New York 134: Planet of Hats (Scum Win!)

[bvoigt]

Is that a serious claim?

[Celebloki]

Prod dodge/Waiting to hear more from Thor and what NS did last night before I go further with a Vote.

[Thor665]

@bvoigt - yes.

[bvoigt]

I believe the general play for a claimed SK is to direct their kills, and lynch them if they don't comply. Right?

[Thor665]

I dunno - what do you think we ought to do? I'm really bad at this SK business.

[bvoigt]

(shrug)

[Auckmid]

Claim: "SK"

I don't get it. Why are you telling us this?

[DrippingGoofball]

I dunno - what do you think we ought to do? I'm really bad at this SK business.

just wow

[DrippingGoofball]

I feel so sorry for you I actually want to let you live to end game and win.

I value honesty.

[xRECKONERx]

...

Vote: Thor

You are anti-town. We lynch you. I don't care how "helpful" you say you're going to be -- you don't have town's best interest in mind.

[Parabollocks]

Vote: Thor

You're not town.

therefore, you're not town.

[Parabollocks]

I believe the general play for a claimed SK is to direct their kills, and lynch them if they don't comply. Right?

>impying a claimed SK is going to live to see the next day

Thor just set himself up on a death wish, quite ilterally.

[Parabollocks]

21. SleepyKrew

15. NobodySpecial

16. Thor665

12. PeregrineV

My point of interests right now.

Son of a bitch, two of those are scum.

i even amaze myself sometimes.

Hey NS, tell me we're getting the magic number 3 and you investigated PeregrineV.

[xRECKONERx]

Protip: NS is probably scum.

OH GUYS THERE ARE TWO COPS IN THE SETUP
OH HEY I JUST SO HAPPENED TO GET A GUILTY ON MY PARTNER (lol worthless goon) AND SAVED MY ASS
NAOW I LURK

[Parabollocks]

Hmm.

Let's have thor shoot NS, then.

Hey thor, shoot NS, it's your only lifeline.

[Thor665]

You guys are hilarious.

I'll still finish my full claim after NS says what happened to him last night.

@Para - so do you want to lynch the "claimed SK" or do you want a pet SK who will shoot people you want dead? I'm confused.

[chkballin]

Realistically I see no point in lynching Thor JUST because he's the Serial Killer, why not let scum deal with him? He's a threat to them too since he just wants to kill everyone. I mean I am all for him helping us and if something doesn't go exactly how it should we immediately lynch him. At least he's out in the open we can lynch him at any time.

~

BALLIN

[Parabollocks]

@Thor

shoot NS, then we'll deal with you later.

unvote

[Nobody Special]

I investigated Palisade last night. Palisade is Innocent, therefore I believe his claim.

I chose Pali because of the interesting interactions between them and Sleepy yesterday.

Thor, got any finished games as SK?

[Thor665]

@NS

I suspect I probably do have a finished SK game.

Why were you looking for "interactions" with someone who had to either be an SK or a Vig? Did you think he was scum with an additional kill power or something?

Full Claim

Single Shot Vig.

Night 1 - Jilly (roleblocked...whew!)
Night 2 - JDGA

Basically at this stage the "roleblocker" is a messed up mystery because they didn't touch either NS or Palisade on Night 2 - which suggests they're pro-town. However somebody gakked up Pally's kill last night, which suggests anti-town.
There should theoretically be a roleblocker who wasn't on me, Palisade, or chkballin' who ought to have a confirmed scum.

If what we have is a doctor...than the doc doesn't need to claim but...that means the roleblocker who was on me Night 1 (an anti-town block in my personal opinion...unless JKer?) decided not to touch a claimed cop or Vig but then later did block a 'confirmed' Vig.
I claimed "SK" in quotes just to make Reck stop sweating an SK hunt that wasn't viable, I didn't expect the SK blowup but decided to ride with it for fun to see who would freak out. I'm not sure what to make of the reactions (because I've never tried to openly claim SK before) but my vague gut says Para and Reck look worse for it, because most people seemed more confused by the claim (and why wouldn't they be) while the two of them decided lynching was in order and Para even then went into lynching plus a need to kill NS for some reason. Meh, I'd be happy to hear other thoughts on that reaction fish if anyone has them.

[xRECKONERx]

ITT I look bad for wanting to lynch a claimed SK, cool

Unvote

I don't know why you didn't just fullclaim from the start but okay

[Thor665]

I wanted to see NS's claim prior to me claiming a RBer existed and also my presebce as a 'safe' guilty claim. Him confirming the other Vig after that is a bit neutralish in my eyes but I'm still leaning town on him which makes Pally town too, which I can work with.

Is there a reason you shouldn't look bad?

[DrippingGoofball]

Realistically I see no point in lynching Thor JUST because he's the Serial Killer, why not let scum deal with him? He's a threat to them too since he just wants to kill everyone. I mean I am all for him helping us and if something doesn't go exactly how it should we immediately lynch him. At least he's out in the open we can lynch him at any time.

~

BALLIN

Chkballin is now CONFIRMED TOWN.

[Nobody Special]

I don't see how. WIFOM, etc.

He isn't "confirmed" town until I investigate him.

[Celebloki]

I honestly don't see how that makes chkballin confirmed town. Having a one shot NKer around can be helpful to scum if it misses and at any point chkballin can push for Thor's lynch or kill him themselves. I don't see how them not being on his lynch wagon confirms them.