ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[Lost Butterfly]

god damn it i almost believe benmage could be an insane cop after reading his fucking ISO. but that makes no sense and if he is i'll rage at ooba.

'unless i'm insane LB is scum' is hard to ignore

.

BOOM. I IS A COP. U IS SCUM.

yeah i'd bring that up as scum alright, you idiot.

[Benmage]

Also, getting people to write town/scum/cult lists isn't protown and it never will be. (In my opinion, so you wouldn't have got me to do one anyway)

It commits people reads... Scum bussing or buddy or something... Theres connections there and it helps to not have "confirms" on the list.

[Benmage]

god damn it i almost believe benmage could be an insane cop after reading his fucking ISO. but that makes no sense and if he is i'll rage at ooba.

'unless i'm insane LB is scum' is hard to ignore

.

BOOM. I IS A COP. U IS SCUM.

yeah i'd bring that up as scum alright, you idiot.

Why not... convince everyone and me I am insane and mislynch vezo today, than me tomorrow. Sounds fun.

[ooba]

Vote Count

Benmage (5)

- Lost Butterfly, Empking, SpyreX, Hinduragi, vezokpiraka

Lost Butterfly (3)

- Benmage, Thor665, Nexus

Not Voting (6)

- Locke Lamora, CyberSet, Magua, LynchMePls, Espeonage, AlmasterGM

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch!

[AlmasterGM]

Alright, I've read over everything and here's the contradiction that gets me - Lost Butterfly's primary argument is "Benmage is an idiot who got forced into a 1:1 and decided to fakeclaim." However, Bnemage has the cop claim crumbed in his first post and the guilty very clearly crumbed as well. This means the exact opposite of what LB is saying is true - Benmage didn't "rage fakeclaim"...he's had this planned for quite some time. Could he have done it a scum? ...sure, but then that's some really brilliant planning and manipulation, which is inconsistent with LB's worldview that Benmage is a total bumbling idiot. If he took the time to carefully plan all this, why would he blow it at such a bad moment?

Benmage scum doesn't add up

Vote: Lost Butterfly

[Benmage]

I cant wait to hear u ask me to go out on a faith.. to ignore my results... and work with the guy who wanted to lynch me to tank the game... this ought to be good..

*popcorn*

[Lost Butterfly]

Mafia:
Cyberset
Vezok

I'm just gonna change my mind and say Benmage is actually an insane cop. Which makes me rage on a level you can't imagine, but I don't particularly care.


edit: look at the votecount Benmage, I'm winning this if I'm scum and I don't need to change tack.

magua would have obviously voted you, he hates ya. that's 6, I can get 2 more, Locke Lamora and LMP in all likelyhood if AGM doesn't play ball.

[Lost Butterfly]

Alright, I've read over everything and here's the contradiction that gets me - Lost Butterfly's primary argument is "Benmage is an idiot who got forced into a 1:1 and decided to fakeclaim." However, Bnemage has the cop claim crumbed in his first post and the guilty very clearly crumbed as well. This means the exact opposite of what LB is saying is true - Benmage didn't "rage fakeclaim"...he's had this planned for quite some time. Could he have done it a scum? ...sure, but then that's some really brilliant planning and manipulation, which is inconsistent with LB's worldview that Benmage is a total bumbling idiot. If he took the time to carefully plan all this, why would he blow it at such a bad moment?

Benmage scum doesn't add up

Vote: Lost Butterfly

yeah, you're actually right.

[Nexus]

IF anyone was so inclined, your two innocents could help with VCAs.

[Lost Butterfly]

I cant wait to hear u ask me to go out on a faith.. to ignore my results... and work with the guy who wanted to lynch me to tank the game... this ought to be good..

*popcorn*

i am beyond caring. you'll be quicklynched when i flip town. town will probably lose this.

[Lost Butterfly]

shrug, gonna see if I can do a re-read before I'm lynched, I'll ask Mina if she has anything to say too.

