ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[ooba]

Vote Count

Benmage (4)

- Empking, SpyreX, vezokpiraka, Espeonage

Espeonage (1)

- CyberSet

Hinduragi (1)

- Thor665,

Lost Butterfly (1)

- Magua

vezokpiraka (2)

- Benmage, AlmasterGM

Not Voting (5)

- Nexus, Lost Butterfly, Hinduragi, Cogito Ergo Sum, Bogre

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch!

[Espeonage]

Taking shot when CYS is over.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Shoot AGM or Thor.

[Espeonage]

It would be Thor or Magua for the shot. I've had an anti town read on Thor since I replaced in. Which, given Cow's investigate means Thor ain't cult unless scum can be recruited. So that leaves Magua. Next two on list* are Bogre and CyberSet factoring in my reads. Bogre seems like a weird person to recruit to me and I've had a CR read on CSet from the beginning.

So Magua or CSet?

*Using compiled list of reads.

[Espeonage]

Taking shot when CYS is over.

Ignore this, I thought it was about to start. -.-

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I will yell at you if you shoot Magua.

[Lost Butterfly]

Have cyberset posted since espeonage claimed dayvig?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Yes. They suggested he was mafia dayvig, remember?

[Lost Butterfly]

I am a 1-shot Vig variant. Embodiment of the Warrior for those who want the flavour claim.

I have a 1-shot Daykill that I can either use privately or in thread. I get another shot if I manage to kill a cult member. I wanted to wait as long as possible before using it to maximise the chance of hitting a cult member.

Considering where I am and that I am likely going to be eating rope I am willing to give my shot away to the majority. Recent consesus points to people like Emp, Spy, LB. Anyway, even if I nab a cult member today I'm not getting my next shot until tomorrow. I've been trying to get people to pay attention to my cult suspicions from when I replaced in for just this purpose, to find who the cult is so I can get them.

I think everything is true about this claim except alignment. I think he's mafia with a daykill and if he hits cult with it, he gets another kill. Makes perfect sense for mafia to be incentivized to take out cult.

Also, I don't see town in his position offering to give away the kill like this. If he were town, he should have SOME scum read strong enough to take them out and take responsibility. There are surely so many cult and mafia alive to influence it that it's just ridiculous for a townie to give it away to the mob.

oh they did, I don't like this, reads as someone upset their pet mislynch has gone to shit when they claimed a pr. if he's scum with a dayvig we probs won't see a kill tonight, as that's the best way to balance that sort of role. not trolololol scum you hit cult you get another shot on top if your nightkill.

[Lost Butterfly]

Yes. They suggested he was mafia dayvig, remember?

Yeah, just then.

I think they're some form of scum, but not sure which variety. have they interacted with vezok, like at all, I wonder. lemme skim

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Has anyone interacted with vezok?

[Lost Butterfly]

CyberSet are most likely mafia with vezok, yeah.

[Lost Butterfly]

Has anyone interacted with vezok?

No, but the early argument that MOI was scum with vezok is still odd to me, his being scum rested on vezok being scum so, it's very probable the MOI wagon has vezok buddies, but then again that's lolwagonanalysis, so who cares i'm not colouring pretty shit.

CyberSet are probably mafia anyway, so who cares.

[Lost Butterfly]

Ooba: can you put a deadline in your votecounts?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I'd be more convinced by the "they're more likely mafia" argument if we had a bunch of good CR suspects. I don't really feel comfortable excluding them here (although AGM is still my preferred shot).

[Lost Butterfly]

Okay, that's fair.

[SpyreX]

I just want a shot.

Cyber flipping cult would turn that dial way hot on Hindu. Recruiter after last page I'd hammer without second thought.
Magua flipping cult... AGM maybe?
AGM flipping recruiter would shock and awe me. Recruit maybe.

[Hinduragi]

I'm more confident in Thor flipping cult than Magua if it comes down to those two.

What makes AGM an obvious shot? I've thought most of what he said has made sense and was pro-town.

Cyber flipping cult would turn that dial way hot on Hindu.

You do realize I was the one pushing Cyber-scum during our fake-turned-real twilight, right?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

So you got recruited last Night?

P.S. It's not going to come down to Thor vs. Magua because Magua's town.

[Hinduragi]

Why would I get recruited last night when Spyrex was calling me the CR? Don't be stupid.

[Hinduragi]

Well, he called me cult. I don't know if he meant CR or not.

[SpyreX]

Actually yea shoot Cyber since I'm giving up on the crusade for now:

Hindu and LB are super obvcult. Espeon is still stupidly scum but the cult's what's on everyone's mind right now so there's not much else to be said there. Still going to mention him wherever possible though, he must not be allowed to slip under the radar.

Vote: Lost Butterfly

Need to read Benmage's play today again but we're both really confident about those other two right now.

Pretty sure I never called you anything more specific than cult if we're gonna quibble about types.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Why would I get recruited last night when Spyrex was calling me the CR? Don't be stupid.

Why would Spy's opinion be all that relevant? You're not a particularly likely recruit for last Night, but it's hardly out of the question if the CR wanted to go with a non-obvious pick who might be able to steer the town away from him (which e.g. Thor obviously can't do).

[Espeonage]

Kill: CyberSet

[Hinduragi]

Man, this moonlogic is stuff I cannot even touch right now.

You do realize I suck as scum, right? If DGB was here, she'd tell you. Faraday can tell you.

Now, if I was recruited simply for the purpose of kamikaze'ing for a CR right now, I'd be doing a hell of a better job. Let me break it down for you.

So I've already said I'm ok with being lynched if you guys are going to be this stubborn, right? Ok, good. If I was planning to be lynched anyways, I would have gone out with STYLE. A finesse type of scum play you wouldn't even imagine. Most likely it would start off with either a cop counterclaim or something else along those lines or I would've condemned Faraday if I wanted to play it safe. Instead, what did I do? Go AGAINST the cop counterclaim? Stick by my BEST townread? I know it means nothing that I'm saying this because it's theory but the argument I'm responding to is theory too.