Mini 1195: The Beehive Mystery (GAME OVER)

[subgenius]

Nah, scummy is scummy. If you've seen scum do something several times and never seen town do it, then it might be scummy, but if you've never seen anyone do it, that doesn't make it scummy.

[ICEninja]

Llama, the hammer in itself wasn't all that scummy. The fact is you had scum reads and did absolutely zero, nothing at all, to push towards their lynch is quite scummy.

ICE played a game with foilist once.

Foilist is on my list of "will not play with" players. If Ivan is indeed Foilist, I understand why I hate everything he says.

Dead town gets pretty much totally ignored so I feel like I'd be spending a lot of time for nothing.

Should you flip town, rest (in peace) assured that I will not ignore your thoughts on currently living players.

An Llmarble lynch is unacceptable. We will be looking very carefully at everybody on that wagon if the lynch goes through. You all need to flashwagon subgenius for a mafia lynch.

Threat noted.

Can we lynch Llama now? We're too close to the deadline to lynch sub. It isn't happening.

[Beck]

Well, I can't wait forever marble. You promise a case and I've been waiting and waiting

vote: marble

[Magic Trainer]

It's 1 AM in the morning.

I'll hammer when I wake up.

[Llamarble]

Bah. Life interfered. Hopefully you all can win this thing without me and make me not feel so bad about flakiness.
At this point my only hope of making it to tomorrow is to no lynch, which while better for town than lynching me has the drawback of being unacceptable to everyone ever.
I do promise EXTREME USEFUL CONTENT AND SCUMLYNCHES if allowed to live another game day, for what it's worth.

[Tommy]

Don't believe you for a second. You can't even manage useful content now, when your life depends on it.

[Captain Spoon]

marble?

you're going for him?

what about the SK/kool reps? I'm sure there's a scum in that pair.

My past experience with marble says he's town. Town marble is cryptic and lazy, but a great asset to the town when he actually makes a case

I think we should leave him alive and if we don't get golden cases and ISos from him tommorow he can face the gallows

either way, i don't think marble should go today. There are better candidates

[Captain Spoon]

Hey marble, which votes on you do you find the scummiest?

[Tommy]

either way, i don't think marble should go today. There are better candidates

Think you might have left it a bit late there, Captain. You have eleven hours to prepare a case against someone and organise a flashmob.

[Captain Spoon]

I blame CC

i told him i Was v/la

I really need a votecount right now

catching up to see who's been exploiting this marble wagon

[Tommy]

Here's an unofficial one:

Subgenius (3)- Ivan the Pleasant, Magic Trainer, Llamarble,
Giitah (2)- Captain Spoon, rblinker123,
Llamarble (5) - Scott Brosius, Tommy, ICEninja, Subgenius, Beck

And Magic Trainer's promised a hammer when he wakes up. Which I guess will be in four hours or so.

[Captain Spoon]

Quick question: is marble the only one here with a suspicion on tommy? I feel he could be a dark horse candidate. Not sure

An Llmarble lynch is unacceptable. We will be looking very carefully at everybody on that wagon if the lynch goes through. You all need to flashwagon subgenius for a mafia lynch.

agrees with first part but not second

K, this gitah fellow is odd

I thought I'd heard the name twistedspoon before and initially read him off as being a fool but he's shown himself to be reasonably town in his posts. Solid town read.

some nerve you have
I'll have you know I'm nominated for 2 scummy awards. I am no fool. This game has just been awkward for me

I appreciate that he made reads though.

Magic boy is a wildcard. I don't feel I can analyse him well. Leaning town from flakey anon though

Scott seems good enough once you overlook the marble obession (who I'm sure will be flipping town. Scum marble would do as he promised and have cases by now; he has most to lose. And meta and gut arguments)

Tommy is suspect. I'll VCA him sometime

NInjas: Thanks tommy. Seeing as Sub is the only other wagon and he's a weaker town read than Marble, I'll go down that route. I think he might be town, but not as much as I think for marble

Reluctant vote: Sub

@Magic trainer: are any of your suspects on the marble wagon? If so do you still think it makes sense to hammer then? I feel as though marble is myslynch fodder and scum have pushed to get his lynch

[Captain Spoon]

I'm going to skim back to the start of D2 and see how this marble wagon occured

I feel sure that it would have been started by scum. Marble was such an easy target after his hammer

No-hammers pls

[Captain Spoon]

Tommy not being on the Acro wagon goes to his credit, but on the flipside he voted no-one D1.
why was this?

[Tommy]

As I've explained before, I was ready to vote Acronach, but I was waiting to get some content from Greymarble first. I didn't want to go into the night without a read on every player. As it turned out, Greymarble hammered before I got a chance to vote.

[Captain Spoon]

okay, I feel like originall scum tried to push a jilly wagon D2

that failed for some reason so they started to push marble

If marble flips scum, Ivan needs a real check over, but I strongly doubt he will
I expect scum ivan to be on Marble town right now. Ivan isn't so I conclude ivan town if marble town.

D1 tommy was super conservative with his vote. Now that Myslynches are everywhere you turn your head today; Marble, Ivan, the vote has been going much more. Not sure what to think

ICE i have difficulty reading. marble seems to have a scumread on him. Can you elaborate pls?

I'll try to get something on Tommy tommorow. After reviewing again, there are some parts of Sub I don't like, but some parts I do. Tommy+sub is possible. Tommy has been pro-sub. But I lack evidence today

I'll be V/la from monday for 2 weeks, so It's CC's fault if you hear nothing D3 :p

In conclusion I'll accept a Sub lynch. The cases on him are somewhat flimsy, but My gut strongly argues against marble

[Tommy]

D1 tommy was super conservative with his vote. Now that Myslynches are everywhere you turn your head today; Marble, Ivan, the vote has been going much more. Not sure what to think

Well, today I know more about the players. I'm more comfortable lynching when I have a strong scum read.

[Twistedspoon]

imho, I suspect you because I feel the players you have voted are myslynches; Ivan and Marble. They have clear cut cases on them; Marble's self preservation hammer (which I've seen town do before but I forget where) and Ivan's daft play (which isn't a scumtell even if most of it is completely bizzare. If anything, scum want to try and fit in. Ivan is most certainly not doing so. See my case on Ivan for more info)
If you are scum, you've played well though because some of D1 stuff looks like good questioning and scumhunting, but not beyond what I'd expect from capable mafiosi.
You're not today's lynch at any rate

[Beck]

unvote

want to hear CS's reads

MARBLE POST YOUR CASE ON SUB NAO!!!

also CS, I have been suspect of Tommy too, his play is quite odd and it is mostly gut

[Tommy]

Llamarble seems to have given up in post 1079. I don't think you'll get a case out of him.

Spoon provided his reads in post 1090.

[Twistedspoon]

want to hear CS's reads

Ivan, marble, Beck, possibly magic, blinker on gut : probtown
sub : leaning town (could just be very good scum)
scott, Tommy, Ice : unsure

Giitah seems townish, even though SK really pinged my scumdar

[Beck]

So CS is now just TS?


This game is annoying

Can we just lynch me do I don't have to be confused anymore?

[Twistedspoon]

So CS is now just TS?

no

I go V/la from monday, so CC has to post :p

[Tommy]

Can you stop posting from the wrong account?

[Captain Spoon]

K