Any Band U-Pick (Town Wins)

[nintendoaddict1]

So either you're not sure or you don't want to say? Well, you explained your supposed 'gut' reads on them, so why did you include the '(or don't want to say)' bit?

Full disclosure. Go read Open 180 for an example of the "don't want to say" reason. It's linked from my wiki.

And you are now rolefishing EPM.

Again I say: what is this i dont even

Asking for a claim from someone who's within lynching range is not rolefishing, it's SOP. And I notice you outright claimed when you were at L-3 (I think), so I don't see what your issue is with having someone else claim at L-2.

Full disclosure? BS. You say you might not want to say your motivation for the read, then EXPLAIN the read. Doesn't sound like you really meant it when you said you might not want to say.

Oh, and there is a HUGE difference when I claimed, no one was ASKING for my claim. If they did, I would have said they were rolefishing.

[Seraphim]

..........I understand the concept of distancing.

But how is "rolefishing" distancing? In fact, what's he done is definitely NOT rolefishing. Calling for a claim isn't rolefishing especially when the player in question is within lynching range.

Calling for a claim IS rolefishing, and you're on my scumlist too. Now that you are defending them it is only strengthening my scumread on you.

I'm scared, bro. Stop scaring me.

Would you rather we lynch EPM without a claim which almost happened?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Rolefishing is by definition more subtle than asking for someone's claim. No offense, but you have no clue what you're talking about, nintendo.

[Seraphim]

Rolefishing isn't always scummy either

[nintendoaddict1]

..........I understand the concept of distancing.

But how is "rolefishing" distancing? In fact, what's he done is definitely NOT rolefishing. Calling for a claim isn't rolefishing especially when the player in question is within lynching range.

Calling for a claim IS rolefishing, and you're on my scumlist too. Now that you are defending them it is only strengthening my scumread on you.

I'm scared, bro. Stop scaring me.

Would you rather we lynch EPM without a claim which almost happened?

I think if someone claims it should be because they deem it necessary, not because people are telling them to. Those people telling someone to claim could easily be scum trying to distance or send subtle clues to their buddies.

P. Edit: Depends on who does it and who else in the game thinks it is scummy. In this case, I think it was a scummy call fro EPM to claim.

[nintendoaddict1]

Rolefishing is by definition more subtle than asking for someone's claim. No offense, but you have no clue what you're talking about, nintendo.

Which is why they might outright ask for the claim in order to look less scummy as a bussing gambit.

[Seraphim]

Have you ever seen this behavior before from scum?

[Trumpet of Doom]

Full disclosure? BS. You say you might not want to say your motivation for the read, then EXPLAIN the read. Doesn't sound like you really meant it when you said you might not want to say.

BAHAHAHAHAHAHA you're just trying to throw everything you can think of at me and see if something sticks. Flail moar plz. (Protip: Just because "I don't want to say" didn't apply to either of those reads, that doesn't mean it hasn't in the past, and more to the point, that doesn't mean it won't in the future.)

[Juls]

I'm rereading this game from scratch at some point tonight and will post full reads. I haven't read the past few pages yet. Just an FYI.

[nintendoaddict1]

BAHAHAHAHAHAHA you're just trying to throw everything you can think of at me and see if something sticks. Flail moar plz. (Protip: Just because "I don't want to say" didn't apply to either of those reads, that doesn't mean it hasn't in the past, and more to the point, that doesn't mean it won't in the future.)

Who's flailing? You're downplaying what you've done and now you're trying to redirect suspicion onto me.

[Trumpet of Doom]

Who's flailing? You're downplaying what you've done

Remind me again: What have I done?

and now you're trying to redirect suspicion onto me.

What suspicion? You and Furry are the only ones expressing any suspicion of me ATM.

[nintendoaddict1]

Who's flailing? You're downplaying what you've done

Remind me again: What have I done?

and now you're trying to redirect suspicion onto me.

What suspicion? You and Furry are the only ones expressing any suspicion of me ATM.

Read your ISO.

That may be but you're not responding well to the pressure.

[diddin]

..........I understand the concept of distancing.

But how is "rolefishing" distancing? In fact, what's he done is definitely NOT rolefishing. Calling for a claim isn't rolefishing especially when the player in question is within lynching range.

Calling for a claim IS rolefishing, and you're on my scumlist too. Now that you are defending them it is only strengthening my scumread on you.

[nintendoaddict1]

..........I understand the concept of distancing.

But how is "rolefishing" distancing? In fact, what's he done is definitely NOT rolefishing. Calling for a claim isn't rolefishing especially when the player in question is within lynching range.

Calling for a claim IS rolefishing, and you're on my scumlist too. Now that you are defending them it is only strengthening my scumread on you.

Do you have anything besides fluff to add here, diddin?

[Trumpet of Doom]

Read your ISO.

Whatever you're talking about, I don't see it. Enlighten me?

That may be but you're not responding well to the pressure.

...what do you expect me to do? Your attack on me is crap, and even if it wasn't, you'd be scum for unrelated reasons anyway.

[diddin]

..........I understand the concept of distancing.

But how is "rolefishing" distancing? In fact, what's he done is definitely NOT rolefishing. Calling for a claim isn't rolefishing especially when the player in question is within lynching range.

Calling for a claim IS rolefishing, and you're on my scumlist too. Now that you are defending them it is only strengthening my scumread on you.

Do you have anything besides fluff to add here, diddin?

You're missing the point.

[nintendoaddict1]

Read your ISO.

Whatever you're talking about, I don't see it. Enlighten me?

That may be but you're not responding well to the pressure.

...what do you expect me to do? Your attack on me is crap, and even if it wasn't, you'd be scum for unrelated reasons anyway.

I don't need to, you're scum and you know it.

Heh, what unrelated reasons would those be, hm?

[evilpacman18]

Quite a shame it had to go this way, really. I figured I had pretty good reads.

I'm a VT (I considered PR claim gambit here but no thanks). Nintendo is town. Only one of Juls/Parabollocks is scum but there is definitely one scum in there. Lynch CSL. Lynch Seraphim. CES is probably right about Gaoth. Compare the wagons on Nintendo and me. I'm sure not about to do it but I bet you can catch 1 or 2 scum with that.

[evilpacman18]

Hell. Parabollocks is scum, not Juls. My wagon exists because a Parabollocks wagon does not.

[diddin]

Vote: EPM

L-2 since Nintendo unvoted.

What's your band again?

[diddin]

EBWOP: Nvm, you never claimed it. What's your band?

[nintendoaddict1]

Vote: EPM

L-2 since Nintendo unvoted.

What's your band again?

What point is there in mentioning me in your post? Why not just say "L-2 since I just voted"?

[evilpacman18]

I did claim.

Islands - Swans (Life After Death)

[evilpacman18]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wq3-98XJCfw

[diddin]

Vote: EPM

L-2 since Nintendo unvoted.

What's your band again?

What point is there in mentioning me in your post? Why not just say "L-2 since I just voted"?

He was previously L-2 before you switched to ToD.