Newbie 1120 - The Scum in Sherlock (Over!)

[hiplop]

mainly due to being hundreds of miles away from you

50/50 is a pretty fucking good place, add in my RAGE towards hellhound and i think weve won tbh

[hiplop]

SH if youhad to guess right now; whos scum?

[Thor665]

Torq iso - two heavy pushes on Awesoma.

Only other votes were one on me and one on DK.
Really like current vote.
Would consider hiplop lynch over Muffin tomorrow probably.

[Thor665]

Awesoma=Muffin.

[zMuffinMan]

Right. Well, I am still pretty sure hiplop is town, although the whole Albert-knowing-shah-is-lying-without-even-considering-hiplop is a bit weird. I'll chalk that up to him not thinking it through properly, it was a fake-claim after all. And the rest of hiplop's play reads as town, anyway.

Thor has a beard. And he looks really, really town.

I need to go back over hellhound, but I'm pretty sure it's him.

[Scumhunter]

Quick opinion without really rereading.

Hellhound is most likely scum.
Hiplop possibly 2nd most likely?

Take my opinion with a grain of salt this game as I have been far off.

Also, assuming we lynch hellhound and the game doesn't end. Hiplop can do one of two things.

1. Jail me and have me choose between Thor/zMuffin on 3 way.
2. Jail someone Thor/zMuffin. If I were to die, it would come to a showdown between hiplop + someone else.

Not really sure which is best. Regardless I want to win the game today. So..hmm. Hellhound makes the most sense. What I don't understand is if hellhound is scum, why didn't he jump on the hiplop wagon with me yesterday to try and save Albert. In fact, why did NO ONE jump on the hiplop wagon with me to try and save Albert. Hmmm....could be that hiplop is in fact the scumlord among us -____-

I am due for a reread in this game.

[Hellhound1]

Would anyone care to elaborate on why you think its me...?
I go from "pretty much sure he's town" to everyone saying I'm scum overnight, and nobody gives a reason. How about someone justifies it other than all this rubbish? Thanks

[Hellhound1]

What I don't understand is if hellhound is scum, why didn't he jump on the hiplop wagon with me yesterday to try and save Albert. In fact, why did NO ONE jump on the hiplop wagon with me to try and save Albert. Hmmm....could be that hiplop is in fact the scumlord among us -____-

Well hurr durr maybe it's because I'm not scum? Once again hiplop blindly pushes towards lynching me with no reason and no evidence.

[Thor665]

@Hellhound.

Scumhunter is confirmed town.
I am practically confirmed town.
Hiplop is claimed JKer and is...probably not scum.

That leaves you and Awesoma/Muffin, and I have a better town read on Awesomuffin. That's why you're scum.

Who do you think is scum?

[Thor665]

@Scumhunter - we're not JKing you tonight - no way, no how. That's a terrible plan. We JK someone else and force scum to confirm another town. I'd suggest a Muffin JK, quite frankly. But whichever of he/Hellhound are not lynched, that one is being jailed.

[Scumhunter]

JKing me/JKing someone else ...either way results in 3 way lylo with a clear either way....

Hellhound, who do you suspect?

[Hellhound1]

Right, well I'm kind of stuck on my phone until tonight, but ill try anyway.

A) no doubt scumhunter is town.
but that doesn't stop hiplop being scum, seeing as scum can pretend to do that job. Theres nothing stopping hiplop saying ill jk someone, then kill someone else, knowing it'll make him look town.

Your better town read on muffin, look at #788
Also look at what you said shortly after that about hiplop/Albert. Alberts gone, and was scum, you call me town, and overnight you switch me round with hiplop.


Also @ your latest post: I was happy with being jk'd last night, but it wouldn't play to hiplops scum plan to confirm me town. So he gets the doc out the way who can disprove him, fakes a pr claim and then today starts the process to lynch me, again.

So yeah i think its a very well played game by hiplop.

[Hellhound1]

Btw they were directed at Thor.

[Hellhound1]

JKing me/JKing someone else ...either way results in 3 way lylo with a clear either way....

Hellhound, who do you suspect?

I think its most likely hiplop or muffin.

[Thor665]

@Hellhound - there was no Doc - that was a scum fakeclaim. You do continue to fling town tells from your pores which is messing with my soul though.

JKing me/JKing someone else ...either way results in 3 way lylo with a clear either way....

Remember earlier, when you announced how bad of a game you were playing?
You're confirmed town, huzzah.
I'd rather have confirmed town me or Muffin end up in lylo though - we're both full of ourselves and have confidence in our reads and are less likely to listen to...well, anyone but ourselves Waaaay better than doubting sel milquetoast town, yeah?

[zMuffinMan]

meh, I think it's Hellhound. Had a quick read over his D2 posts and he makes the most sense.

[zMuffinMan]

If Hellhound is town, I'm about 99% sure that jailing Thor or myself will result in no NK. Thor won't kill if I'm jailed, and neither will Hiplop.

But, I think that's unnecessary paranoia. It's most likely Hellhound.

VOTE: Hellhound

[Hellhound1]

Ok. Ive said it before and ill say it again, I'm a VT. I thought this game was about logic, infact it seems to be most of you guys blindly buddying eachother.
For the record, VOTE: Hiplop.
Enjoy losing because of fail play and bullshit.
Also, out of interest, care to say how my D2 posts say anything about me bring scum? Oh right they don't, just brings you potentially one step further to your scum win.
I cant decide if its you or hiplop now :/

[Hellhound1]

Thor, never said anything about a doc O.o
You do realise its possible to have just the 1 PR yeah?

[zMuffinMan]

It was your reactions to Hiplop's claims and your arguments with him. He came off looking town, you came off looking scum. I was around post #500, so like.... p21.

It's not me.

I don't think it's Hiplop. He really, really reads as town.

Thor's making a big deal out of how he's "practically confirmed town", which is a load of bullshit, but whatever, he has a beard, he can get away with saying that and I think he's probably town anyway.

It's you by PoE.

You do realise its possible to have just the 1 PR yeah?

Yes, this would be like my 10th game in this setup. I know how it works. I still believe Hiplop's claim.

[Hellhound1]

I was addressing Thor actually, in reply to his doc thing.
Yes i, who had a valid argument came off looking scummier than someone who threw a OMGUS tantrum. Nice reading, well done.

[zMuffinMan]

Yeah, because his omgus tantrum looked genuine.

[zMuffinMan]

Go back and read p20 onwards from the perspective hiplop is scum, then from the perspective hiplop really is the JK. Tell me what you think is more likely and why.

[Hellhound1]

Mmm k i have 20 minutes till work so err.. If you take me off L1 i might actually have a chance to do so when i get home.
And i will explain fully, quotes and all, my logic.

[Hellhound1]

also omgus is never genuine, especially when he couldn't answer any of mu questions, if you go back and read it.