process of doing so.
I just suck at it. I much prefer

and is essentially telling us to "deal with it".

^Doing that. It works better for me as a playstyle than writing cases, since I'm that bad at cases. (Since people are unaware of who I am and I promised my partner not to out myself, though, the "deal with it; that's just who I am" approach doesn't work that well. >.<)

But, hey. I do have a partner, to help me improve. (Just 'cause I'm more experienced than him doesn't mean I can't learn a thing or two from him.)

The best way I have to describe it is as this:
I can give reasons; my reasons for my suspects are Interactions, Tone, Motive, a little VCA, and--most vitally--Process Of Elimination.
I have trouble elaborating on (almost) all of those. "This interaction is why they're scum."
"But WHY is that interaction why they're scum?"
"...it...just is?"

Since I am bad at explaining that, my cases are generally not that strong.
That doesn't mean I can't build a case. Just that it's historically not gone very well for me.

If you don't mind, I have made significant progress on my case. But this slows me down. It'll get done faster if I ignore the thread.

[xRECKONERx]

Unvote.

I have my reasons.

[Nobody Special]

Posting in the next little bit. Conferring with SecondHead.

[Nobody Special]

Fuck.

[chkballin]

JDGA's response makes my gut rest easily.

VOTE: Palisade

Of all the things I'm scum for, it's because I'm joking with Thor665? That's reaching and especially so after quite a few people have joked and been jest back and forth. With this same mindset, SleepyKrew is scum too (for joking with Reck) right? Oh, no, he's not. Which should mean that I'm not either, right? Unless you're contradicting scum.

Then there's your vote on KoC which

totally looks sincere

and is about as valid as your vote for me.

Add the other things people have said and I'm convinced you're scum.

Then there's this new excuse you're giving us. "I'll finish this if I ignore you guys" sounds a lot like "I'm going to hopefully active-lurk myself out of this lynch." Do not like.

PEDIT: What's up NS? I didn't expect you to describe yourself as having almond hair...

[BeaverWeasel]

Yes, whatever, we all know NS/FirstHead can be an idiot. Shall we move on?


Celebloki is incredibly town. Often, when someone says this, it's not based on anything, but I have my reasons. Plus, he's just very town.

I'm rereading the thread. But right now, I'm confident that Celebloki, Ballin, and one to two of {PBuG, KoC, Parabol} (with one more name between {sancho, JDGA, Mist, Zihark, *numbers*, Taro} being scum if only one) is our scumteam. Gimme a sec to figure out which of them it is. (The result is the difference between me sheeping Thor and me demanding people sheep Me. )

OMG are you seriously being this convulted? Die.

Know what? I'll sheep Thor.

Unvote, Vote: KoC

.

Yar. Looking back I think I'm going to;

Vote: Knight of Cydonia

Also, protip - when you're miller you claim miller Day 1. There is so much gak we wouldn't have even had to do if DK had been sitting behind a miller claim like he should have.

What's your reason to voting him?

The scumteam has revealed itself!

Thanks, Sancho. You've made this a walk in the park for us. Celebloki, Ballin, Sancho, KoC. They die. Today.

Surely you realize that we only have one lynch today?

Swag/PBuG is quite scummy/newbie for jumping on the DK wagon with the admitted sheepening. Must keep eyes on that one.


SleepyKrew is so newb it hurts. Can we kill it now?


Palisades is overconfident wheeeee

Of course, sanchoc has to vote for the wrong reason entirely.

So much scum, so few votes.

Vote: Palisade

[xRECKONERx]

Ah, NS is a part of the BeaverWeasel hydra.

That explains why they're so anti-town.

Palisade wagon's just gonna keep growing, apparently. Hmmm.

This REEKS of mislynch fueled by scum at this point. Analysis...eventually. I'm exhausted.

[TBuG]

This REEKS of mislynch fueled by scum at this point. Analysis...eventually. I'm exhausted.

I agree heavily. Most of my suspects right now are on it which makes me feels really uneasy.

[Palisade]

I'll give you a hint.

Palisade (5.5): SleepKrew, Celebloki,

sanchocolates

, Taro,

chkballin

(

KoC

)

Underlined-->Honorary Member(s). (Count as half a vote--too lazy to track down all of them.) Italicized-->added since last votecount.

[Palisade]

Whoops. Forgot to bold Celebloki.

I'll give you a hint.

Palisade (5.5): SleepKrew,

Celebloki, sanchocolates

, Taro,

chkballin

(

KoC

)

Underlined-->Honorary Member(s). (Count as half a vote--too lazy to track down all of them.) Italicized-->added since last votecount.

Fix'd.

[BeaverWeasel]

So, you're saying the bolded ones are your scumpicks?

[Palisade]

Yes.

[Palisade]

Oh, right.

I missed Beaver's vote on us. It's actually 6 right now. (Reck got off, two got on.)

[TBuG]

Celebloki is incredibly town. Often, when someone says this, it's not based on anything, but I have my reasons. Plus, he's just very town.

Share them. And while you're at it, reason your vote, because you spent that post dancing around why you actually think Palisade is scummy. If there's so many suspicious people, you surely have a credible reason.