Mini 1176: Dexter Season 2 (Game Over) Who Won?

[VP Baltar]

That part was about hind, not KKN.

re: socio - I was talking about the part where he claimed Rita and I thought he had the ability to recruit Kise. Then I looked back and Kise actually said he was the one with the ability to choose. That's what I meant by I rescinded that point.

[Fargrass]

That part was about hind, not KKN.

re: socio - I was talking about the part where he claimed Rita and I thought he had the ability to recruit Kise. Then I looked back and Kise actually said he was the one with the ability to choose. That's what I meant by I rescinded that point.

I know. I was commenting that non-newb scum has defended their scum buddies fake claim before. It's not something that sways me.

So why were you still voting for SP at the end of the day?

Final question why are you voting BB over KKN?

[VP Baltar]

I was still voting SP at the end of the day because at the time I signed off of MS, I still felt it was the best place for my vote. Then the day ended while I was gone.

I'm not prepared to divulge my reasons of voting BB over KKN at this point and time. I will explain how I came to my process of elimination though:

Town:
DDD - felt good about him for a long time, continue to do so
Sociopath - hind flipped scum. bussing isn't impossible, but unlikely
tanstalas - felt he was townish since day 1 and when I reread hind over night, they way they argued seemed genuine
Farside - felt you were town for awhile, and that was soldified by how mean you were to Sotty. Scum probably wouldn't be so intentionally cruel.
Kise - still survivor

Scum:
KKN - stayed out of the fray pretty much all game after the early pages of day 1. Strikingly similar play to hind.
BB - preceded by LMP, who I have felt was scum since his early interaction with me. He soft claimed out of left field, which gave me pause for a bit, but upon further consideration didn't seem like a very townie move. Also, he survived the night after soft claiming a PR that is potentially useful. Doesn't make any sense as town.

It's pretty cut and dry that there is scum in KKN and BB to me.

[VP Baltar]

ebwop: point in time

[VP Baltar]

Oh and AGM, who was sotty, who was clearly town.

[Kise]

Actually VPB, either Socio trolled me and is not Rita (LOOOOOOOOOOOL) or I was, dare I say, stopped by something (LOOOOOLL). The mod hasn't returned anything to me.

Kise put Fargrass to L-1 please. I don't believe we should put anyone to L-1 that Kise isn't voting for after yesterday.

This made me uncomfortable the other day. I may be voting you this phase.

[VP Baltar]

Why should i give you the freedom to do whatever when you've already proven yourself anti-town? You wanting to vote for the most popular wagon doesn't surprise me, so there is little reason for you to try and telegraph your plays to look better. Faux reasoning is faux. Knock it off.

Out of your two proposed LOOOOOL scenarios, which do you think is the most likely?

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

No really, so far everyone who has shown up today other than me and VPB is playing like a derp-a-doo. Why would VPB-scum kill Amrun? Especially when Amrun's play yesterday unconditionally accepted VPB as town, something even I wasn't comfortable doing, and then she was part of our town bloc. I know it's "WIFOM" but 99 times out of 100 if you're scum you keep that person alive and use them instead of killing them because they're so much more useful to you alive. Dead Amrun means VPB town and VPB town means I'm trusting his instincts.

VOTE: Blackberry

[VP Baltar]

Just as a warning AGM, my town read on Sotty is a not a free pass for you by any means. I expect serious contribution.

[Blackberry]

I'll post more later when I have time but:

A) Amrun dying suggests either Mafia discount me as a serious threat and didn't think I could get Amrun lynched

B) I was right about 2/3 of who are scum, and so mafia killed Amrun to discount my scumreads

C) DDD - If VP wouldn't kill Amrun, do you think I would kill Amrun as scum considering she was one of my top 3 suspects?

D) As already mentioned, why try to lynch a claimed PR over your other suspect?

E) I still want Kise to full claim

F) The fact that I survived the night is probably credited to the fact that a lot of people have expressed interest in killing me and thus why would mafia kill me when they could get my lynched?

[VP Baltar]

A lot of people have expressed interest in killing you?

And everything you've said about why Amrun was killed over you is LOL.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

C) DDD - If VP wouldn't kill Amrun, do you think I would kill Amrun as scum considering she was one of my top 3 suspects?

Yes.

[AlmasterGM]

Hey guys, I've got notes but they're on my laptop which is being repaired. I'm picking it up tomorrow, so I'll have a post then. Thanks.

[tanstalas]

I'd be willing to support a KKN wagon, not a BB wagon though.

I'd also be willing to support a Kise wagon if Socio confirms he is Rita, as either he was blocked somehow, and can continue to be blocked and I don't want him as a loose canon nearer endgame and side with scum or he may be gambiting scum.

[VP Baltar]

You still think I'm scum Tans? If so, why?

[Fargrass]

@VPB- If our meanness convinced you that we were town, then why did it take you 4 pages and 16 posts to unvote us? You were only on our wagon for two posts before we were mean.

Grass.

[VP Baltar]

came to my conclusion last night. I was also pissed off at the way you acted toward a friend of mine, which was uncalled for (and you've yet to apologize for it).

[Juls]

I would appreciate that subject dropped outside of game context until the game is finished please

[tanstalas]

You still think I'm scum Tans? If so, why?

By process of elimination you are still on my radar. Also what I mentioned in my second to last post

[VP Baltar]

I'd like to hear your process of elimination explained, just as mine was for your sake.

[SocioPath]

I was, dare I say, stopped by something (LOOOOOLL).

This doesn't make rational sense.
If there is a scum RBer, why would they block a claimed 3rd party?
If that is really the case, then more power to them.



By any means, tans is still scum.

Vote: tans

[tanstalas]

I'd like to hear your process of elimination explained, just as mine was for your sake.

SocioPath Probably town due to the Hindu push on him
Fargrass Leaning neutral, was sure she was scum on d1 and so, but lately I've gotten town vibes
VP Baltar Already explained
Blackberry Been calling LMP town forever, and BB replacing in and posting as he has I think that role is town for sure
tanstalas Obv Town
Kid Know Nothing Lurking, and not really saying much, probably scum as he hasn't added much in way of scumhunting, TBQH - I have forgotten he is in game at points
AlmasterGM Had an awesome town read on sotty
Kise Most likely survivor or gambiting scum
Debonair Danny DiPietro Townish read, though lately he is slipping, but still town

SO I doubt there is a SK in the game,or at the very least there is not an SK that has to kill.

I think there are probably 2 scum left in the game between Fargrass, KKN, BB and/or DDDP

And I think Socio is just stupid for his vote on me

[VP Baltar]

ok, tans might be scum. read that list and then try to get to this:

I think there are probably 2 scum left in the game between Fargrass, KKN, BB and/or DDDP

your brain will melt faster than if you had read 50 straight DGB shark posts.

[tanstalas]

Lynch me then

I already have 1 vote on me. Make it TWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[tanstalas]

Oh wait lol, I meant VPB not BB - I see what you were quoting now hehehe