Mini 1176: Dexter Season 2 (Game Over) Who Won?

[Kid Know Nothing]

If it's google docs, change the editing settings to what you feel comfortable with and just copy and past, It think.

[Blackberry]

https://spreadsheets.google.com/spreads ... utput=html does that work X_x

[Kid Know Nothing]

Yes. Explain the colors?

[Blackberry]

Red BG means mafia voted for you... blue background means you voted a confirmed-townie... pink background means you voted a confirmed-mafia... green background means mafia voted you... I wasn't originally intending to share this so it's skewed with the assumption for yall that i'm a townie X_x

[Kid Know Nothing]

Black and green blocks?

[Blackberry]

My original intention was to actually look at the vote frequency, i.e., I thought town would most likely be sporadic, while scum would be vote switching as a consistent rate.

Black means someone voted you.

[Blackberry]

*Green means confirmed-town voted you

[VP Baltar]

We're not lynching Kise and we're not lynching DDD. Again, why do I keep having to say this. Unless we're looking at a Socio-Fargrass team, I don't see how all of BB-Tans-KKN can be town. Tans is the worst out of that group and I don't really understand why he's off the table for some people.

That being said, I'd be ok with lynch Socio today. He's made pretty much every effort to stay out of the fray today and I don't find it implausible at all that he and hind were bussing.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

The sad thing in the Tans case is that I already countered his bad "DDD was bussing yesterday" argument with a clear statement of fact and he's seen me try to set up a town alliance in the newbie game we've played before. As far as I can tell those are big objections to my play and they've already been explained away and yet apparently because I annoy him and because I haven't been subtle about my attempt to control the game he's going to throw a hissy fit. Whatever.

Doesn't Socio-scum also implicate Kise? Because Kise claimed that both Rita and Dexter were pro-town roles and if Socio flips scum then that'd be just another thing Kise was lying about and this one would be even more egregious than his other lies.

[VP Baltar]

Yeah, it does.

I mean, I'm kind of at a loss though. I can understand how both Tans and KKN look genuine in their responses to pressure. The latter more than the former, but I also don't think it's impossible for a scum to fake raging as a way to deflate their own wagon.

I feel like BB is being genuine about his scum hunting as well, but that could be fake.

Fargrass has the sotty attack, but that could have just been a bastardly thing to do that has nothing to do with alignment.

I'm 99% certain DDD is town just from how he's played this game. I'm not gonna second guess myself because that is where I get into stupid trouble. I really wish AGM was here because as much as I had a town read on Sotty, she's smart enough to fool me. On the other hand, I don't see her as a quitter when she takes scum either. Her frustration was definitely real, which I think was a town tell in that case.

Kise is a liar liar pants on fire and I still don't think he's being genuine about his role. I do think there are more pertinent matters at hand though.

So, I guess that leaves me with a huge ball of wifom. Looking at the above and me talking through my thoughts, it seems to me like maybe Fargrass or Tans are the best lynches at this juncture.

[Kid Know Nothing]

I'm willing to get behind Socio or Tans. Still think Fars has less of a chance of being scum based on my result.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

I wasn't pointing that out as a reason we shouldn't lynch Socio, in fact that might be a benefit, VPB just noting that fact. While I still have objections to KKN's claim it makes more sense to let scum kill him it it's a legitimate claim or make him prove it with results tonight given he can't just track "null reads" tonight and expect us to believe that fact. I'll back a Tans or Socio lynch.

UNVOTE:

[tanstalas]

First off, I'd like to apologize to Juls and everyone else for my drunken rage posting last night.

I really don't think we should lynch Socio today. Kise can visit Socio, KKN can track Kise. Kill 3 birds with one stone. If Socio doesn't die KKN can confirm them, unless those 3 are scum together, or KKN dies. If KKN dies then I'd think that a kise/socio team is possible.

Fargrass or myself would be the best lynch today, leading into tonight.

