mastin2 wrote:Let's make page twelve "Page Wall". Hiraki and chk, both hurry and get it onto this page, so that we won't have to have three pages in a row of walls!
hiplop wrote:lmao at mastin for making lists for no reason; i'm looking town despite never posting? lol
HERE'S THE PITCH.
hiplop wrote:Dont see town motivation for what hes doing, not at all. Trying to look helpful despite doing shit.
SWIIINNNNGGGGG.
Hiplop then goes onto to say how it's not helpful. Assuming makes an ass out of u and m(e)ing. We'll get there in a second, there's something better we have to look at here.
Neruz wrote:mastin2 ( 6 ) - Toon Fighter, Tomie Uzumaki, Maxous, malpascp, Phoebus,
hiplop
Numero Seis?
Numero scumo. To be fair, the devil's number is 6 and therefore scum are on the wagons as the sixth person, obv.
hiplop wrote:I'm thinking in late game. When you ISO someone, and you see things like that; it will look better, and i think he knows that.
Its really just a RV with some reasoning/weight to it.
But since you've noted it, then he can't use it. So, now there's no scum reasoning behind it unless everyone ignores this post, and doesn't look into mastin as hard as they should.
So um.
What's the point of this vote now? Not sure. Oh wait! There is none.
ouch
hiplop wrote:key word - looks.
Again, Hiplop is assuming here. He doesn't know what anyone will do at the end of the game. While it may look scummy, it doesn't mean that it is scummy in retrospective. Furthermore, by the end of the game, there should be some loose holes that will give Mastin the leeway to be targeted as scum. I doubt that anyone would bring up this as a point in that time. So why should it be a standpoint for a D1 lynch? psst. It shouldn't.
hiplop wrote:Town shouldn't have to try to look good. Thats what he is doing, hes not actually doing anything helpful. Its simply an illusion
I still consider this a slip because of grammar. However, you could make more of it by saying that hiplop has only associated Mastin's first game comments to this point.
For example, hiplop is directly incorrect in the point that Mastin has done anything helpful. This is post #75. Mastin has 18 posts by post 76. If you're saying that each and every single post that Mastin has made is useless then sure, your argument would be correct. However, this is not the case. While Mastin doesn't explain all of his reads, he does explain some. You could make the case that he's with-holding information, but have fun trying to get that lynch done. Because that's all you have at the moment.
hiplop wrote:muffin i dont see what you dont get... I explained it fine earlier, stop distracting town.
Asking questions is in no way, shape, or form distracting town. In fact, you should want to explain a bandwagon as town or scum in order to advocate your lynch. Considering that muffin did not, and still doesn't as shown in #148 which you blatantly ignore, understand it, you're either aware that your BW sucks, or unsure about Mastin. Either way, you must die for it since you haven't retracted the plausibility of Mastinscum.
ISO 9 and 10 are skippies.
Hiplop wrote:lmao what? I've never done that as scum. I type more the angrier/more interested i am, scum or town.
Are you sure you're not just making shit up?
This is a horrible reaction. Even if Paupaums rat is wrong, a simple yes or no should do. I believe that the scumtell of over-explanation works here quite well. In addition, what if he was making it up? Wouldn't that make him suitable to die?
Posts 180-182 show easily fallacies in hiplop's case due to Muffin's questioning. I advise everyone to read that, but I know that if you have even gotten this far in my wall, you must read it because you like to read and stuff. This is because .01% of mafiascum read walls in full context. Hell, I'm not even expecting hiplop to read this much. I want him to, and respond back, but the chances of that are slim to none. I digress.
Here's the new advances in the hiplop case.
Hiplop wrote:and now GI seem a slight bit scummy to me really.
Hiplop wrote:GM has me convinced
You went with someone who you just stated you had a scumread on?
hmmzorz.
Not only that, but Maxous' points have some meaning as well. To note, I don't have a definite stance on TF at the moment. From my initial skims, he looks outrageously scummy, but that in itself looks a bit odd. Tomie is still town btw. guys.
Moving on now.
Mastin wrote:Do you think Pine is scum, Hiraki?
I haven't read much on him yet, but at the moment he's one of my scummies for his little slip thing. I didn't like his explanation of it either. Hiplop is numero uno though, so don't worry.
) And I have asked plenty of questions to others--and had done so before that post. 
