ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[ooba]

Vote Count

Benmage (4)

- Lost Butterfly, Empking, SpyreX, Hinduragi

Lost Butterfly (2)

- Benmage, Thor665

Not Voting (8)

- Locke Lamora, vezokpiraka, CyberSet, Magua, Nexus, LynchMePls, Espeonage, AlmasterGM

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch!

[Nexus]

I'd like to hear his other results too. I have no idea why those can't be claimed.

They will be claimed. I'd like everyone to post who they think is:
3 scum
3 town
3 cult

I dont want my results to influence these reads beforehand.

My fucking god, can you all stop spamming the thread measuring the size of your epenises?

Ben, claim your damn results. Noone else is going to post their fucking lists.

You do know how bad a situation you're in, right? You fake cced a cult cop, leading to his lynch, before going "lolgaizIwaslying." Now you've claimed a guilty on LB, conveniently as he started pushing you and backing you into a corner. You have a history of making retarded decisions.

Now claim the rest of your damn results. Please.

Elsewise, if LB is scum, then great.

I am not cult, nor scum. This is sadly how badly I play in all Large games. It's something I'm trying to rectify, but it isn't working too well x]

[vezokpiraka]

vote benmage

might move it when he apologises for being a retarded fuck, might not.

First post after dawn. You vote Benmage.

Then this whole clusterfuck happens. I bet you two are both cult. Benmage is maybe CR, but I'm not sure.

[vezokpiraka]

unvote
vote benamge

btw.

[Thor665]

In the morning I grok the 4-4-6 situation better for lylo claims.

@LB - serious question, what were you going for with your 'policy lynch Benmage' if you feared Cult lylo?

[Lost Butterfly]

because I could, I was willing to throw the game away, the satisfaction of lynching benmage would make up for a loss.

you're recruited anyway, so stop talking to me. the fact you even *think* Benmage is a cop is a hilarious thing in and of itself.

One more reason for why Benmage is scum, check any game where he gets in a 1/1 as town. look at choose your side agm, where he clogged the thread up with rage. you think he'd take me calling him a fucking idiot and awful player if he was town here? nope he'd be mad that there was the posibillity about him getting mislynched. Here look at him be all cute, scumscumscum.

[Lost Butterfly]

So, my final question (OMG ROLEFISH):

LB, are you unrecruitable?

I'm going to 'tehee' around this one for a little, as I'm pretty sure I know *why* you're asking, but I can tell you what you're thinking is impossible for one reason or another....assuming we're on the same page that SHOULD answer your question, but I'll be more blunt in if need be.

Btw, what's your flavour for the maiden being unrecruitable.

[Lost Butterfly]

*sigh*, you fucking idiot, I was getting great reactions.

magua's confirmed town beyond any doubt with his reaction to that lynch.

U saved cow..

^ legitimately thinks I saved cow. yes I am a scum aspect of the mother, benmage. despite that going completely against the flavour. so troll.

^ hey thor this guy is a cop with a guilty on me, just to be clear. i'm a scum troll governer who saved the cult cop?

[Lost Butterfly]

brb narrowing down cult leader again for scum. not sure who i ruled out, but i figure they need the help since they're bad.

[Thor665]

Your defense is you suck - right.
You also tell me to stop talking to you because 'I'm recruited' but then try to sell me anyway, proving you're trying to bully me into support. Cute, thanks. Good job ignoring I cited him as looking more town yesterday prior to being recruited, and if you think I was recruited yesterday and was buddies with Benmage than you are silly and should have sheeped me.

I don't actually think believing Benmage is a cop is totally out of sorts, he certainly was setting up that fakeclaim very early if that was his intent, and besides being obnoxious I don't see his play as unreasonable. Bleh, you annoyed me with that response so I'm getting bullish - but I think most of your 'proof that Benmage didn't have a guilty' quotes are actually much weaker than Benmages 'I'm a cop, lawl' proof posts.

So your contention is that a player you randomly decided to attack today due to RAGE and desire to tank the game;
1. Was cult.
2. Was cult in the optimal position to win the game because everything has gone right for cult.
3. Was Cult Recruiter all along *or* is an actual cop who can be recruited *or* is scum who can be recruited because he had set up cop fake/real claims since Day 1.
4. Decided everything would keep going his way so well he could afford to hard wagon you today, bet the scum wouldn't kill him tonight (which further suggests he's a real cop with a real guilty on you or is scum - not cult)

What am I missing here?

[Lost Butterfly]

[quote="ooba"]

Players alive:

2. Locke Lamora

3. Thor665

4. vezokpiraka
6. CyberSet

Setael

7. Lost Butterfly

9. Empking

10. Magua
11. Nexus
12. LynchMePls

15. SpyreX

16. Hinduragi

17. Benmage

19. Espeonage

Maemuki

20. AlmasterGM

Assuming I believe SpyreX's claim, and I probably do Also thinking AGM isn't cult, nor Emp due to play. Thor and Locke due to hascow. Benmage due to play.

That leaves *8* possible Cult Recruiters. Guess what, some of my list are probably scum!

