Mini 1194: Reverse Mafia [Game Over]

[kiwieagle]

No, but you just claimed that you don't give a damn about who's revived as long as they're not the PR that's (according to my theory) the most dangerous to scum.

Bobsnox is a double edged sword.

[Packbat]

No, but you just claimed that you don't give a damn about who's revived as long as they're not the PR that's (according to my theory) the most dangerous to scum.

Bobsnox is a double edged sword.

At best.

[StrangerCoug]

SC's posts seemed good at first, but I realized what game he's playing - he's trying to appeal to Pack's good side because he knows Pack's town and Bub's scum, and Pack is the most likely of the three living players to vote Bub. Lots of subtle stuff, but I think he's been getting what he wants and he knows it; the problem is that his attempts are just a bit too transparent.

While I've been viewing Packbat more favorably than I did at the start of the day, I fail to see how I've been trying to get on his good side; if anything, he got on mine after bobsnox's claim as I don't see how he responded to it as bussing.

I'm for reviving ToastyToast. For Slaxx to be scum it would have made the best sense for him to revive another scumbuddy for the win. The game's still running, so I'm in agreement that ToastyToast townslipped.

UNVOTE: Bub Bidderskins
VOTE: ToastyToast

Just keep bobsnox and whichever of malpaspc and kiwieagle it happens to be in limbo and we've got it.

[malpascp]

Hum...
I'm pretty sure you can't vote.

If anyone has questions to make me, do them, please.

[Pomegranate]

I'm for reviving ToastyToast. For Slaxx to be scum it would have made the best sense for him to revive another scumbuddy for the win. The game's still running, so I'm in agreement that ToastyToast townslipped.

UNVOTE: Bub Bidderskins
VOTE: ToastyToast

Just keep bobsnox and whichever of malpaspc and kiwieagle it happens to be in limbo and we've got it.

This might matter if you

had

a vote.

[MrTrow]

About Toasty`s 'townslip'

#284/285: slaxx: gg-gambit (while toasty wat the most likely candidate for revival)

#293-301: slaxx: 'gg-gambit was intended to draw a towntell out of toasty, didn`t work so who to revive'

#304: toast: 'didn`t see the gambit/busy' excuse (given the 15 minutes the gambit lasted credible) + a defence on why he wouldn`t fall for it anyway

#309-315: (probably) final part of the reason for the revival of crypto (+announcement of decision being final)
#329: toast: disapointed about not being revived?

I can see the scum motivation in that post.

[Pomegranate]

Also, I agree that Toasty is defininitely town.

[malpascp]

Also, I agree that Toasty is defininitely town.

I don't. All the townslip thing is WIFOM. We don't use the word "definitively" on mafia (at least I try not to).

[Parama]

Hey look who the people trying to discredit the townslip are - the ones I find scummy! WOOP WOOP.

[bobsnox]

scumteam of bobsnox and kiwieagle = 0% probability SC

[StrangerCoug]

I'm for reviving ToastyToast. For Slaxx to be scum it would have made the best sense for him to revive another scumbuddy for the win. The game's still running, so I'm in agreement that ToastyToast townslipped.

UNVOTE: Bub Bidderskins
VOTE: ToastyToast

Just keep bobsnox and whichever of malpaspc and kiwieagle it happens to be in limbo and we've got it.

This might matter if you

had

a vote.

Oh, that's right.

scumteam of bobsnox and kiwieagle = 0% probability SC

Says the person who is clearly partial about his alignment.

[malpascp]

Hey look who the people trying to discredit the townslip are - the ones I find scummy! WOOP WOOP.

Did SC, Bub, kiwi and MrTrow all disagree you?

And there was noone you didn't say was scummy disagree you?

Besides, I don't think there are 5 scum in this game.

Also, I can't discredit something that has no credit at all. That post reveals absolutely nothing about anything at all. Whoever disagrees, show me logic, and not the bullshit I've seen so far. "Amen, Parama, Amén Parama"-style is not townish, just because Parama was pseudo-conftown on D1.

Yeah, I remember that. What happened to everyone saying "Parama is absolutely town" like in D1? I was the first one to question that, but there wasn't a single comment on my statement. Now, everyone talks about Parama's possible scumbuddies and so on.

@bobsnox: don't do that. I mean, if you reasoned it, it would be sort of OK.

[Parama]

You're reversing the question. The people I see denying the townslip are people I find scummy; I never said all the people I find scummy are all denying the townslip.

[ToastyToast]

A slip of any kind can be WIFOM, malpascp.

I don't really know how I'm supposed to comment on this other than that I thought a scum revive would immediately end the game.

@mal: he didn't say ALL scum are trying to discredit his point. He said ALL those trying to discredit his point were on his scum-list. Its a big difference.

Pretty sure suspicion on both Packbat and Crypto is higher than suspicion on Parama.

[malpascp]

I asked both things guys. Question not reversed: I made it and added another one.

@Toasty: people can suspect whoever they want.

Either way, it's cool to see another "reversed question" answered. Is Toasty agreeing with Parama?

[ToastyToast]

I'm agreeing that you completely misinterpreted Parama's statement. Anyone who's not oblivious can see that.

[bobsnox]

@bobsnox: don't do that. I mean, if you reasoned it, it would be sort of OK.

it is not scum v scum

[malpascp]

What Parama's statement? He can make all the connections to the townslip he wants, but I really think it is null-tell. Maybe all this crap was only intended to sink Toasty's image, by associating him to Parama, that is already alive. But after all, everyone agreeded Parama, what works well for Parama anyway.

[Parama]

malp shut up you're wasting everyone's time

[ToastyToast]

Hey look who the people trying to discredit the townslip are - the ones I find scummy! WOOP WOOP.

....wtf mal. Parama said this. You said

Did SC, Bub, kiwi and MrTrow all disagree you?
And there was noone you didn't say was scummy disagree you?
Besides, I don't think there are 5 scum in this game.

and I posted this at the same time Parama posted the exact same thing.

@mal: he didn't say ALL scum are trying to discredit his point. He said ALL those trying to discredit his point were on his scum-list. Its a big difference.

Its basic fucking progression. What else would I be talking about? What else would I be

Is Toasty agreeing with Parama?

agreeing about.

[Packbat]

Mod: can we get another prod on crypto?

[MrTrow]

of course he considers people who disagree with him scummy

This entire 'you can either sheep me or be scum' attitude really doesn`t sit well with me.
The reason i wasn`t all over this from the start, i because i believe it to be more indicative of personality than allignment.

[malpascp]

I meant that Toasty is agreeing with Parama about his own towntell.

[ToastyToast]

I meant that Toasty is agreeing with Parama about his own towntell.

Wouldn't you have a bias if someone else said you made a townslip? I mean, I know my allignment...I guess you can say that I didn't really think anything of it until Parama pointed it out, but its the players--not me--who should decide whether it is actually a town slip.

[malpascp]

I wouldn't say "yeah, I didn't know the win-cons, so I must be town". That only makes it even WIFOMier