Mini 1176: Dexter Season 2 (Game Over) Who Won?

[tanstalas]

After thinking about it. Why wouldn't you track BB, KKN? You thought he was scum, he claimed a role, if he visited someone that didn't die last night you could have confirmed him as town and yourself as tracker. Also you were on LMP/BB for most of the game. I am REALLY not buying this claim.

On N1 - you thought LMP was scum yet did not track him
On N2 - you believed he had a PR but did not track him to confirm

The fact you didn't track either Kise or BB either night makes me think you are lying.

[Blackberry]

I'll give KKN time to respond.

I'll also give Fargrass the opportunity to hammar if Fargrass KNOWS he is lying.

I kind of want to hammar but I'm really fearful of KKN being a real tracker and thus it being my fault if it's wrong. I keep going back and fourth, and agree it doesn't make sense not to have targetted me, at the very least, you would have been able to confirm yourself or something.

KKN's early interactions acted like he knew what a PR ability/etc. would look like...

[VP Baltar]

He's not a tracker. Amrun and Fargrass are illogical track choices to the extreme. KKN does not appear to be an illogical player.

Also, HE NEVER COUNTERCLAIMED HIND. Why would you not CC for a guaranteed scum? Tracker isn't that powerful of a role. Certainly worth dying for if you can catch a scum in the process. Feel free to hammer.

[tanstalas]

Hey KKN, place a vote on your scumbuddy now for the bus

[Blackberry]

@hin, do you have any flavor with your ability, specifically with your ability. I'm watching you, this claim seems really weird.

KKN seems to genuinely be interested in the flavor ability, etc., etc.... but if KKN was really a tracker, why would he even ask that and be interested?

...

Actually, I decided I'm going to hammar KKN because of this... although... I want to see how Fargrass responds. If I hammar now that means Fargrass doesn't have to commit on whether or not she'll fake a PR. If KKN is scum, the only person he can safely-ish accuse to track without being wrong is the scum partner, plus if we believed him, it would have guaranteed both him and farside safety from being lynched today.

...

On second thought, if KKN was scum, why would you fake-claim tracker knowing full-well that you didn't counter the tracker that claimed earlier? Or is he just not paying attention? Doing both scenarios in my head and still can't see him being a real tracker... and you just said he isn't illogical, so why fake-claim a tracker when he didn't CC the other tracker claim? ... Or is it because of what I said earlier he knew tracker was 100% the only thing I wasn't and he could claim it without me CCing it.

...

KKN I am awaiting answers.

Fargrass I am awaiting your confirmation of not going anywhere.

[VP Baltar]

I think it's that a) he was run up quick and didn't have time to put together a good fake claim and b) he's not paying much attention to the game.

[Juls]

My V/LA has just been extended from July 15-25 due to a death in the family. July 15-17 will be absolutely no access. Same for July 18-25. Bare with me please.

[tanstalas]

My V/LA has just been extended from July 15-25 due to a death in the family. July 15-17 will be absolutely no access. Same for July 18-25. Bare with me please.

Want to postpone game until the 25th Juls? I'd be fine with that. Would give KKN a chance to make a better claim

Also, very sorry for your loss. Hope it wasn't someone close

[Juls]

It was my husband's grandmother. I don't need to postpone the game. If a lynch occurs over the weekend I should be able to get a scene up Sunday night/Monday morning before taking off for my second trip. If it doesn't then I think I will be ok while in vegas. I should have internet access at the very least on my phone.

[tanstalas]

Phone posting sucks, I cant even imagine doing a VC on a phone, but if you are fine with it, whatever

[Fargrass]

Fargrass, do you confirm you didn't go anywhere last night?

I went no where last night.

This just in I'm not hammering KKN.

I watched enough Dexter to believe that claim.

fars

[Kid Know Nothing]

I really want him to answer how he knew BB was going to be safe overnight and make it until the next day if he isn't a doc. It should be a good read for the lulz.

lolwhat? Where did I ever see that? I just realized that questions applied to BB today.

@VPB; Why would I have CC'ed yesterday? I started in a less direct route; something I knew he most likely wouldn't know. If he had a flavor attached to his ability. That was a safer way for me to double check. And I claimed because I'm at L-1. How is that scummy?

[Blackberry]

Can you post something more convincing? ... Or should I just hammar you? Your lack of effort and interest/intensity is not helping...

[Kid Know Nothing]

Why should I have directly cc'ed him? If I had another method I thought was more legitimate and safer? Explain that.

[Blackberry]

You haven't commented on why you wouldn't target me or Kise, both people who claimed to have abilities.

Also, for some reason, I just realized Kise making a "no selection" really doesn't make a lot of sense to me X_x.

[Kid Know Nothing]

Because Kise

would

be visiting someone. No point in it, in my eyes. I don't care.

And at the time, I could care less about you. Day one, I tracked Amrun as a null tell read. Day Two, Fargrass didn't sit right with me at the end of the day. You redeemed LMP in my eyes. I went after someone who I thought was more scummy.

[Blackberry]

Considering I've adamently stated I'm close to hammaring you... why aren't you posting more? I'd expect your thoughts and reasons why you're not mafia, how you may or may not have hinted as your claim, and excessive reasons of who you think mafia is or "if I die here is who I think mafia is."

...

[Kid Know Nothing]

Considering I've adamently stated I'm close to hammaring you... why aren't you posting more? I'd expect your thoughts and reasons why you're not mafia, how you may or may not have hinted as your claim, and excessive reasons of who you think mafia is or "if I die here is who I think mafia is."

...

All of which I've already spoken out on.

Day Two, I came in defending Amrun in the beginning. I've been saying all day that Far is town. I talked about how unlikely the 2 shot tracker claim was. I've already said who was town and who isn't. That hasn't changed. Far, you, and me are town. Kise is third party. Possibly a traitor. The rest? That's my pool of possible scum. I've explained my reads are shot, I haven't had the time to do a proper re-read in a while.

What do you expect me to say? I'm not going to fill the thread with things I've already said just because I've claimed.

I think it's weird that VPB is calling claiming at L-1 scummy. What, do I have to wait until I'm asked? Why?

The closest thing I've done to be scummy is exactly what LMP did. Which is pretty much actively lurk. I've been attempting to keep up, I've been attempting to keep prodding and pressuring, but things fall apart sometimes. Exactly how am I scum for my claim?

[Kid Know Nothing]

When I'm lynched, focus on VPB tomorrow. How about that?

[Kid Know Nothing]

These posts are also known as; how do I defend myself against a nonexistent case?

[VP Baltar]

=========[ ]
[ ]=========

[Kid Know Nothing]

=========[ ]
[ ]=========

?

[tanstalas]

It means hammer, are you that dumb?

[Kid Know Nothing]

Hammer me. I don't want to play in this game anymore.

I remember why I stopped coming to this site. Thanks guys. gg scum.

[Kid Know Nothing]

Mod: Replace me if I'm not hammered by then