Oh, LMP's probably not Cult Leader due to his agressiveness towards me day 1, it drew a lot of unwanted attention to himself, keeping calm would have suited him better, and I think he's not a mentalist so could control himself.

Gonna give the others a read, gut says it's not Hindu as cult leader. That narrows it down *EVER MORE* for the scum as there's surely 1 scum in my list. Guys, I'm lining 'em up and you knock em down, it's like fish in a barrel, sheep the sexy butterfly hydra.

Vezok is scum of some sort, if he's not in your mafia group shoot him I say. If he is, and I think he probably is? Eh, not sure I'd probably not shoot Nexus, would say he's less likely CL than the others. CyberSet is a decent chance I think.

Let me check Espeonage's last post, i want to see if it's a weird position for the CL to take.

[Thor665]

@LB - what alignment was Benmage when he did his cop role crumbs?

[Lost Butterfly]

Your defense is you suck - right.
You also tell me to stop talking to you because 'I'm recruited' but then try to sell me anyway, proving you're trying to bully me into support. Cute, thanks. Good job ignoring I cited him as looking more town yesterday prior to being recruited, and if you think I was recruited yesterday and was buddies with Benmage than you are silly

oh no, not trying to sell you, trying to sell everyone else.

and I suck? no i'm very good at this game, actually.

[Lost Butterfly]

@LB - what alignment was Benmage when he did his cop role crumbs?

there are no crumbs. the 'crumbs' are retarded and something that's co-incidental. his interaction with me is clearly not that of a cop with a guilty, but you already know that, trolololol.

[Thor665]

You suck for wanting to tank a game out of spite - which is what you said was your logic in calling for BM policy earlier today. You can define your play as 'very good' in that setup if you wish. I strongly disagree.

You really think his spelling of COP in his first three posts is a coincidence? With the weird word setup he went with in the very first post as well?

[Lost Butterfly]

So your contention is that a player you randomly decided to attack today due to RAGE and desire to tank the game;
1. Was cult.
2. Was cult in the optimal position to win the game because everything has gone right for cult.
3. Was Cult Recruiter all along *or* is an actual cop who can be recruited *or* is scum who can be recruited because he had set up cop fake/real claims since Day 1.
4. Decided everything would keep going his way so well he could afford to hard wagon you today, bet the scum wouldn't kill him tonight (which further suggests he's a real cop with a real guilty on you or is scum - not cult)

i've already told you there's no actual mafia cop in the game due to ooba mod meta, yo.

clearly 1 is correct

[Nexus]

Caboooom.

Game on.

vote SK

Post 53 is trying to hard.

Is this his cop crumb?

Erm, Ben, CGP doesn't spell cop...

[Lost Butterfly]

You suck for wanting to tank a game out of spite - which is what you said was your logic in calling for BM policy earlier today. You can define your play as 'very good' in that setup if you wish. I strongly disagree.

You really think his spelling of COP in his first three posts is a coincidence? With the weird word setup he went with in the very first post as well?

sure, I do. you really think his play is that of a cop with a guilty? when everything *screams* it's not.


feel free to blacklist me or something for 'playing against my wincon' post game then. i don't particularly care. i'd have been very happy to lynch benmage today regardless of his alignment. this is BONUS POINTS.

[Nexus]

And before you say "it almost says cop! it is a crumb!", it fucking isn't that hard to choose a random word that has O as the first fucking letter.

Now claim your other results.

[Lost Butterfly]

REPLACEOUT dipshit

hey thor, why is benmage telling the scum to replace out? explain this quote as 'benmage is a cop with a guilty'. i'm eager to find out your opinion on his thoughtprocess.

[Lost Butterfly]

that's not his 'breadcrumb' btw, it was a longer post than that. don't know which though.

[Thor665]

@Nexus - he spelled it out in the first letter of his first three posts - look at his iso, it's there.

I just did a search for caboo(m) in Benmage's iso and still have only found one usage of it. People really want to tell me he just decided to use onomatopoeia Day 1, Post 1 in this game for lulz - or do you think it was to help establish the cop claim?

@LB - I've only ever blacklisted one player, and you're still ages from that level of issue, so climb off the cross. Seriously now - you're saying Benmage is cult recruited not-cop who just randomly had his first three posts spell out cop, and is now using that to get you killed? That's what we're going with here? Ockham's Razor is going dull methinks.

EBWOP - That's actually a good point. Please answer my question above.

@Benmage - why were you telling scumLB to replace out?

[Lost Butterfly]

sure, it's weird, but there's far more going against it. the posts i've quoted and his interactions with me aren't that of a cop with a guilty.

[Lost Butterfly]

Sooo.. I'm reading the thread today/i guess tomorrow aswell.. Gruelish. I started from pg 7.. I'm on 11.. lol. I'm going to dinner now tho.

Anything people have lingering for me to answer... Shoot.

Anything key for me to focus on during the reread... Shoot.

This on pg 9 was funny:

Anyone catching up, this whole page can be skipped.

Anyways...bbl.

theoretically if ben's a cop, lol) there should be an innocent crumbed here! see if *you* can find it.

[Lost Butterfly]

in fairness Mina would probably not have let me vote Benmage all the way to a lynch anyway, if i'm thinking about it. and i would listen to her (most likely)