OPEN 310 - Medical Mafia - TOWN WIN

[Hoppster]

Still happy with my Moratorium vote.

Mod: V/LA Friday-Sunday (inclusive). Sorry for lack of notice.

Those of you wanting a non-gut case on Mor will need to wait until late-Sunday/Monday, Sowwy.

[Quilford]

I think we should have every doctor alive target the same person provided we haven't won by tonight. Since we know the paranoid doctor is still alive, we can hopefully clear someone without them dying, provided we don't target the paranoid doctor themselves. The worst that can come out of this is a weak doc death putting us in 3way LyLo, but that gives us guaranteed scum anyway.

[Quilford]

Then again, this would mean that Helloo dies (provided we target non-mafia). Oh well.

Everybody, who would you like to be hopefully clear by tomorrow (hint: you cannot answer yourself).

I'd say Hoppster; I'll have to think about it.

[Quilford]

provided we don't target the paranoid doctor themselves

Not really a problem, actually, since there's only one result that confirms the targeted player as scum: a weak doc death

and

no other kill.

[HellloooNewman]

LOL, try thinking for 5 minutes, THEN posting.

[Quilford]

wut

[HellloooNewman]

3 posts, 10:03, 10:05, 10:07. It was basically a stream of conciousness. Nvm, I was just being a smartass.

[Quilford]

lolk

[AntB]

VOTE COUNT - 6 Alive - 4 to Lynch

tim_hill1990

<- Quilford

Moratorium

[L-1] <- Hoppster - Amrun - HellloooNewman

Hoppster

<- Moratorium

Quilford

<- tim_hill1990

V/LA

-> Amrun (Indefinite)-> Hoppster (Sunday?)

DEADLINE

FRIDAY 8 JULY 2011 23:59:59 UTC

(expired on 2011-07-08 19:59:59) remaining.

[Amrun]

Quilford, I don't understand how your plan does anything of the sort - we don't know how multiple docs will resolve, and scum could just choose to no kill if we did pick town.

My plan has already been decided on and involves you submitting no action and Hoppster and HN submitting something.

Tim or Quilford, are you willing to move to Moratorium?

[Quilford]

Tim or Quilford, are you willing to move to Moratorium?

nope

[tim_hill1990]

Sorry to hear about your dad Amrun, I wish him and you all the best.

Tim or Quilford, are you willing to move to Moratorium?

Only if necessary, I think Quilford is more likely scum than Moratorium, though from my perspective either one of them is likely to be scum.

[Sunday]

scum could just choose to no kill

That's also a problem with your plan.

[Quilford]

scum could just choose to no kill

That's also a problem with your plan.

That's me failing to log out of my hydra. Sorry.

[Amrun]

What problem, Quilford?

Tim, so are you saying you're willing to hammer Moratorium?

[HellloooNewman]

Exactly, what problem? The scum choose not to take out a townie? Oh noes!!!

[Quilford]

Amrun, my plan is better. If we all target the same person several helpful things will happen.

1) That person will not be able to be killed.
2) That person (if they are Mafia) will not be able to kill that night: the Paranoid Doctor will be targeting them.
3) If the targeted person is Mafia the weak doc will die.

We can then deduce the Mafioso by exactly who was killed.

Your plan just relies on random chance and doesn't provide us with any useful information.

[HellloooNewman]

...........am I just tired, or does that actually make sense?

[Quilford]

The only problem is if you are the weak doc.

[HellloooNewman]

I don't care if I die, as long as my death is not senseless. If it catches the scum and wins the game, I am all for it.

[Amrun]

Actually, that sounds okay. There are lots of resolution issues.

Mod: If the quack is still alive, would a normal protection negate that? How do multiple protections resolve?

[Quilford]

It's certainly not perfect, but it has a better chance of catching mafia than the previous plan tbqh.

[HellloooNewman]

So, we lynch Mora today, then we all protect who tonight? Tim? Quilford? Amrun?

[Quilford]

Tim or I.

[Amrun]

Tim.

I would like to wait for mod answers, though.