ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[Lost Butterfly]

You should full-claim and point to breadcrums as far as I'm concerned.

Also this, yeah.

Also there's one aspect of the seven left, right?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Magua was definitely among AGM's suspicions, but AGM didn't push Magua particularly hard. AGM did put up a "Who wants whom shot?"-count at a point Magua was leading the vote (a feature the count wouldn't've had if he had counted me as an opponent of the Maguakill).

We've had 6 aspect claims so far, which leaves one, yes.

[Faraday]

7th aspect should also claim so we can get a better idea of the set-up. And stuff.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

And to rapture away all the townies and induce the Great Tribulation.

[Nexus]

Has the Stranger been claimed yet?

[Empking]

You should full-claim and point to breadcrums as far as I'm concerned.

Watcher but I don't crumb. (Though I've probably got a post where I have a capital C and capital W )

N1 - LB - Nobody
N2 - DGB - Nobody
N3 - SpyreX - Nobody
N4 - LB - Nobody

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Why Spy?

[Empking]

Why Spy?

He looked like a good recruit target.

[Magua]

Was AGM pushing for Magua to be shot?

Just wondering as I don't remember it. Not that I think recruiting the person pushing you as CR is especially good play actually, or at least it's not how I'd play cult recruiter but i'm just curious.

If you're curious, how about you go look for yourself?

In other news:

VOTE: Benmage

[Lost Butterfly]

Asking someone else is much easier though.

[Lost Butterfly]

Empking why didn't you watch Thor/locke Night 3 after they'd been cleared of being cult and thus probable recruits?

[Empking]

Empking why didn't you watch Thor/locke Night 3 after they'd been cleared of being cult and thus probable recruits?

To be honest I hadn't fully digested the mess that was the end of D3 until the beginning of D4.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Spy still strikes me as a weird choice; there's a reason he claimed yesterday.

Talk to me about your thought process regarding your N4 choice.

[Empking]

N4 to me looked like the best by miles as a cult target.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Quite possibly LB was the best recruit option, but the kill was far more predictable, I would think.

[Empking]

Quite possibly LB was the best recruit option, but the kill was far more predictable, I would think.

But the cult is more dangerous. I also disagree on the kill being more obvious. If he wasn't killed last night then he'd probably been killed today.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Mafia want the recruiter dead as much as we do. I'm not sure if AGM would've been the better watch, but it has to be part of the conversation.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Not to mention that even if you catch the recruiter, you still have a credibility problem.

[Empking]

Not to mention that even if you catch the recruiter, you still have a credibility problem.

If I catch a Mafioso I still have a credibility problem.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Not if AGM had been the recruiter. The mafioso also wouldn't've had to be lynched that day, which makes it less of a pressing issue.

[Magua]

@Lost Butterfly:

Benmage-town, yes/no?

[Lost Butterfly]

Good chance he was recruited last night, I'd say.

[SpyreX]

Are you unrecruitable? That'll shed light on more than a few things.

Watcher if real is up for grabs but I'd lean town.
Watcher if a fakeclaim makes far more sense for scum than cult.

[Lost Butterfly]

Emp's probably scumscum as opposed to cultscum if he's scum. Could be a mafia watcher. Not sure how that'd work balance wise, what with town having jailer + 2 vigs to combat the mafia.

I actually thought he was a tracker who tracked Benmage, hence the about turn on the claim, but this makes sense too. Think I buy that he's a watcher at least, and thus not the CL.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Why do you buy that he's a watcher? It's an easy enough fake claim.