ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[AlmasterGM]

whatever, you realise no matter what you say people will ignore it and I'll probably be the lynch, but in a 1 vs 1 where I'm town I'm not going to *let* myself be the lynch.

If you think Benmage is an insane cop and you're a VT, why would you not be willing to sacrifice yourself to a) save the cop and b) confirm his sanity?

In any case, I actually don't even think Benmage is an insane cop. That was a silly road, and I got mindtricked onto it by Faraday. I think he is a sane cop, and that Lost Butterfly is scum. People keep treating Lost Butterfly as confirmedtown and Benmage as a nutcase. But if you think about it, Lost Butterfly has done absolutely nothing to confirm himself as town. He's just played a good town game, which scum are perfectly capable of (see Mafia MetaMafia). The vision of Lost Butterfly as town is reliant entirely Lost Butterfly being more charismatic than Benmage. But that doesn't matter. Benmage cop makes sense. His guilty makes sense. Occam's razor this giant mess: Lost Butterfly is scum.

[Lost Butterfly]

Except that doesn't make more sense due to Benmage's behaviour and the fact you're ignoring that is silly.

How does it 'confirm' him in any way at all. You'll think insane cop is just as unlikely/likely tomorrow, and lynch Benmage for being 'scum'.

I think he's fakeclaiming as VT at this stage anyway, Mina's pointed out on AIM that insane cop in a cult game is actually incredibly terrible.

And fuck this HURR DURR METAMAFIA, that's retarded, I guess I should be policy lynched day 1, as ya know if I'm scum I'm just

so fucking good(lol)

I can't be read?

I'm blindingly obvious town. I don't self deprciate my scum team as scum by calling myself a moron. I'm not scum.

[AlmasterGM]

Do you ACTUALLY think he is fakeclaiming VT?

[Lost Butterfly]

Yeah. He's fakeclaimed cop in LYLO as Doctor before, so.

[AlmasterGM]

Also, wasn't the whole "insane cop" thing YOUR idea?

[Lost Butterfly]

he has a history of fakeclaiming guilties on people he believes is scum.

look at his play at the start of today even, HE DOESN'T HAVE A GUILTY, he's just more arrogant than he should be.

[Lost Butterfly]

Also, wasn't the whole "insane cop" thing YOUR idea?

Sure, I've changed my mind after conversing with Mina.

Also no offense, but if we were scum here I'd have Mina itt making pretty arguments and being 'logical' for me.

[AlmasterGM]

Did he crumb the guilty ahead of time in the games he fakeclaimed?

If you can show me he did this, then I will believe you.

Otherwise, no.

[Lost Butterfly]

Go on, give me my scum motivation for even BRINGING UP insane cop when he was at 5 votes and the wagon was going choo choo? I even had Thor questioning his start of day mindset. Why do I back off as scum there AGM?

[AlmasterGM]

Also no offense, but if we were scum here I'd have Mina itt making pretty arguments and being 'logical' for me.

Nope. Logic is against you. You need charisma right now, which is why you are ITT. Also, Mina might be afraid of panicking under pressure.

[Lost Butterfly]

Did he crumb the guilty ahead of time in the games he fakeclaimed?

If you can show me he did this, then I will believe you.

Otherwise, no.

not to my knowledge, one was a daycop guilty, you can probably ask LMP if he breadcrumbed it, he was the guy he faked it on iirc.

[Lost Butterfly]

Also no offense, but if we were scum here I'd have Mina itt making pretty arguments and being 'logical' for me.

Nope. Logic is against you. You need charisma right now, which is why you are ITT. Also, Mina might be afraid of panicking under pressure.

Mina's better as scum than town, so nope.

[Lost Butterfly]

Also no offense, but if we were scum here I'd have Mina itt making pretty arguments and being 'logical' for me.

Nope. Logic is against you. You need charisma right now, which is why you are ITT. Also, Mina might be afraid of panicking under pressure.

EXCEPT HIS FUCKING PLAY ISN'T THAT OF AS COP WITH A GUILTY AND YOU KNOW IT.

[Lost Butterfly]

whatever, I'm going to try and convince people who might actually fucking listen.

[AlmasterGM]

Whatever, I don't need to argue with you. If you can't show Benmage planting fake breadcrumbs in other games, then I don't think his history of fakeclaiming PRs matters. I would believe he drew a REAL PR in this game, and decided to play it properly by crumbing his guilties. You are scum who played well. I'm not going to be tricked into believing otherwise by you repeatedly saying "BUT IM BLEEDING TOWN." Yeah, I've been obvtown as scum too. It's challenging to pull off, but not impossible.

[Lost Butterfly]

you can apologise post game for letting herp derp paranoia get to you.

[Lost Butterfly]

hey thor,

you're better than this

[AlmasterGM]

If you're town then yeah, I'll say sorry.

If you're scum then I'm getting a Jabba the Hut avatar for being able to resist your mind tricks.

(Not actually).

[Lost Butterfly]

God damn it I'd never fake a governor as scum, what's the point I can just sit back and lurk and wait for ooba instead of actually trying to get information from the day.

[Benmage]

A few more of the lurkers need to post.. then conclusion..then hammer...then good day.

[Faraday]

i hope i'm wrong about you and you're scum, because i'd hate to blacklist you from my modded games. if you think i'd say this as scum (@ anyone) then you're retarded too.

[Faraday]

i can't wait till both wagons get to 7 votes and everyone refuses to budge

[Benmage]

i <3 u too

[Faraday]

SpyreX can *read me*, and he says we're town. Ya'll trolling with your scumreads on me.

[Lost Butterfly]

Benmage (8) - Lost Butterfly, Empking, SpyreX, Hinduragi, Magua, AlmasterGM, Nexus, Locke Lamora

^ this is my guess as to the people who will be voting benmage at the end of the day.

AGM, you're just waiting for Magua to vote Ben so we can get the order mostly right, right? >_>