[Benmage]

I cant wait to hear u ask me to go out on a faith.. to ignore my results... and work with the guy who wanted to lynch me to tank the game... this ought to be good..

*popcorn*

i am beyond caring. you'll be quicklynched when i flip town. town will probably lose this.

You wanted to tank the game anways..... right?? What do u care about the town.

Magua wont not PTW. He'll vote u.

[Lost Butterfly]

IF anyone was so inclined, your two innocents could help with VCAs.

they're both scum.


if anyone actually thinks i'm mafia comitting these nightkills you don't know me very well, and should never fucking ever make comment on my play again.

[Lost Butterfly]

I cant wait to hear u ask me to go out on a faith.. to ignore my results... and work with the guy who wanted to lynch me to tank the game... this ought to be good..

*popcorn*

i am beyond caring. you'll be quicklynched when i flip town. town will probably lose this.

You wanted to tank the game anways..... right?? What do u care about the town.

Magua wont not PTW. He'll vote u.

well town have already likely lost at this point anyway, I lied about 'tanking the game' to make myself pro town for the record, i'd have unvoted you after 2/3 days.

[Nexus]

IF anyone was so inclined, your two innocents could help with VCAs.

they're both scum.

if anyone actually thinks i'm mafia comitting these nightkills you don't know me very well, and should never fucking ever make comment on my play again.

Delicious wine.

Incidentally, I don't know your play very well

[Lost Butterfly]

that's, uh, meta. but whatever.

[Lost Butterfly]

so I think Espe could be the cult recruiter. I don't know, thor, cyberset, vezok, locke are out. let's say i believe spyrex, fair enough.

i dunno. espe doesn't feel right. maybe it's magua *shrug*

[Lost Butterfly]

actually if nexus is lurky in general i guess he could be cult recruiter, plus he's setting up lynches between me and benmage in a way that looks fake, I think.

[AlmasterGM]

Benmage - this is important. Does the wording of your role PM leave room for the possibility of insanity?

Because on the first page, the mod says he will not lie to players. Depending on the wording of the PM, insanity could be considered lying.

Also, you said you had an innocent. I'm on phone so I dont wanna hunt back. Who is it on?

[Lost Butterfly]

(which obv doesn't make him cult leader but makes him scummy)

[Lost Butterfly]

Benmage - this is important. Does the wording of your role PM leave room for the possibility of insanity?

Because on the first page, the mod says he will not lie to players. Depending on the wording of the PM, insanity could be considered lying.

Also, you said you had an innocent. I'm on phone so I dont wanna hunt back. Who is it on?

vezok (actually can I see the breadcrumb, Ben?) and CyberSet

[Benmage]

Innocents - Vezo/Cyber

I Pm'd the mod.

It doesnt tell me I am the "mafia" cop.. or anything like it said cult cop for cow.


I'd like last words before LB gets hammered.. i know he only has 3 votes.. but this is the weekend and I may be busy a bit.. I want to draw some of my own conclusions before probably my last night.

[Empking]

Benmage is definitely scum. I know my vote isn't moving.

[Lost Butterfly]

I'll be getting last words in too. This isn't up for argument.

I have some minor problems with SpyreX's claim hence asking for clarification. Ftr if it wasn't obvious by now we're just a plain ol' vanilla, i was trying to draw a nightkill with my agressive play night 1. Surprised, thought we looked really town and were a gonner, actually.

[Benmage]

Its not very good. I imagined Capitilaze crumbing it.. but that would've taken serious effort.... Thats why all I did was post ---> as a prod dodge..

but then I got engulfed in the day... but I did sorta crumb it here:

Vezo, you're town.. but please help some more.

Which out of the blue counters my earlier days dislike.

And anyone even VEZO should be able to recognize how much i dislike VI's and vezo specifically and always seek their policy lynch... I didnt do so here.