malpascp wrote:@Magua:Can you tell me why is that?
You're trying. Your reads seem reasonable not particularly forced. Your overall tone is rational.
But then you have this vote for LLD that seems left field. Your only other mention of her is that you think she could be in a scumteam with SK, but you've got a townread on SK. Nothing about LLD being scummy on her own or other reasons for the vote. That part seems forced and reads off.
I *really* don't like Sigma asking what's scummy about criticizing someone without voting them, and then when I answer, his response is literally "WIFOM". Looking back, this just looks worse in correspondence with his answer to Magna on newb slips: "WIFOM, WIFOM, WIFOM"
Re: LLD and voting block. I'm happy for both you and Magna to sheep me. That is totally agreeable. =)
MagnaofIllusion wrote:1. So you are saying that verydark is Town because he care? So scum, inherently don’t care?
Newbs are a lot more transparent with their intent than experienced players. I don't feel that verydark is being duplicitous with what he's saying; it rings as sincere.
MagnaofIllusion wrote:
2. I’d like you to assess your standards as to what constitutes a “newb”
Jungle Republic was also cjdrum's *at least* 5th game (it's the fifth listed on his wiki, but I know for a fact he was also in Open 295 which isn't listed because he replaced out). And cjdrum is a very active and prolific poster. Length of time alone just doesn't cut it.