ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[Benmage]

Thor's list is comical... too many town.

I already noted that...I could start calling you scum again if it'd make you happy.

Go nuts.

[ooba]

Vote Count

Benmage (6)

- Empking, SpyreX, vezokpiraka, Hinduragi, Bogre, Espeonage

Lost Butterfly (2)

- Thor665

vezokpiraka (1)

- Benmage

Espeonage (1)

- CyberSet

Not Voting (5)

- Magua, LynchMePls, Lost Butterfly, AlmasterGM, Nexus

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch!

[Nexus]

I'm not voting vezok :S

Fixed ~ ooba

[Thor665]

@Benmage wagon - how many of you, yesterday (Day 3), had a town read on Benmage?

[ooba]

Cogito Ergo Sum replaces LMP

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

YARR!

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Quick question: Is my slot obvtown or do I need to wow you guys with pro-town zest and can-do attitude?

[Thor665]

Zest.

[Hinduragi]

Unvote

Alright. I don't like Benmage's gambits. Next time, pick people who are looking null-er.

I think by this point we should focus our efforts on the CR. Spy and I have both said there's a possibility cult wouldn't be fucked since they couldn't recruit N1. So there's probably more than we thought.

Hindui and Bogre need to return to unvote...there's almost enough idiocy to get me lynched.

I know but I wasn't here. Look at obvscum going for a quicklynch. It makes me sad they think we're that bad of a town.

So Spy or AGM…. It isn’t AGM… It could be Spy. (Although the CR could also be SPY because…..)

Why can't it be AGM? And I don't know. I saw Spy's claim largely as a good town move. I rose suspicion he was probably the CR and he had zero to no pressure on him at the time. So mafia wouldn't shoot the wrong target, he claimed. Make sense? Do you think that was a fakeclaim? Everyone else who claimed an Embodiment was town. Would mod-ooba give safeclaims to a CR? Any mod meta on it? That would be gay.

[Faraday]

scum will have safeclaims, or would if I was modding. but otoh, town will have uncreuitables so.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

About halfway through the thread.

Vote: Espeonage

, hunch.

There will be zest tomorrow.

[Benmage]

V/LA till next Monday

[SpyreX]

@Benmage wagon - how many of you, yesterday (Day 3), had a town read on Benmage?

I sure did.

That doesn't change one whit about benmage, EVEN if this is a town move (its not) being a better decision.

[Hinduragi]

^Didn't see whoever posted the above quote and/or forgot to go back and answer questions I reread over my phone. Anyways, I had a town read on Benmage too. I think I said that already, though.

[SpyreX]

Anyways, I

had

a town read on Benmage too. I think I said that already, though.

Had?

The unvote and ohhh benmage gambits gorsh sure sounds like a have.

[Hinduragi]

..I was clearly replying to the post you quoted.

[SpyreX]

...and that changes what I'm saying about that how?

[Hinduragi]

@Benmage wagon - how many of you, yesterday (Day 3), had a town read on Benmage?

I had a town read on Benmage.

@Benmage wagon - how many of you, yesterday (Day 3), had a town read on Benmage?

"I have a town read on Benmage" doesn't make much sense context-wise. Past-tense =/= present tense.

I have a townread on Benmage now, yeah, if that's what you're asking.

[Hinduragi]

I sure did.

You said the same thing here

Wait, you still think he's scum/cult?

[SpyreX]

Yes, I do.

Pretty clear about that.

[Hinduragi]

Ok, but what about this doesn't match up with Benmage's play gambit-wise?

[SpyreX]

Really?

I could see fakecrumbing cop to draw an NK or what have you.
I could EVEN see faking a guilty to see what happens.

What I can't see is 4 days in a cult game faking a guilty on scum after the cult cop is lynched and pointing to the fake claim you made at game start.

NO.

This goes.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Okay, I've finished reading.

1. WE ARE NOT LYNCHING BENMAGE. "Yawn vt, let's breadcrumb cop." is mucho plausible and definite non-CR tell; if he's CR, then either he breadcrumbed cop without having a safe claim OR he decided to not go with his safe claim despite the fact that SpyreX basically got a pass for it just now. We need to hit the CR real soon and Benmage ain't it.
2. WE ARE LYNCHING ESPEONAGE. He's lurking, useless and his reads don't make any sense. The fact that he made this big :EFFORT: catch-up post just yells CR to me; he clearly hasn't been as motivated to contribute at any point since and drawing CR obviously motivates you, especially when there's some suspicion on the slot.
3. THE TOWN ISN'T GOING TO LISTEN TO ME. Faraday, I'm going to need your Irish charm to make these fuckers do the right thing.

P.S. Vez is obvscum too, but that goes without saying. CyberSet makes plenty of sense as Mafioso sadly. Magua reads as town. Nexus pushing for Benmage to reveal his innocents is a clear non-CR tell. SpyreX pretty much has to be town here despite his terrible push on benmage.

[Lost Butterfly]

Vote Espeonage

CHARISMA.

Not really sure what to make of CES posting that amount of words, leaning him being cheeky....town at the moment. Mina found your 1956 hilarious enough that I'm willing to sheep you.

[Hinduragi]

So we're ruling out it being a bus? Ok. My vote isn't doing much and CES seems to know everything that's going on and Faraday's behind him. Looks legit enough.

Wait? What is that? Is the Butterfly man wearing a..party hat?

Vote: Espeonage