Vote: Fargrass

[Kid Know Nothing]

First off, I'd like to apologize to Juls and everyone else for my drunken rage posting last night.

I really don't think we should lynch Socio today. Kise can visit Socio, KKN can track Kise. Kill 3 birds with one stone. If Socio doesn't die KKN can confirm them, unless those 3 are scum together, or KKN dies. If KKN dies then I'd think that a kise/socio team is possible.

Fargrass or myself would be the best lynch today, leading into tonight.

Vote: Fargrass

4 Man scum team? Seems a bit much. Then again, meta's probably changed.

That said, I have reservations about tracking Kise. He's a known liar and if he no visits like I mentioned earlier, nothing changes tomorrow. I can either track BB or Kise. I feel like BB would be safer for me to confirm myself to the town, plus that would allow me to clear BB as well. Kise seems like a risk.

[tanstalas]

I meant, unless those 3 are scum together in a facetious way.

[tanstalas]

If Kise doesn't visit someone, and you say he doesn't and he says he does we have scum between the two of you guaranteed

[VP Baltar]

I think tracking BB, myself or DDD are all good choices. I agree that Kise is a liar and a waste of night action.

Tans, if you're town, why on earth would you think you're a good lynch? What information do you think would come out of that at this point?

[tanstalas]

Only for the reason that whoever gets lynched today flips town I will probably be next anyhow.

If we flip Fargrass-scum though, that should be enough to hopefully convince you all I am town.

[Fargrass]

First off, I'd like to apologize to Juls and everyone else for my drunken rage posting last night.

I really don't think we should lynch Socio today. Kise can visit Socio, KKN can track Kise. Kill 3 birds with one stone. If Socio doesn't die KKN can confirm them, unless those 3 are scum together, or KKN dies. If KKN dies then I'd think that a kise/socio team is possible.

Fargrass or myself would be the best lynch today, leading into tonight.

Vote: Fargrass

Well if you say so

unvote
vote Tans

Don't attempt to build your ethos and then pass the buck. If you think you are one of the 2 best lynches then vote yourself.

[Fargrass]

GRass

[VP Baltar]

Socio, you got anything to say about anything?

[VP Baltar]

Kise, given your role PM and everything that's been said in thread today, which of the following scenarios do you think is most likely:

Rita-town, Dexter-scum
Rita-scum, Dexter-town
Rita-town, Dexter-town

[tanstalas]

I still think it's DDD and KKN. Noone will vote for DDD, and KKN seems to have gotten a free pass today.

Also don't like people claiming trackers and DDD's reaction to them claiming said role "Oh yeah that fits with how he's played" or "Yeah that fits with the name/character"

If I claim tracker can I get a free pass as well? TBQH - I was thinking of fake claiming hider, since I am a little kid and I can hide in small places. With the ability name "Hide and Seek" since that's a game kids play.

However, KKN's his can be proven, and if he is a tracker he will most likely die tonight by scum, unless they target BB.

KKN - Don't tell us who you are going to track, just so in case you are scum and say BB dies tomorrow you don't go "Oh I was watching VPB"

Also, VPB, why would you be a good person to track, did you just softclaim a PR as well? People really need to stop doing this

Anyhow

VPB-Town
DDD-Town via VPB
BB-Town
KKN-Scum we are letting live
Kise-Will hopefully prove his role tonight
Socio-Needed to be left alone for Kise to prove role
AGM-Town via interactions with dead people
Myself-Town

Fargrass - only person I am left with

Unvote:
Vote: Fargrass

[VP Baltar]

not comping to anything PR related. Just being sure I was fair and no one can say I was trying to be shady and direct the tracker away from me or something.

Also, wtf, why would you fake claim hider?

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Also don't like people claiming trackers and DDD's reaction to them claiming said role "Oh yeah that fits with how he's played" or "Yeah that fits with the name/character"

To be ironic

his role and flavor does fit the character. Also, this is my vote not moving.

You're not even trying any more are you?